"It makes the neighborhood less safe," Daniel said.
"It makes you less comfortable," Elaine said, and she turned back to the map, and the conversation was over, at least in that room, on that night.
The argument became personal after that, though neither of them would have said so at the time. Daniel would have said that it stayed about the cameras, and Elaine would have said that it stayed about privacy, and both of them would have been partly right, and both of them would have been wrong in the way that people are wrong when they have stopped listening to each other and started listening for the next thing to answer. The notices began to arrive, and they arrived with a regularity that felt deliberate, one every few weeks, each one on HOA letterhead, each one signed by the Technology and Privacy Committee, each one demanding that Daniel remove a camera or change a setting or stop using a piece of equipment that he had installed on his own house.
The first notice claimed that his doorbell camera recorded the interior of her living room. Daniel read it at the kitchen table, and Melissa read it over his shoulder, and they both looked at the camera on the porch, which faced the porch and the driveway and a narrow strip of the sidewalk, and which could not see through the front window of a house across the street even if it had been pointed there, which it was not. The claim was false, and Daniel knew it was false, and he wrote that in his appeal, and he included a photograph of the camera's field of view, taken from the camera itself, showing the porch and the driveway and the sidewalk and nothing else.
The second notice claimed that his home network used an unauthorized signal frequency. Daniel was a network administrator for the county library system, and he knew what an unauthorized signal frequency was, and he knew that his home equipment used ordinary, standard frequencies, the same ones used by every router and every phone in the neighborhood. He wrote that in his appeal too, and he listed the model numbers and the specifications, and he offered to let any technician the board chose come to his house and test the equipment. No one came.
The third notice was the one that stayed with him. It claimed that Sophie's medical relay interfered with community Wi-Fi. Daniel read it three times, because the first time he thought he had misunderstood it, and the second time he thought it must be a mistake, and the third time he understood that it was neither. The relay was a small, low-power medical device, and it did not transmit on the frequencies used by home Wi-Fi at all, and the provider had confirmed that in writing when the Harpers first installed it. The idea that it could interfere with the neighborhood's wireless network was not only false, it was technically impossible, and the provider's letter said so in plain language. Daniel attached the letter to his appeal, and he underlined the sentence where the provider confirmed that the relay could not interfere with community Wi-Fi, and he waited for the board to act.
Victor Hale withdrew the first two notices. Daniel learned about it the way he learned about most things the board did, which was by finding out after the fact, when he called the HOA office to ask about the status of his appeal and was told that the matter had been resolved. There was no hearing, and there was no written explanation, and there was no apology. The third notice was never heard at all. It sat in a file somewhere, unresolved, and Daniel stopped asking about it, because he had learned that asking Victor Hale about Elaine Brooks was like asking a man about a storm he had decided to wait out.
Victor never confronted her publicly. Daniel asked him once, after a board meeting, why the notices kept coming when each one was false, and Victor looked at the floor for a moment, and then he looked at Daniel, and he said the two things he always said when Elaine's name came up.
"She is passionate," Victor said. "She believes privacy is important."