Their father sometimes joined them on those evenings, sitting a little apart, smoking slowly, saying almost nothing. Once, after a long silence, he had said, "You boys are building something that will outlast both of you if you do it right." Thomas had laughed and said, "That's the plan, Dad." Roy had not laughed. He had thought about the words for a long time afterward, turning them over in his mind the way he turned a part over in his hands, looking for the flaw. He had not understood then. He understood now. The bike had outlasted the shed, the argument, and Thomas himself, carrying a letter for twenty-seven years, waiting for someone to look in the right place.
Ava was quiet too, and Roy could see her thinking, fitting the pieces together. "He hid the cigarettes," she said at last, "but he also hid the bike's secret. He was good at hiding things."
He was, Roy said. "Too good. He hid the good things right along with the foolish ones, and then he forgot how to tell the difference."
Thomas turned twenty-one in the spring, and the fight with their father came not long after, hard and fast and ugly in the way only a fight between a father and a son who love each other can be. Roy had never told anyone the exact words, and he did not tell Ava all of them now, because some words belonged to the people who had spoken them and to the room they had been spoken in, and repeating them would only give them a second life they did not deserve. But he told her enough.
It was about the road, Roy said. "About Thomas wanting to leave and Dad wanting him to stay. Dad thought the shop and the farm equipment and the shed were enough. Thomas thought they were a cage. They both said things they didn't mean, and they both meant the things they said underneath the words they didn't mean. It was the kind of fight where cruel words find exactly the places they can hurt most."
Ava listened without interrupting, her hands still folded, her eyes steady. She had heard fights like that before, Roy guessed, in her own house, in her own life, and she knew better than to ask for details that would only make the telling harder.
Thomas left the next morning, Roy said. "He didn't slam the door. He didn't shout. He just packed a bag, put it on the blue Harley, and rode away. I stood in the yard and watched him go, and I kept thinking he would turn around at the end of the driveway. He didn't. He just kept going, smaller and smaller, until the dust settled and he was gone."
Roy had assumed he would return. A week. A month. Christmas. He had waited by the phone that first summer, and he had checked the mailbox every day, and he had ridden his own bicycle to the end of the road more times than he could count, just to see if a midnight-blue motorcycle was coming back over the hill. It never did.
Six months after he left, a letter came. One letter. Roy could still see it in his mind — the envelope thin, the handwriting loose, the postmark from a town he had never heard of. Thomas wrote that he was okay. He wrote that he had found work. He wrote that Roy should not look for him.
So you stopped? Ava asked, and Roy's face tightened, the way it always did when he remembered that part.
No, he said. "I didn't stop. I looked for years. I searched motorcycle clubs. I went to repair shops and asked if anyone had seen a midnight-blue Harley with a certain dent in the tank. I went to rallies and walked the rows of bikes, looking for that paint, that frame, that seat. Whenever someone mentioned a blue Harley, I followed the rumour. I drove to towns I had no reason to go to. I called numbers that led nowhere. I wrote letters to shops that never wrote back."
He had searched because he could not do anything else. Thomas was his brother, and his brother was gone, and the not knowing was worse than any bad news would have been. At least bad news would have been an ending. Silence was not an ending. Silence was a door left open in a storm.
Did you ever think he was dead? Ava asked softly.
Roy was quiet for a long moment. "I thought about it," he said at last. "I tried not to. But after a few years, after no letters and no calls and no rumours that led anywhere, I started to think it. Not all at once. Just a little, every year, like rust. I told myself he was probably fine, probably married, probably happy somewhere. But in the back of my mind, I kept thinking, what if he's not? What if he's gone and I never knew?"
Dan had told Ava earlier, when she first walked in, that he thought Roy's brother had died when they were kids. Roy corrected that gently now, not with anger, but with the tired patience of a man who had heard the mistake before and understood why people made it. "He didn't die when we were kids," Roy said. "He left when he was twenty-one. He was alive. At least, I believed he was alive. I had to believe it, or I would have stopped looking, and I wasn't ready to stop looking."
The years passed. Roy got older. He opened his own shop. He joined the Iron Wolves. He rode and worked and lived, and the searching became quieter, less frantic, more like a habit than a mission. He still asked, when he met an old rider, "You ever see a midnight-blue Harley, custom frame, built by two brothers in Texas?" And the old rider would shake his head, and Roy would nod, and they would move on to other things. But he never stopped asking entirely. He never stopped listening for that paint, that engine, that shape.