Harold and I were not close friends. We did not socialize, and I did not attend many meetings, but we understood each other well enough. He had come out to my property once, early on, and looked at the gate, and nodded in the way a man nods when something has been done properly and there is nothing further to say about it. He never demanded a code from me. He never suggested that the association needed one. His view, as I understood it, was that a man's driveway was his own business so long as emergency vehicles could get through, and my driveway was kept clear for exactly that reason. I kept it clear because it was sensible, not because anyone had ordered me to, and Harold seemed to appreciate the difference. He was the kind of president who noticed when a thing was already being done right and did not invent a rule to take credit for it.
As the years went on, though, Harold's health declined. It happened gradually, the way such things do, and at first it showed only in small ways: he moved more slowly at meetings, he tired sooner, he let other board members handle the correspondence he used to handle himself. Nobody made a fuss about it, and Harold himself certainly did not. He had run the association for a long time, and he had done it well, and the neighborhood owed him a debt of patience that most people seemed willing to pay. But an organization, like a house, needs someone tending it, and when the person tending it begins to step back, someone else steps forward. That is not a criticism of Harold. It is simply what happens. He had given the neighborhood years of steady, unremarkable competence, and the time came when he could no longer give it quite so steadily.
I thought about Harold sometimes when I sat on my porch in the morning, though I did not dwell on it. He represented, to me, a particular idea of how neighbors ought to deal with one another: directly, reasonably, and with a presumption of good faith. I had benefited from that idea for years without really naming it. The dues notices arrived, I paid them, the common areas were kept up, and nobody knocked on my door demanding anything I had not agreed to. That was the functioning association Harold had built, and I had taken it for granted, as people take for granted anything that works quietly. I did not yet understand that a functioning association was not a permanent condition. It was a condition that depended on the person running it, and on the temperament of the people around the table, and on whether anyone at that table had decided that functioning was no longer enough.
Harold ran the meetings the way he had run a classroom, I imagined, though I never saw him teach. He started on time, he kept the agenda visible, and he let people speak without letting them repeat themselves. When a dispute came up about a fence or a mailbox, he would ask what the documents actually said, and then he would read the section aloud, slowly, as if the words themselves could settle the matter. Usually they could. The dues were collected, the common areas were mowed and kept up, and the reserve fund was mentioned once a year in a tone that suggested it was being watched. It was not exciting work, and Harold did not pretend otherwise. He treated the association as a utility, like water or electricity: it should function, it should be accounted for, and it should not become the main event in anyone's life.
Carol Ashby arrived, as these things go, not with a dramatic entrance but with a binder. She was in her early fifties, and she always looked prepared to argue, not in an angry way but in the way of a person who had already decided what she would say and had organized her materials to say it. She had worked in property management years earlier, and she mentioned it often, usually at the point in a conversation where someone else might have mentioned a qualification. It was not a boast, exactly. It was a credential she carried into every room, the way other people carried a title. She knew how associations worked, she implied, because she had worked for the companies that ran them, and the rest of us were amateurs by comparison.