Arthur looked at Jonathan.
“You're right.”
Jonathan turned toward him.
“You don't have to defend them.”
“I'm not. I'm telling you that you're right. The adults failed you. Every one of us who knew and stayed silent failed you.”
Martin nodded.
“I did.”
Jonathan looked away.
Arthur continued.
“But now we have a chance to make sure the children who came after you aren't left behind.”
Jonathan stared at him.
For a long moment, he said nothing.
Then he nodded.
“Then we find them.”
The investigators returned to Mercy House the following morning.
This time, they brought a forensic team and a structural engineer.
Jonathan accompanied them.
He had not wanted to return, but he insisted that he should be there.
“I know where the other room is,” he said.
The team entered through the chapel.
Jonathan walked to the far wall.
He placed his hand against the stone and counted the panels.
“Here.”
The engineer examined the wall.
There was a narrow seam hidden beneath the plaster.
A concealed door.
It opened into a second staircase.
The air below was colder.
At the bottom was a room with six small beds.
Five were empty.
One still had a blanket folded at the foot.
On the wall were children's drawings.
A house.
A tree.
A woman holding a little boy's hand.
A motorcycle.
A blue sweater.
And, written in uneven letters near the bottom of the wall:
I WANT TO GO HOME.
Arthur stood in the doorway.
His chest tightened.
Daniel approached the nearest bed.
There was a small notebook on the mattress.
He opened it.
Inside were drawings and short sentences written in a child's handwriting.
My name is David.
I am seven.
They say my mother is gone.
I don't think she is.
Daniel turned another page.
Eleanor says I must remember my real name.
A name had been written beneath the sentence.
SAMUEL REED.
Jonathan looked at the notebook.
“I remember him.”
“Who was he?” Rebecca asked.
“A boy who came after me. He was younger. He had blond hair and a scar on his forehead.”
“Where did he go?”
Jonathan shook his head.
“I don't know. One morning, his bed was empty.”
The investigators photographed everything.
The room contained more than drawings.
There were medical records, school papers, and several sealed envelopes.
One envelope was addressed to Eleanor Price.
Another carried the name Adrian Vale.
Inside the second envelope was a typed list.
It contained six names.
Five had dates beside them.
The sixth had a question mark.
Martin read the list.
“Samuel Reed. David Lawson. Peter Walsh. James Carter. Andrew Bell.”
He stopped at the final name.
“Bell?”
Arthur looked at him.
“Your family?”
Martin shook his head.
“I had a brother named Andrew.”
Daniel turned.
“You never mentioned a brother.”
Martin looked down.
“He disappeared when he was eight.”
Nobody spoke.
“Was he taken from your family?” Rebecca asked.
Martin nodded.
“My parents were told he had died in a hospital. I was twelve. I believed them.”
He looked at the list again.
“His name was on the ledger.”
Arthur felt a terrible understanding settle over the room.
Martin had not simply worked for the institution.
He had been connected to the network as a victim's brother.
He had spent decades hiding from the truth about his own family while protecting the people who had taken his brother.
“Martin,” Daniel said quietly.
The older man could not look at him.
“I thought he was dead.”
Arthur approached.
“Then we find him.”
Martin shook his head.
“He would be almost sixty.”
“Then we find the man he became.”
The investigator took the list.
“This is now a missing-person investigation involving multiple potential victims.”
Laura nodded.
“And the evidence suggests that Mercy House was used long after St. Matthew's closed.”
Jonathan looked at the empty beds.
“They were still here.”
“Yes,” Arthur said.
“They were still telling children their families had forgotten them.”
Arthur placed a hand on his shoulder.
“Not anymore.”
The first breakthrough came from the school records.
A state archivist found a transfer document for Samuel Reed.
He had been placed with a family in western Pennsylvania under the name Samuel Parker.
A later school record showed that he had attended a technical school in Erie.
The family had moved several times, but the final address led to a small town near the Ohio border.
The investigators located a man matching his age and description.
He was alive.
He had spent most of his life believing that his biological parents had died in a house fire.
When the state investigator called him, he refused to believe the story.
Then he saw the photograph of the notebook.
He recognized the handwriting.
He recognized the room.
He remembered the words on the wall.
And he agreed to meet Jonathan.
The second name, David Lawson, was harder to trace.
The records had been altered twice.
The investigators found him living in a care facility after a stroke.
He could not speak clearly, but he recognized the photograph of Mercy House.
When Jonathan visited, David began to cry.