Yes, Roy said, because she had asked him not to explain, but she had not asked him to lie.
Rebecca looked at him. "You don't defend him."
I loved my brother, Roy said. "That doesn't mean everything he did was right. Your mother said the same thing, didn't she, Ava? That was what you told me in the shop. Your mom said the same thing."
Ava nodded. "She did."
Rebecca looked down at the letters again. "He was a coward," she said, and the word landed in the kitchen like a plate set down too hard. "He was a coward about the things that mattered most. He could weld anything. He could fix anything. He could build a motorcycle out of junk. But he couldn't knock on a door."
Roy thought about Thomas sitting across the street from his garage for almost an hour, two years ago, watching him and then driving away. He thought about the letters, stamped and never mailed, sitting in a storage unit in Red Creek while Rebecca lived her life a few miles away. He thought about his own years of searching, and about how searching was also a kind of not-knocking, a way of looking without ever having to stand in front of someone and say, I'm here, I'm sorry, I stayed away too long.
He was afraid, Roy said quietly. "That doesn't make it right. But I think it's true."
Rebecca did not argue. She opened another letter. This one made her pause longer. Roy watched her read it twice, her lips moving very slightly on the second reading, as if she were trying the words out in her own mouth.
He says he's sorry, she said. "He says it in every letter, in different words. I'm sorry. I should have come. I should have written. I should have called. He says it so many times it starts to sound like he thought saying it was the same as doing it."
Maybe he did think that, Roy said. "Maybe that's the saddest part."
Ava reached across the table and put her hand over her mother's hand. Rebecca did not pull away. She turned her hand over and held Ava's, and for a moment the three of them sat in the kitchen with the letters between them and the kettle cooling on the stove and the clock ticking on the wall, and no one tried to make the moment into something it was not.
I need to stop for now, Rebecca said at last. She closed the container lid, gently, and set the letters she had read in a neat pile beside it. "I'll read the rest. But not tonight. Not all at once. If I read them all at once, I'll be angry at a dead man all night, and I don't want to be angry all night. I want to be — I want to think."
Roy nodded. "Take as long as you need. They're yours. They'll be here."
Rebecca looked at the second container, the photographs, and then at the third, the bank documents. She did not open either one yet.
Tomorrow, she said. "I'll look at the pictures tomorrow. And the bank papers. Tonight is enough."
Ava stood up and began to clear the table, moving the containers to the sideboard with careful hands. Roy helped her, lifting the heavier one and setting it down where Rebecca pointed. When the table was clear again, Rebecca stood in the middle of her kitchen and looked at the two of them, and Roy saw that she was tired in a way that had nothing to do with work.
Thank you for bringing them, she said. "I mean that. Even if I'm angry. Thank you."
Roy nodded. He did not say you're welcome, because that would have sounded too easy. He said, "I'll be at the shop tomorrow, if you need anything. Or if you don't. Either way."
Rebecca walked them to the door. Ava hugged her mother, long and tight, and Rebecca held her close, her eyes closed. Then Ava stepped back, and Rebecca looked at Roy.
Good night, Roy, she said.
Good night, Rebecca, he said.
He walked to the truck with Ava beside him, and the porch light stayed on behind them, and the wind chime moved once in the dark, like a spoon touching glass.
Roy did not sleep well that night. He lay in his bed above the shop — no, not above the shop, in the small room behind it, where he had lived for years among spare parts and old manuals and a coffee maker that gurgled like a sick animal — and he listened to the sounds of the building settling. The blue Harley was back in the center of the garage, where it had been that afternoon, only now the sale papers were gone from the workbench and Harold Finch had gone home without a motorcycle and without any hard feelings, which was more than Roy could say for most deals that fell through.
He thought about Rebecca reading the letters. He thought about the way she had said, he was a coward, and the way she had not taken it back, and the way she had still said thank you for bringing them. He thought about Thomas, and about the difference between a man who writes I'm sorry fifty times and a man who knocks on a door once. He thought about his own life, and about the doors he had not knocked on, and about the years he had spent riding and searching and telling himself that searching was the same as finding.