At one meeting, the one in the spring when the clubhouse was full because the board was voting on the landscaping budget, Elaine stood at the front of the room and unrolled a map of Cedar Ridge and pinned it to the corkboard behind the podium. The map showed every street and every house, and someone, Elaine herself, had gone over it with a red marker. Forty-two cameras were marked in red, small red dots scattered across the neighborhood, some clustered near the entrances and some spread along the walking paths, and she tapped the map with the end of her pen as she spoke, moving from dot to dot as if she were giving a tour of a problem that only she could see.
"This is what we are living with," she said. "Forty-two cameras, and that is only the ones we can see from the street. There will be more behind fences and above garages, and we have no way of knowing where they point."
Daniel sat in the third row and listened, and he thought about the map, and he thought about the fact that she had made it by walking the neighborhood and photographing visible devices, including which homes had side-yard coverage, and he thought about what a map like that would mean in the wrong hands. He understood networks, and he understood that a map of camera blind spots created more danger than the cameras themselves, because it told anyone who read it exactly where no one was watching. He stood up when she finished, and he asked the board to restrict access to her file, to keep the map from being copied or shared beyond the committee, and Elaine turned toward him from the front of the room and accused him of trying to silence a committee volunteer.
The room went quiet. The board members looked at one another, and the president, Victor Hale, cleared his throat and said that the board would take the matter under advisement, which in Cedar Ridge meant that nothing would happen and everyone would go home and the map would stay pinned to the corkboard until someone took it down. Daniel sat back down, and he looked at the forty-two red dots, and he thought about the way Elaine had smiled when she tapped the last one, as if the map were proof of something she had always known.
That was the beginning of it, though Daniel did not know it at the time. He thought it was an argument about cameras, and it was, but it was also the start of a file, and the file grew with every meeting, and every notice, and every photograph, until the morning Elaine knelt beside his fiber box with a pair of insulated cutters and a canvas tote on the grass.
After the meeting with the forty-two cameras, Daniel asked Elaine directly how she had obtained the information on the map. He did not ask it in anger. He asked it the way he asked questions at work, because he wanted the answer on the record. She was standing beside the corkboard, rolling the map up from the bottom, and she did not look up when she answered.
"I walked the neighborhood," she said. "I photographed what any person walking the neighborhood could see. The devices are visible. That is the point. They are pointed at public life, and public life can see them back."
Daniel pointed out that walking the neighborhood and photographing visible devices was one thing, and that compiling the photographs into a map that showed which homes had side-yard coverage and which did not, and where the blind spots fell, was another thing entirely. He said that a map like that, in the wrong hands, would tell a person exactly where to stand so that no camera could see them, and that the board should restrict access to her file so that the map could not be copied or passed around. He said it, because he knew that the moment he raised his voice the argument would stop being about the map and start being about him.
Elaine stopped rolling the map. She looked at him, and her expression changed, and the change was visible from the third row, where the board members were gathering their papers. "You are trying to silence a committee volunteer," she said. Her voice carried, and it carried further than Daniel's had, because she was standing at the front of the room and he was not. "I have given this neighborhood a year of my time, and you want the board to lock my work in a drawer because it makes you uncomfortable."