Daniel did not argue. He had learned that arguing with Victor about Elaine was like arguing with a man who had already decided that the cost of a confrontation was higher than the cost of letting the notices arrive, and he had learned that Victor's way of handling a problem was to wait for it to go away on its own. The problem did not go away. It grew, the way problems grow when no one stops them, and by the time Daniel understood how much it had grown, it had already changed shape.
The change came in the form of a proposal. Elaine brought it to a board meeting in the early summer, and she presented it the way she presented everything, with a printed handout and a calm voice and the air of a person who had already decided that the matter was settled and was only waiting for the board to catch up. The proposal was called SecureNet, and it was, in her words, a solution to the problems the neighborhood had been arguing about for a year.
Under SecureNet, the neighborhood would replace individually managed internet connections and private cameras with a single neighborhood-wide system. One company would provide the fiber service, the doorbell cameras, the alarm monitoring, and the centralized technical support. The HOA would receive access to security footage during investigations. Residents would pay for the service through their monthly dues, so that no one would have to manage their own equipment or argue about which camera pointed where. The contract would run for five years, and it was worth nearly half a million dollars.
The vendor was Beacon Residential Systems. Elaine told the room that Beacon was independent, a company with experience in residential networks, and she said it with the same certainty she used for everything else. Daniel went home that night and looked up the public registration records, because that was what he did when someone told him a company was independent and he had reason to doubt it. The records were not hard to find. Beacon Residential Systems belonged to Owen Brooks, Elaine's brother, and Owen Brooks owned seventy percent of it.
Daniel brought the records to the next board meeting. He laid the printouts on the table in front of the board members, and he waited until Elaine had finished her presentation, and then he raised his hand, and Victor nodded at him, and Daniel said the things that needed to be said, in the order they needed to be said.
"He owns seventy percent," Daniel said. "Your brother owns seventy percent of the company you are proposing we hire."
Elaine did not look at the printouts. "My brother is one of several partners," she said. "He has experience. That is why the proposal is strong."
"You helped write the requirements," Daniel said. "The requirements exclude every provider except his."
"The requirements describe what this neighborhood needs," Elaine said. "If other providers cannot meet them, that is not my fault."
"Because I understand the problem," she added, when Victor asked her why she had been the one to draft the specifications. She said it as if understanding a problem gave a person the right to decide who would be paid to solve it, and she said it without looking at Daniel, and she folded her hands on the table in front of her, and she waited.
Daniel looked at the board members. He looked at Victor, who was studying the printouts without picking them up, and he looked at Helen Price, who was writing something in the margin of her own copy of the proposal, and he looked at the two other board members, who were looking at the ceiling and the floor and anywhere except the table. He thought about the forty-two cameras on the map, and he thought about the three notices, and he thought about the way Elaine had photographed the technician during a repair, and he thought about the fact that the woman who had spent a year arguing that cameras were a threat to privacy was now proposing that the neighborhood hand its cameras, and its footage, and its internet service, to a company owned by her brother.
The board delayed the vote. Victor said that the matter required further study, and Helen Price said that the residents needed more time to consider the proposal, and the meeting moved on to the landscaping budget, and the SecureNet handouts were left on the table when the room emptied, and Daniel gathered his printouts and put them back in his folder and walked home through the quiet streets, thinking that the delay meant the proposal was finished.