Meridian Freight, by contrast, was a name on letterhead and a tower downtown — ten times Brightline's size, with lawyers who billed by the tenth of an hour and a representative named Marcus Webb whose smile, in the one preliminary session Paula had attended, never quite reached his eyes. Paula didn't dislike Meridian. She didn't think about them at all, most days. She thought about the records, which were hers to get right.
That was the part she carried into Tuesday: not just the exhibits, but the faces. The records would do the arguing. The faces were why the arguing mattered.
She opened the exhibit folder on her desktop and began, again, at the beginning.
Chapter 3: Tuesday, Nine A.M.
The hearing was Tuesday at nine a.m., by video, and Paula had been preparing for it the way she prepared for everything: in layers.
The arbitrator was Victor Lang, sixty years old, a retired judge with a reputation for patience and a distaste for theatrics. Paula had read three of his past decisions, which were public, and had taken notes in the margins the way Lucia took notes on novels for English class. Lang liked chronology. Lang liked documents more than speeches. Lang had once written, in a decision Paula had underlined twice, that a credible record beats a confident witness. Paula had built her entire preparation around that sentence.
By Friday afternoon, her exhibits were done: forty-one exhibits, each numbered, each with a one-line description, each cross-referenced to the master timeline she had built in a spreadsheet with eleven tabs. She had backed everything up twice — once to the external drive in the desk drawer, once to the encrypted cloud folder — because once was hope and twice was a plan. That was something her father used to say about spare tires, and Paula had adopted it for her whole professional life.
She printed the hearing notice, too, on paper, and slipped it into the folder by her desk. Lucia had teased her about it once — "Mom, it's in your email, it's in your calendar, it's tattooed on your brain" — but Paula had only said, "Paper doesn't need a password," and Lucia, to her credit, had never teased her about it again.
Friday evening, Daniel came home hoarse and happy — the team had won, 21-14, on a fourth-quarter drive he described at the dinner table with salt shakers for players — and they ate late, all three of them, and nobody talked about Tuesday. Lucia had a physics test Monday she was pretending not to worry about. Daniel had film to review. Paula had forty-one exhibits and a printed notice and two backups, and the deep, settled feeling of a person whose preparation was complete.
On Saturday morning she rehearsed her testimony aloud in the home office, the way she always did, with the door closed and the headset on, talking to the empty chair across the desk as if Victor Lang were sitting in it.
"Ms. Reyes," she said, in her best formal-arbitrator voice, "please walk us through Exhibit Twelve."
And then, as herself: "Exhibit Twelve is the cold-storage temperature log for the week of March fourth..."
She did it for two hours. The fern listened. The monitors glowed. Outside, Fair Oaks went about its Saturday — lawn mowers, children's voices, somebody's wind chimes — and Paula Reyes got ready for the biggest call of her life.
On Saturday evening, after the rehearsal, Lucia knocked and leaned in with the particular expression she wore when she was about to be kind about something she found ridiculous.
"Mom," she said, "you know the hearing notice is in your email. And your calendar. And probably carved into the back of your eyelids."
"Paper doesn't need a password," Paula said, for the hundredth time.
"I know, I know." Lucia came in and sat on the edge of the desk, careful of the monitors. "It's just — it's very you. If the internet ended tomorrow, you'd still have Tuesday at nine a.m. on paper."
"If the internet ended tomorrow, I'd have bigger problems than Tuesday."
"Would you, though?" Lucia grinned. "I think Tuesday would still be problem number one."
Paula laughed, and it felt good, the laugh loosening something in her chest she hadn't known was tight. "Go do something fun. It's Saturday."
"I am doing something fun. I'm watching you prepare for the biggest call of your life. It's like a nature documentary."
Later, Daniel found her in the office, reviewing the master timeline one last time. He didn't say anything for a moment — just stood in the doorway the way he had that morning, whistle gone now, game won, the week behind him. Then he said, "You know what I tell my players before a big game?"
"Don't fumble?"
"I tell them the game is already won or lost in practice, and Friday night is just showing people what you did all week." He kissed the top of her head. "You've done the work, Paula. Tuesday is just showing them."