Rebecca taped it to the mirror's edge and stood in front of the glass in her nightdress, and raised her own chin, and tipped her own head, and let the laugh come up out of her throat.
It sounded wrong. She did it again. She practiced the way her sister held a wine glass, the way she tilted toward a listener, the vowels that Elena had been polished with and Rebecca had only ever overheard.
Night after night the smile improved. Night after night the woman in the mirror became less and less the sister who had been sent away, and more and more the sister who had been kept.
And on the last night of that first month, Rebecca looked at the two faces, the magazine's and the mirror's, identical and laughing, and she stopped practicing Elena's smile and simply wore it, and understood that she was no longer rehearsing a way into the family.
She was rehearsing a replacement.
Daniel Reyes had been head of security at the Hale estate for six years, and he had built his career on a simple principle: a house tells the truth if you walk it slowly enough.
That night, with the engagement party wreckage still cooling in the ballroom and a woman pulled living out of the dark under the swimming pool, the house was talking very fast.
The west wing had been closed since Richard's death. Staff did not go there. The cameras there had been switched to a maintenance feed four years ago, and the dust, Daniel had always been told, was undisturbed.
The dust was disturbed.
He had found the first signs an hour earlier: a door whose lock had been oiled recently, oiled in a closed wing, which is the domestic equivalent of a stranger's footprint in snow.
Then a panel in the service corridor that swung a half-inch too freely. Then, behind a linen shelf, a child's drawing, fresh crayon on the back of a delivery invoice: a house, a pool drawn as a blue rectangle, and two stick girls holding hands.
Two stick girls. He had folded it into his inside pocket like evidence and like a prayer.
Now, past two in the morning, he stood in the doorway of the estate's security room, in the basement corridor behind the kitchens, and the house was telling him the rest of the story whether he wanted to hear it or not.
The monitor wall showed the estate in green-grey squares: gates, lawn, pool house, corridors. It had been rebuilt three weeks ago, the workmen said, new screens, new housing, at Mr. Doyle's instruction.
Graham again. Graham's name was on every new thing in this house the way damp is on a wall.
Daniel ran his hand along the side of the new housing, the way he had run it along the service panel upstairs, and felt the same wrongness: depth where there should not be depth. A wall that was thicker than the room it belonged to.
He found the seam at the third monitor from the left. It took him four minutes with a screwdriver from the desk drawer, working quietly, the way a man works when he has begun to suspect that the house itself has enemies.
The panel came away in his hands.
Behind it was not wiring. Behind it was a room.
It was small, perhaps nine feet by six, and it had been made with terrible care. A narrow bed with clean sheets. A rug. A shelf of books with soft covers, and a lamp shaped like a rabbit, and a plastic box of crayons, and a water bottle with cartoon animals on it, refilled recently.
No windows. A vent high in the wall, humming. A door on the far side that Daniel understood at once would open into the old service passage that ran toward the pool house, and his stomach went cold and still, because he understood the geography of the whole crime at once.
And on the bed, sitting up very straight with her back against the wall and a stuffed rabbit held to her chest with both arms, was a little girl.
She was six years old. She had dark curls and Elena Hale's eyes and Ava Hale's face, Ava's whole face, assembled identically, as if God had used the same drawing twice and hidden one copy in a wall.
For a moment Daniel Reyes, who had carried a weapon professionally for fifteen years and never once fumbled it, could not make his body do anything at all.
She watched him with the enormous, assessing calm of a child who has been taught that adults arriving through walls are a category of event to be survived quietly.
"Is the party over?" she asked.
Her voice was small and hoarse, a voice that had not been used much lately.
Daniel set the screwdriver down on the desk behind him, slowly, and put both of his hands where she could see them, palms open, the way you approach anything that has been locked up and has learned to bite or to freeze.
"Nearly over," he said, as gently as he could. "You heard it, through the wall?"
"I heard the music stop," she said. "Aunt Rebecca gets angry when I make noise after the music. Is she angry?"
Behind his ribs, Daniel's heart was slamming so hard he was afraid she would hear it and be frightened by yet another loud thing in her life.
"What's your name?" he asked, though Ava's face had already told him, though the drawing with two girls holding hands had already told him, though Nurse Wells's records, which he had not yet seen, were already waiting somewhere in the world to confirm it.