I walked the rest of the yard after that, not because I needed more photographs, but because I wanted to be certain I was not missing something — some forgotten head, some line I had never noticed, some plausible basis for the claim. There was none. The lawn, such as it was, was patchy in the way a wooded lot's grass is patchy, green where the sun reached it and thin where the trees shaded it. The beds near the house held shrubs and mulch, watered by hand when I remembered and by rain when I did not. The well pump I had replaced years ago sat in its housing, quiet between cycles, feeding the house and nothing else. The house was dry. The ground was dry. The only water moving on the property was in the pipes inside the walls, going where pipes are supposed to go.
It struck me, standing there with the camera still in my hand, how easy it would have been for someone else to accept the fine and pay it. Seventy-five dollars is not a ruinous sum. It is the price of a dinner out, a sum most people would pay to make a piece of paper go away rather than spend an afternoon photographing a dry hole in the ground. That, I thought, might be the point. A fine does not have to be large to be effective. It only has to be slightly cheaper than fighting it, and slightly more annoying than ignoring it, until the person being fined decides that his time is worth more than his principle. I was not at that point yet. I had time, and I had a camera, and I had a stubbornness that my ex-wife would have recognized immediately. I would spend the afternoon, and I would keep the receipt for the principle, filed next to the photographs.
Then I sent the photographs to the board with a short letter. I stated, plainly, that I had no irrigation system, that the valve box was dry, and that there was therefore no leak to repair. I asked that the fine be withdrawn.
The reply came back within a week, and it was shorter than my letter. The fine would stand, it said, "pending inspection."
Pending inspection. I turned the phrase over in my mind the way I had turned over the phrase "enforcement action" in March. An inspection had not yet happened, but a fine had already been issued, and the fine would remain in place until someone got around to verifying the thing it punished. The order of operations was backwards. In my work, you inspected first, you documented the defect, and then you required a correction. Here, the correction had been priced before the defect had been confirmed, and the burden of proving a negative — proving that a system I did not own was not leaking — had been handed to me.
I did not pay the seventy-five dollars either. I filed the reply with the fine notice and the photographs, in the folder, and I added a line to my log: "Fine 2 stands pending inspection. No system exists."
It was a strange sentence to write about one's own house. It was also, I was beginning to learn, exactly the kind of sentence this dispute was going to require.
The third fine arrived on May 16. One hundred dollars, for fence height.
This one I could measure, and so I did, immediately, with more care than the board's inspector appeared to have taken. My fence is five feet eleven inches tall. The limit in the governing documents is six feet. I was one inch under the limit, on level ground, measured the way any competent person would measure a fence: from the ground at its base to the top of the fence, on the side where the ground was level.
The board's inspector had measured it differently. He had measured from the downhill side, where the grade drops eight inches. Stand on the low side of a slope, hold your tape at the bottom of the slope, and run it to the top of the fence, and of course the number is larger. It is larger because the ground fell away beneath you, not because the fence grew. It was a measurement error dressed up as a violation, and it was the kind of error I had spent my career learning to catch, because in structural work a measurement taken from the wrong datum does not just produce a wrong number. It produces a wrong conclusion, and then someone builds on the wrong conclusion.