PART2 The HOA Karen Used My Private Road Every Morning — So I Installed a Gate Before Sunrise

Chapter 27

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Greg Halvorsen walked his fence line most evenings and had taken to waving when he saw me at the pond. He had been told a story, believed it, apologized when shown the paper, and stood up in a public meeting to ask the question nobody else would ask. If generosity has a proper first recipient, it is a man like that — not because he earned a right, but because he would understand it was not one.

I did not decide that night. I decided slowly, over about a week of mornings, most of them unguarded. On the last of those mornings, I got a sheet of paper and wrote at the top, in my own hand: Permission — walking only. Then I called Dana, because a man who has learned anything about permission learns to put it in writing properly, with a lawyer reading the draft.

"Revocable at will, on thirty days' notice or immediately for cause," she said, reading it back. "You'd be surprised how many people give a thing and forget to keep the string attached."

"I kept the string in view the whole time," I said. "That's the entire document, really. The string."

Dana returned the draft with two sentences changed and one added, which is about as close to praise as lawyers come. I printed it on plain paper, two copies, and drove them over to Aspen Hollow on a Saturday morning — through the public entrance on County Road 9, like any other visitor, which was a route I had by then some sympathy for. Fourteen minutes is fourteen minutes. It is not, however, a right.

Linda Marsh met me in the management office, where Debbie Hart, at the front desk, looked up and then, after a moment, smiled in a way that reached her properly for the first time since I had known her. "Mr. Carter," she said. "It's a quieter building these days."

"It suits it," I said.

Linda read the document standing up, then sat down and read it again, which I took as respect for the paper. It was short, as Dana and I had intended. I granted permission to residents of Aspen Hollow, and their accompanied guests, to walk the old service track — on foot only, in daylight hours, staying to the track, no vehicles, no fires, no litter, dogs on a leash. The permission was a license, not an easement, created no right, and could be revoked by me at any time, in writing, on notice to the Association. Anyone who drove the road was still a trespasser, and the injunction still said so in a judge's language that did not require my courtesy to enforce it.

"You've thought about how this will be read," Linda said.

"I've thought about how the last one was read," I said. "That's why this one says everything twice, in different words."

She signed the Association's acknowledgment, I signed both copies, and she put one in the office safe and one in an envelope for the next newsletter, where it would be printed in full, so that no one could later remember it as more than it was.

"There will be people who test it," she said, honestly. "Somebody's nephew with a dirt bike, most likely. When that happens, tell me first, before the sheriff. Not because you owe me that — you don't — but because I would like the chance to be the kind of board that handles it."

"That's fair," I said. "And if it keeps happening, Linda, the paper comes back. That's in there too."

"It is. I read that part twice." She walked me to the door. "You didn't have to do this at all. The board knows that. I want it minuted that the board knows that."

"Minute it however you like," I said. "Just print the terms where people can see them."

Greg Halvorsen was among the first to walk it, the following Sunday, in the late afternoon when the light goes long across the pond. I saw him from the porch — a man in a canvas hat, unhurried, staying to the track the way the paper said, a pair of binoculars around his neck that I suspected were mostly an excuse. At the pond he stopped and looked for a while at the heron that had taken up residence on the far bank, a gray, patient bird that had opinions about fishermen. Then Greg lifted a hand and waved, not the wave of a man exercising a right, but the wave of a neighbor who knows whose ground he is standing on and is glad to have been asked onto it, in the only sense that mattered — by permission.

I waved back. It cost me nothing. That was rather the point of the whole document: what is given freely costs the giver nothing he has not chosen to spend. What is taken costs everyone, eventually, and the bill in my case had come to thirty thousand four hundred dollars of other people's money and a year of my mornings.

A few others came in the weeks after. A woman with a leashed spaniel, who stayed to the track. Two older men who walked at the pace of a long conversation. A father with a small girl who stopped to watch the heron, and who held her hand a little tighter near the pond, which told me he had read the terms like a parent and not like a claimant.

The dirt bike came, as Linda had predicted, on a Friday evening — a nephew, as predicted. I called Linda first, as agreed. By Saturday noon she had called back: the boy had been spoken to, his uncle rather more firmly, and the Association had reminded all homeowners that the permission was on foot only and its loss would be on its users. The track stayed clean. The permission stayed in force. A system, once again, had worked as written.

News in the same category

PART2 The HOA Karen Used My Private Road Every Morning — So I Installed a Gate Before Sunrise

30 Part