PART2 HOA Karen Called Deputies to Open My Gate — Then Used Their Report to Take Control Anyway

Chapter 7

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

That was the problem, though I did not see it clearly at the time. What Carol could see from the street was a closed gate, a long driveway disappearing into trees, and a house she could not inspect without coming through that gate. What she could not see was the drainage I had repaired, or the well pump I had replaced, or the wiring I had redone, or the porch I had rebuilt, or the dead trees I had cleared. She could not see the folder in my office drawer, or the permits, or the inspection records, or the nine years of quiet maintenance that had gone into keeping the place sound. She saw a barrier, and because she could not see past it, she assumed that what lay past it was unexamined. Privacy, to Carol, read as defiance. A man who kept his gate closed was a man who had something to hide, or something to resist, or at the very least something that had not been brought into order.

I understood, later, that my own habits had fed that reading. I did not attend meetings regularly. I did not volunteer for committees. I did not stop to chat at the mailbox about landscaping or standards or the business of the association. I paid my dues and went home, and home was a place other people could not easily reach. To a woman whose vocabulary was accountability and uniform landscaping and strict inspections, that way of living looked like a refusal to participate, and a refusal to participate looked like a challenge. I had not intended it as one. I had intended it as nothing at all, which in Carol's world was almost worse, because a thing that meant nothing could not be negotiated with or brought into line.

So we settled into a pattern that was not quite a conflict and not quite peace. Carol's binder grew thicker. My gate stayed closed. The neighborhood went on around us, with its gardens and its mailboxes and its common areas, and I went on with my mornings on the porch and my evenings checking the cameras, and for a while the arrangement held. It held because Harold's way of running things still lingered, even as Harold himself stepped back, and because no one had yet written down, in a letter on association letterhead, a demand that forced the question. I did not know that letter was coming. I only knew, in a vague way I did not examine too closely, that a woman who carried a binder full of rules into every meeting would eventually find a rule she believed applied to me. The gate was the most visible thing about my property, and the least visible thing behind it was everything else. That combination was always going to attract her attention, sooner or later.

I had not sought out Carol's company, and she had not sought out mine, and our encounters were brief and correct. At the mailbox, or at the edge of a meeting, we exchanged the small courtesies neighbors exchange, and then I drove home through my gate and she drove home to her binder. I did not tell her about the drainage or the wiring or the porch, because she did not ask, and because a man's home improvements are not, as a rule, a topic of conversation with someone who has not asked to hear about them. What I did not realize was that my silence was being recorded as evidence: every meeting I missed went into an account I could not see, in which I was the neighbor who would not cooperate. I had thought I was simply being private. Carol had decided I was being defiant, and defiance, unlike privacy, was something a binder could be opened against.

The letter arrived on March 4, on HOA letterhead, in an envelope I opened at the kitchen counter without any particular expectation. I read it twice. I remember reading it twice because the first reading did not quite make sense to me, and the second reading did not make it make any more sense. It said, in full:

"Dear Mr. Wittmann, The association requires access to all properties within the community for routine oversight and periodic compliance review. Please provide a working gate code or physical access key within ten days."

I put it on the kitchen counter and stared at it, the way you stare at a bill sent to the wrong address. My first thought, and my second, was that it had to be a mistake. The association did not have a right to demand a gate code from me, because no such right existed in the documents I had read when I bought the property, and I had read those documents carefully. I was an engineer. I read documents the way other people read letters, slowly and with attention to what was actually written rather than what someone wished had been written. The governing documents were clear, as I understood them, and I understood them well. The association controlled the common areas, and it set certain exterior standards for properties in the community, and that was the extent of it. There was no blanket entry right. There was no gate-code requirement. There was certainly no provision that entitled the association to unrestricted access to a private lot at the end of a private driveway, for routine oversight or for any other purpose dressed up in those words.

News in the same category

PART2 HOA Karen Called Deputies to Open My Gate — Then Used Their Report to Take Control Anyway

45 Part