The days settled into a pattern that surprised the staff more than any announcement could have done. Eleanor attended the meetings she was asked to attend, asked questions that were mostly about numbers, thanked people and left on time. Then, in the evenings, when the floor emptied and the cleaners began their rounds, she stayed at her borrowed desk with the complaint files. She had asked for them in their original form wherever they survived, not the summaries prepared for due diligence, which she now understood to have been a tidier document than the truth. What arrived was boxes and scanned folders and forwarded chains of messages, some complete and some with gaps that were themselves informative. Dana Whitfield, to her credit, did not attempt to curate them once she understood Eleanor would notice. She had them delivered, box by box, and on the second evening stayed late herself to show Eleanor how the logging system worked, how a complaint was coded, who could amend a code, and who could close a file. Only once, looking at a screen she had clearly seen many times, did she say she had not liked some of what the system allowed. Eleanor asked why she had not changed it. Dana said changing it had never been her decision to make. She said it not defensively but as a fact about how the building had worked, and Eleanor wrote it down.
Reading complaints is a particular kind of labour. Each one was short, most were polite beyond what the circumstances probably deserved, and almost all came from people who flew with Ascendia once or twice and never again. A man moved from a seat he had chosen because another passenger preferred it, and told, he wrote, as if the arrangement were already settled. A woman travelling with her elderly father, reseated at the rear so that a regular client could have the forward cabin to himself, who described being spoken to kindly throughout, which somehow made it worse, because there was no single rude sentence she could point to. Eleanor read each file to the end, including the internal notes, which were never meant for the complainant's eyes and were therefore the most honest pages in the building. It was in those notes, late on the third evening, with rain beginning against the glass and her coffee cold beside the keyboard, that the pattern stopped being an impression and became something she could trace with a finger.
Certain client names recurred. Not many, perhaps a dozen across three years, but they appeared again and again at the top of files that had begun as someone else's grievance. A seat reassigned here, a boarding order changed there, a crew member's account annotated with a reminder of how many flights that client represented each year. Certain complaints died in the same place. Again and again the file travelled upwards, was acknowledged courteously, and then landed in one inbox, belonging to one of two senior managers, where it rested until it was closed. The closures used a small vocabulary that repeated until the words lost their meaning. Service preference. Matter resolved with the client. No further action, relationship considerations. And again and again, in margin notes and forwarded messages, in different hands across different years, the same four words appeared, offered as an instruction, a justification and occasionally as a warning. Protect the relationship. Eleanor sat back and looked at the phrase on the screen until it seemed to belong less to any individual file than to the building itself. Nobody, she thought, had ever needed to order a captain to move a quiet woman out of her seat. They had only needed to repeat, for years, in every decision that reached him, whose comfort the company could not afford to lose, and whose it plainly could. She opened a fresh notebook, wrote the date at the top of the page, and began, methodically, to list every file in which those four words appeared.
The inquiry began the morning after the flight, in a windowless conference room at Ascendia's operations centre, with printed seat charts, a recorder no one quite trusted, and a standing instruction from Eleanor that no witness would be told what any other witness had said. Dana Whitfield led the interviews. Rachel Kim sat beside her, taking notes in a hand so small and even that the pages looked printed. Marcus Bell attended only the first session, to place on record what he had heard over the radio, and then withdrew, so no one could later claim operations had shaped the answers.
The first document was the simplest. The seat-chart file for Odyssey Seven showed Eleanor Voss in the front-left seat and Vivian Hartley directly across the aisle, exactly as Sofia Reyes had loaded it before boarding. It carried a time stamp and no annotation suggesting Mrs. Hartley's preference for that seat had ever been promised or approved. The second document was harder to find, not because it was hidden in any dramatic sense, but because it lived in a part of the client system that cabin crew were never formally shown and were nonetheless expected to understand.