Chapter 3: Dad, Did You Touch Her?
My father was sitting in his armchair when I walked into the living room. He had his book open on his lap, and his reading glasses on, and he looked up at me the way he always did, calm and a little surprised, as if I had interrupted him in the middle of a sentence. The radio was playing on the side table. The afternoon light came in through the window and fell across the rug. Nothing in the room looked wrong. Nothing in his face looked wrong either, and that made me angrier, because if he had just attacked my wife, how could he sit there so calmly with a book on his lap?
"Dad," I said, and my voice came out louder than I meant it to. "Dad, did you touch her?"
He took his glasses off slowly, and he set them down on the book, and he looked at me, and his face was steady, the way it always was when he was telling the truth, plain and simple, the way he had always told the truth to me since I was a boy.
No, son. She's lying.
I stared at him. I waited for him to say more, to explain, to defend himself, to tell me what had really happened, but he did not. He just sat there in his chair and looked at me, and the silence stretched out between us, and I could hear Mia crying in the hallway behind me.
"She's lying?" I said. "Dad, her shirt is torn. Her shirt is torn at the shoulder, and she is crying in the hallway, and you are sitting here telling me she's lying?"
"I did not touch her," he said, and his voice was quiet and flat, the way it got when he was absolutely certain about something. "I have not laid a hand on her. Not today. Not ever. I was sitting right here, reading, the same as every afternoon. She came down the hall, and she was already crying, and her shirt was already torn. Ask her to tell you where I touched her. Ask her to tell you when. She cannot, because it did not happen."
"You are calling my wife a liar," I said. "In our own house. My wife is standing in the hallway crying, and you are calling her a liar."
"I am telling you the truth," he said. "I know it is hard to hear. But I am your father, and I am telling you the truth, and I would not lie to you about something like this, not ever, not for any reason."
I looked at his hands. They were resting on the arms of the chair, old hands, spotted, the knuckles a little swollen, the hands of a man who had spent his life holding books and chalk and nothing heavier. They did not look like the hands of a man who had just grabbed a woman hard enough to tear her shirt. But Mia's shirt was torn. I had seen it. I had held her while she shook.
"Then how did her shirt get torn?" I said. "Tell me that. If you did not touch her, how did her shirt get torn?"
"I don't know," he said. "I was not there. I was here. But I know it was not me, and if you give me a minute, I can prove it to you."
"Prove it?" I said, and I took a step toward him. "How are you going to prove it, Dad? Mia is crying in the hallway. What proof is there?"
He looked up at me, and for the first time something moved in his face, something tired and sad, and he said, very quietly, "Son. Don't do what you are about to do."
But I was already doing it. The anger was up in me like a wave, and I could not stop it, and I did not want to stop it, because my wife was crying and my father was sitting there calling her a liar, and something in me, something I had never felt before, told me that a man does not stand by while his wife is hurt. A man acts. A man defends his wife. That was what I told myself, in that moment, and it felt like the truth, and it felt like the right thing, and I did not stop to think about what it would cost.
Chapter 4: The Slap
I do not remember deciding to hit him. I remember the anger, and I remember Mia crying in the hallway, and I remember my father's calm face looking up at me, and then I remember my hand moving, almost on its own, and the sound it made when it struck his cheek, open-handed, hard, the sound of skin on skin in a quiet room.