He looked toward the family photograph.
"She knew he was alive."
Evelyn placed a hand on his shoulder.
"She never stopped trying."
Arthur wiped his eyes.
"Where is the family Bible?"
"At your old house?"
Arthur shook his head.
"No. Margaret gave it to her sister before she died."
"Where does her sister live?"
"Ohio."
Evelyn stood.
"Then we need to go."
The family Bible was kept in a small apartment in Columbus.
Margaret's sister, Helen, was eighty-four years old.
When Arthur arrived, she embraced him.
"Arthur, I wondered when you would come."
He looked at her.
"You knew?"
Helen nodded.
"Margaret told me everything."
Arthur felt a painful mixture of anger and relief.
"Why didn't you tell me?"
"Because she asked me not to."
Arthur lowered his head.
Helen continued.
"She believed that if you knew Thomas was alive, you would go looking for him immediately. She was afraid you would lead the people responsible straight to him."
Arthur sat down.
"I lost forty-three years."
Helen nodded sadly.
"So did she."
Helen brought out the Bible.
It was old, its leather cover cracked and faded.
She opened it to the Book of Psalms.
A small folded paper slipped out.
Arthur picked it up.
It contained a photograph of a document.
The original was not there.
Only the photograph.
Arthur studied it.
It was a signed statement from Nathaniel Cross Sr.
The document confirmed that he had authorized the destruction of St. Matthew's records and the transfer of seventeen children.
At the bottom was a second signature.
Charles Hargrove.
Arthur looked at Evelyn.
"This is enough to reopen the case."
Evelyn nodded.
"Yes."
But Helen was not finished.
She reached into another drawer.
"There is something else Margaret wanted you to have."
She placed a small cassette recorder on the table.
Arthur looked confused.
Helen explained.
"Your wife recorded a conversation with someone shortly before she died."
Arthur pressed the play button.
A woman's voice filled the room.
Margaret.
Then another voice.
A man.
Arthur recognized it immediately.
Nathaniel Cross Sr.
The recording was old, but the words were clear.
"Your husband should stop asking questions," the man said.
Margaret answered:
"He won't."
"Then he will lose what remains of his family."
"You've already taken his son."
A pause.
Then the man said:
"And I can make sure he never finds him."
Arthur closed his eyes.
Margaret continued:
"You're a coward."
The recording ended.
Arthur sat motionless.
Then he stood.
"We're going to the authorities."
By the end of the week, the investigation had become national news.
A major newspaper published an article detailing the St. Matthew's fire, the missing children, and the newly discovered evidence.
The headline read:
FORTY-THREE-YEAR CHILD DISAPPEARANCE CASE REOPENED AFTER NEW EVIDENCE EMERGES
The article included photographs of Arthur, Daniel, Samuel, and Victor.
It also named Nathaniel Cross Jr. as a person of interest.
Within hours, the county prosecutor announced a formal investigation.
Former employees of St. Matthew's were contacted.
Several retired officers were questioned.
Records were seized from private archives.
But one question remained.
Where was Peter Collins?
Arthur couldn't rest until they found him.
He spent hours examining the list of seventeen children.
Some had been located.
Others were still missing.
Peter's name appeared several times.
Each entry was followed by a different identity.
Arthur eventually found a handwritten note beside one of the records.
Transferred to Tennessee. Receiving family: Collins.
He looked at Evelyn.
"Could that be his real surname?"
"Possibly."
"Then he may still be using it."
Evelyn began searching.
Three days later, she found a possible match.
A man named Peter Collins, sixty-eight years old, living in a small town in Tennessee.
He had worked as a mechanic for most of his life.
He had never married.
And he had no known relatives.
Arthur stared at the photograph.
He recognized the eyes.
"That's him."
Peter Collins lived in a small house beside an auto repair shop.
When Arthur arrived, Peter was working beneath a pickup truck.
He heard footsteps and slid out.
"Can I help you?"
Arthur looked at him.
"Are you Peter Collins?"
"Yes."
"My name is Arthur Whitmore."
Peter froze.
Then he slowly stood.
For a moment, he seemed unable to speak.
Finally, he said:
"I wondered when someone would come."
Arthur stepped closer.
"You remember St. Matthew's?"
Peter nodded.
"Every night."
Arthur's eyes filled.
Peter looked at Daniel.
"Thomas?"
Daniel nodded.
"Daniel now."
Peter smiled sadly.
"Of course."
The three men stood together in the garage.
For several seconds, nobody spoke.
Then Peter reached into his pocket and removed a small photograph.
It showed three boys standing in a garden.
Thomas.
Samuel.
Peter.
Arthur recognized the day.
It was the afternoon he had given Thomas the silver compass.
Peter looked at him.
"You told us something that day."
Arthur frowned.
"What?"
Peter smiled.
"You said that nobody should ever have to earn the right to be safe."
Arthur felt tears fill his eyes.
He remembered.
He had been speaking to the boys after one of them had been punished for breaking a window.
Peter had been frightened.
Thomas had been angry.