Vivian's face altered, not softening exactly, but losing its certainty about what kind of attack was coming. "You read our file."
"I read many files during the purchase. It was my responsibility to understand who flew with us, and why they stayed, and why some stopped. Your name came up often, and almost always with gratitude from the staff. I am not going to pretend otherwise now because we have disagreed about a seat."
"Then you understand," Vivian said, with quick, unsteady relief, "that this seat has been mine. Not on paper, perhaps, but in practice. When you fly this often, the small continuities are the whole point. The same seat, the same outlook. I asked for a courtesy that has always been extended."
"You asked for another passenger to be moved," Eleanor said. "That is the part we have to look at plainly. Not the preference, which is understandable. I have my own habits when I travel. What you asked for was that I should lose my seat so you would not have to lose your habit, and you asked it as if my agreement were not required. You did not speak to me. You spoke about me, to Sofia and then to Captain Mercer, as if the decision belonged to everyone except the person sitting here."
"You were already serious to me," she told Vivian. "Thirty-seven flights is a fact, and I honor it. If loyalty means anything in a service company, it has to mean we have learned how to look after people. It cannot mean we have learned which people we are allowed to overlook."
Eleanor turned to Mercer. "Captain."
He straightened, out of habit more than defiance. No one in the cabin doubted his skill at the controls, and Eleanor never confused the two kinds of competence.
"I know something about your record as well. Three guest complaints in the last eighteen months."
Mercer's jaw tightened. "Complaints are part of this job. Passengers complain about turbulence, about catering, about delays they think we have chosen personally."
"These were not about turbulence, or catering, or delays. I remember them because they were alike. In the first, a man travelling with his adult daughter was seated forward. Another passenger boarded later and said the seat was where he preferred to sit. You asked the man, not the newcomer, to move to the rear. He did. His complaint was closed without a formal response. The note on the file called it a service preference."
"In the second, a woman travelling alone was moved from a forward seat for a couple who flew with the company often. She was told it would only be for takeoff, which was not true. She wrote that she had paid for her ticket in the same currency as everyone else, and that no one asked her name at any point. Her complaint was answered with a voucher and a paragraph that did not mention the seat at all."
"The third was a younger man travelling to see a parent in hospital. Another passenger wanted his seat. You came aft, as you came aft today. He said you did not ask what had happened and did not look at any document. You told him experienced travellers understood how these things worked. He moved, and his complaint was filed under the same phrase as the first. A service preference."
Mercer stared at his folder. "Those accounts are one-sided. That is why we do not conduct trials in the cabin."
"No, and we have not conducted one today. They will be looked at properly, with your account included, and with the records preserved. I am telling you I read them before I ever booked this seat, and I recognized the scene when it began to happen to me. The request presented as a routine. The attendant left to carry a message she should never have been asked to carry. The captain arriving with his decision already made. The passenger in the seat treated as the obstacle to a smooth departure."
"Your failure today was not that you failed to recognize me," she said. "If you had known my name at the door, you would have behaved differently. You would have checked, and asked, and found a gracious way to talk to Mrs. Hartley about the chart. That would not have made the behaviour right. It would only have made it better aimed."