PART2 The HOA Karen Used My Private Road Every Morning — So I Installed a Gate Before Sunrise

Chapter 20

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The second page clipped behind it was a disclosure statement listing, among the papers conveyed, a copy of the writer's March 2019 letter to the HOA. That was why it was in my packet. Someone — Hal, or his lawyer, or the title company doing its work properly — had made sure the buyer received the very letter the HOA had buried. It had sat in a drawer through two years of white SUVs at 6:42 in the morning, waiting for me to read my own files.

I called Dana because my hands were not entirely steady, and I wanted a witness to the feeling. She answered on the second ring.

"Dana. It's in my closing binder. It was here the whole time."

"What is, Ethan? Slowly."

"Hal Brennan revoked it. In writing. March twelfth, twenty nineteen. A letter to the HOA board. He says the permission was from the washout, in twenty-eleven, personal and temporary, and he ends it. He says don't use the road and don't tell buyers they can. It's signed. It says hand-delivered. I have a copy because it was in my title disclosures. I just never read it."

There was a silence on the line that I had never heard from her, and then she exhaled, once, the way a person does when a wall they have been pushing on turns out to have had a door in it all along.

"Do not let that copy out of your hands," she said. "Photograph every page tonight, front and back, and send me the photographs. Tomorrow you bring me the binder itself. Ethan — this is the case. If Hal kept his copy, and if his family can confirm it, this is the whole case."

"I don't know if he kept anything," I said. "He'd be —"

"Eighty-eight. In Kansas. We'll find out. One thing at a time. Tonight, photograph it. And Ethan?"

"Yes."

"Well done for keeping the drawer."

I photographed the pages at the kitchen table under the good light and sent them. Then I put the letter back in its clip exactly as I had found it. Court dates were still ahead, but the shape of the thing had changed. Karen had not merely been wrong about the past. She had been written to, as president of that board, and told. And she had gone on driving through my mornings anyway.

Dana's advice was methodical: we would not approach Harold Brennan cold. We would go through his family, put everything in writing, and let his own lawyer handle anything requiring a signature, because a man of eighty-eight in assisted living deserved that care and because a statement taken properly was worth ten taken in a hurry.

Finding June Brennan Cole took Dana's paralegal less than a day. June was Hal's daughter, living in Salina, Kansas, not far from the facility where her father now lived. I wrote the first letter myself, on Dana's draft, and mailed it rather than calling. A letter can be read twice and shown to a father and a lawyer. A phone call from a stranger about a lawsuit cannot be taken back.

I told her who I was, that I had bought her father's land, that I was in litigation with the Aspen Hollow HOA over the road, and that I had found, in my closing papers, a copy of a letter her father had written to that board on March 12, 2019. I enclosed a copy of my copy. I asked whether her father had kept his own copy, and whether the story in the letter was as he remembered it.

June called me nine days later. I knew it was Kansas from the number and picked up standing in the kitchen, for no reason I could explain.

"Mr. Carter," she said, "this is June Cole. I've read your letter three times. And I've been to see my father."

What she told me over the next half hour filled in the parts of the story that even Hal's letter, careful as it was, had left as outline.

In the summer of 2011, the county lane washed out in a hard rain — a culvert gone and a stretch of road closed for most of a season while the county found the money. Her father, who had farmed the Briar Creek land for forty years, told a handful of neighbors they could cut across his property to reach town. Mostly on foot, down the service track. Two families, for a while, in vehicles. "It was the kind of thing Dad thought you simply did," June said. "It was never a road for the public. It was Dad saying, 'Come through my place until yours is fixed.' When the lane reopened, most people stopped."

She told me what changed. In 2018 the developers finishing Aspen Hollow began putting out their sales materials, and a neighbor brought her father a brochure. In it, a map showed his track, colored in like a park path, labeled creek trail access, listed among the amenities of a development he had never agreed to be an amenity of. "I have never seen my father as angry as he was about that brochure," June said. "Not about the crossing. About being advertised. About his kindness being printed up and sold with houses."

So in March of 2019 he wrote the letter. He wrote it himself, though his lawyer looked it over. He hand-delivered it to the association office because he wanted a person, not a mailbox, to receive it. And he kept his copy — "Dad kept everything," she said. That night she scanned her father's retained copy and emailed it to Dana and to me. Same letter. Same date. Same signature, firmer than in my photocopy. On his copy there was also a handwritten note in the margin, recording the day and hour of delivery and the name of the person at the office who had taken it.

News in the same category

PART2 The HOA Karen Used My Private Road Every Morning — So I Installed a Gate Before Sunrise

30 Part