There was no verdict. There was no courtroom. There was only the slow machinery, and Claire's name on a witness list, and her statement, given at our kitchen table, in the record now where no one could reach it to burn it, which was, she said, the entire point.
"I did my part in October," she said. "The rest belongs to other people for a while. I intend to let it."
The nightmares began to ease in November. *Ease* was the word her doctor used and it was the right one β not stop, not lift, ease, the way a tide eases, almost imperceptibly, until one evening you realize the water has been going out for weeks. She still woke some nights. There was still the bad hour before dawn when the house was coldest. But increasingly I would wake at five and find her asleep beside me with her face turned toward the window, breathing like a person, and once β I remember this the way you remember weather β I woke at five and found her already downstairs, in her robe, making tea and humming something under her breath while she looked at the frost on the inside of the kitchen window, and it took me a moment to place the tune, and then I had to stand in the doorway and hold on to the frame, because it was the river song, and she was humming it to no one, to herself, to the kettle, like a woman whose mind had found its way back to a room it used to live in.
"You're up," she said, without turning around.
"The kettle woke me."
"The kettle apologizes." She poured. "I dreamed about my mother last night. Not the β not the other thing. My mother, in her kitchen, teaching me that song, except in the dream I was grown and she was laughing at me for still getting the second verse wrong." She set a mug in front of the chair that was mine. "Six years of one dream. And last night, a different one. I thought you should know."
"I should," I said. "Thank you."
There was one conversation I was not part of, and I have only ever had it secondhand, from Claire, given to me freely on a night when the wind was worrying the lake, because by then the policy of the house β though we had not yet said it aloud at the kitchen table β was already becoming the truth, going forward, even when the truth was tender.
Lily had asked, at bath time, in the practical tone she used for her most enormous questions, whether the lady under the pool was gone now.
Not *you*, Claire said. *The lady under the pool.* As if there were two of them, and one was still down there.
So Claire sat on the closed lid of the toilet in her robe, with the bath running warm and the mirror fogging, and she told her daughter the truth at six-year-old height: that the lady under the pool had been her, all along, the same person, and that the person she had talked to through the vent and the person who braided her hair at breakfast were one person, and that person was never, ever going back under the water again, because Daddy and the workers were going to fill the underneath with stones.
"All of it?" Lily said. "Even the singing part?"
"Even the singing part," Claire said. "Especially the singing part. The singing part is up here now. It lives in the house. If you want it, you ask me, and I sing it in the kitchen like a normal mother."
"Okay," Lily said, and then, after a silence in which the whole of her two months must have turned over in her mind like a stone in a pocket: "I catched you. At the party. I yelled and Daddy ran and we catched you."
"You did," Claire said. "You were the bravest person in the whole story, and you were six, and you did it in a party dress."
"I had juice on the dress," Lily said.
"You had juice on the dress," Claire agreed, "and you saved my life anyway. Imagine what you'll do in a clean dress."
She told me all of this afterward without triumph, lying awake in the dark beside me, in the hour that used to be the bad hour and was becoming, some nights, only an hour.
"I keep waiting for her to be damaged," she said. "I keep looking for the place where those two months bent her. And then she informs me she had juice on her dress, and I think β maybe children don't keep things the way we keep them, Tom. Maybe she'll keep it as the story where she was brave. Maybe we're allowed to let her."
"We're allowed," I said. "She's allowed."
"Then we'll let her," Claire said, and turned toward the window, and was asleep before the hour was out.
The work on the pool house began on the first Monday of November, and it began with the water going out.