The next morning, Arthur received a call from Victor.
"Mr. Whitmore?"
"Yes."
"It's Victor Kane."
Arthur paused.
"What happened?"
Victor's voice sounded strained.
"I found something in my mother's belongings."
"What?"
"A letter. She wrote it shortly before she died."
Arthur listened.
Victor continued.
"She said she had hidden something from the night of the fire."
Arthur sat down.
"What?"
"A key."
Arthur felt his heart begin to race.
"Where is it?"
"At the clubhouse."
"Can you bring it?"
"Yes. But there's something else."
"What?"
Victor hesitated.
"My mother wrote that Edward Kane didn't start the fire."
Arthur frowned.
"Then who did?"
Victor answered:
"Charles Hargrove."
Arthur closed his eyes.
For forty-three years, he had suspected it.
Now he had confirmation.
Victor continued.
"She also wrote that the man who ordered it was still alive."
Arthur looked at Evelyn.
"Who?"
Victor's voice dropped.
"Judge Nathaniel Cross."
The key was small and made of brass.
Victor brought it to Arthur that afternoon.
It was attached to a faded paper tag bearing the words:
ST. MATTHEW'S — OFFICE STORAGE.
Arthur examined it carefully.
"Where did your mother find this?"
Victor handed him the letter.
"She said she took it from Hargrove's office after the fire."
Arthur read the letter.
The handwriting was shaky.
I know what happened that night. Charles Hargrove ordered the fire because Inspector Harris had discovered the ledger. Nathaniel Cross arranged for the investigation to disappear.
I helped the children escape. I took Thomas to Robert Brooks. Samuel and Peter were sent to other families.
I have hidden the key because I could not destroy what it opened.
If Arthur Whitmore ever returns, give it to him.
Tell him I am sorry.
Arthur lowered the letter.
Victor looked at him.
"She spent her entire life carrying this."
Arthur nodded.
"She saved my son."
Victor looked down.
"I wish she had told us."
Arthur placed a hand on his shoulder.
"She was afraid."
Victor swallowed.
"Fear doesn't excuse everything."
"No," Arthur said. "But sometimes it explains why good people make terrible choices."
The old St. Matthew's property had been abandoned for decades.
Most of the building had been demolished, but the original basement remained beneath a newer storage facility.
Arthur, Evelyn, Daniel, Victor, and Raymond arrived shortly before sunset.
They had informed the local authorities that they were investigating a possible historical crime.
But they had not told anyone about the key.
The facility manager unlocked the basement door.
"Be careful," he warned. "The place hasn't been maintained in years."
Arthur nodded.
They descended a narrow staircase.
The air smelled of damp concrete and rust.
At the bottom was a corridor.
Arthur remembered it.
He had walked through it thousands of times.
At the far end stood a metal door.
He inserted the key.
It turned.
The door opened with a low metallic groan.
Inside was a small storage room.
Shelves lined the walls.
Most were empty.
But in the far corner sat a metal cabinet.
Arthur approached it.
The lock was broken.
He opened the cabinet.
Inside was a black metal box.
Daniel stared.
"Is that it?"
Arthur nodded.
He lifted the box carefully.
It was heavier than he remembered.
He placed it on the floor.
The lid was secured with a small combination lock.
Arthur entered the numbers.
The date of Thomas's birthday.
The lock clicked.
Inside were folders, photographs, handwritten notes, and a thick leather ledger.
Arthur opened it.
The first page contained a list of names.
The second contained payments.
The third contained signatures.
Arthur turned the pages slowly.
Then he stopped.
At the bottom of one page was a familiar name.
Nathaniel Cross.
Beside it was a payment authorization.
The amount was twenty-five thousand dollars.
Arthur looked at Evelyn.
"We have him."
Evelyn photographed every page.
Victor leaned closer.
"Who are the other names?"
Arthur turned the page.
And then he saw something that made him stop.
Edward Kane.
His signature appeared on several entries.
Victor closed his eyes.
"My father."
Arthur nodded.
"Yes."
Daniel looked at the ledger.
"How many children?"
Arthur turned another page.
There were seventeen names.
Seventeen children.
Seventeen lives altered by a network of people who had treated human beings like pieces of property.
Arthur felt sick.
He turned another page.
At the bottom was a final entry.
Transfer authorized: Thomas Whitmore. Receiving party: Robert Brooks.
Below it was a note.
Payment withheld pending permanent identity reassignment.
Daniel stared.
"So Robert was paid."
Arthur looked at him.
"Apparently."
Daniel stepped away.
For a moment, he couldn't breathe.
Then he looked at the final page.
There was another name.
Peter Collins.
And beside it:
Current location unknown. Witness status unresolved.
Arthur looked up.
"Peter may still be alive."
A sudden noise came from the corridor.
Footsteps.
Victor turned.
"Who's there?"
Nobody answered.
Then the lights went out.
A loud crash echoed through the basement.
Raymond shouted.
"Everyone stay together!"
A door slammed somewhere behind them.
Daniel reached for his flashlight.
Its beam swept across the room.
The storage door was open.
The box was gone.
Arthur looked down.
The ledger had disappeared.