PART2 The HOA Karen Used My Private Road Every Morning — So I Installed a Gate Before Sunrise

Chapter 9

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Karen Whitmore had signed it. Her own name, in blue ink, under the title President, Aspen Hollow Homeowners Association, and below that, smaller, the name of her brokerage — the two jobs sharing one signature.

There were enclosures. The letter listed them the way lawyers list exhibits.

The first was a copy of something titled Aspen Hollow Access Resolution 2021-04. It was two pages, with a seal I suspected the Association had ordered for itself, and a row of WHEREAS clauses marching down the page. Whereas the developer had intended a connected community. Whereas residents had historically accessed the creek and the county lane by the Briar Creek route. Whereas the board had a duty to preserve community amenities. Therefore be it resolved that the route was designated a community access route, and that the Association would maintain and defend residents' use of it. It was dated three years before I bought the place. It had been passed, signed, and filed in the HOA's own minutes book, and I had the distinct feeling, reading it at my kitchen table, that everyone involved had treated that as the end of the question. They had voted themselves a road.

The second enclosure was the map. It was a copy of a copy, the lines a little soft, the lettering in that cheerful rounded type developers use when they're selling a lifestyle rather than lots. It showed Aspen Hollow laid out in its curving streets, the creek drawn in as a blue ribbon, and a dashed line running from the back of the development across the parcel that was now mine, down to the county lane. Someone — I didn't have to guess who — had gone over the dashed line with a yellow highlighter. In the margin, in the map's own printed legend, the dashed line was labeled: creek trail access.

Not a road. Not an easement. A trail, on a sales picture, highlighted in yellow.

I read the whole packet twice. Then I did what I'd learned to do in freight when a claim arrived with a lot of paper attached: I checked what was missing. There was no deed reference. No book and page number from the county records. No recorded instrument of any kind, nothing with a clerk's stamp on it. For a claim about land, it was a packet with no land records in it. Just the Association's own resolution about my property, and a picture from a brochure.

Outside the window the pond was flat and gray. It was 9:15 in the morning. The white SUV had already been through at 6:44, on schedule, while I was making coffee, and I had written it in the log out of habit, the way you clock a trailer into a bay.

I called Dana Whitaker's office and told her receptionist I had something to bring in.

"Bring the envelope too," Dana said, when she came on the line herself. "Postmark and all. And don't answer it. Not a word, Ethan. Paper like that isn't written to persuade you. It's written to be found later, by somebody else, looking like you were told. So we answer it the same way — on paper, once, correctly."

I put the letter and its enclosures in a folder, and I wrote the date and the postmark on the folder in pencil. Then I sat a while with the map in front of me, looking at that yellow line crossing land I mowed, land I paid tax on, land with my name on the deed in the courthouse drawer.

Somebody had drawn it as a trail on a brochure years before I ever heard of Briar Creek. Somebody else had voted to call it a right. And every weekday morning at 6:40, a white SUV drove down it to make both of those things feel true.

Dana Whitaker read the packet the way she read everything I brought her: once fast, once slow, with a pencil that never touched the page until the second pass.

Her office was over the hardware store in town, up a flight of stairs that smelled of cut keys and floor wax, and she had a window that looked down on Main Street and a desk with nothing on it that didn't belong to a file. Mine was getting thick by then. She set the HOA letter on top of it, weighted the resolution with her coffee mug, and laid the highlighted map out flat under the lamp like evidence at an inquest.

"All right," she said. "Point by point, so you know exactly what you're holding. This resolution first."

She tapped the seal with one fingernail.

"An HOA is a private corporation with a contract. Its members agree to its rules when they buy in, and its board can pass resolutions all day long — about its own common areas, its own members, its own money. What it cannot do is pass a resolution about your land. You never joined. You never signed their covenants. You are, legally, a stranger to them. This document has exactly the same authority over your road as a resolution passed by the Rotary Club. It binds the people who passed it. It grants them nothing they didn't already have, and what they had was nothing."

"The board voted on it, though," I said. "Three years ago. Before I bought."

News in the same category

PART2 The HOA Karen Used My Private Road Every Morning — So I Installed a Gate Before Sunrise

30 Part