Ava nodded, and Roy knelt down in front of the first container and undid the latches, and the lid came off with a soft pop, and the smell of old paper rose up to meet them, dry and faintly sweet, like the inside of a library that had been closed for a long time, like the inside of a house where someone had lived alone and kept everything, and Roy knew, before he even looked inside, that whatever was in that container was going to change the way he thought about his brother, and about his niece, and about himself, and he was ready for it, or as ready as a sixty-one-year-old man could be, standing in a storage unit in Red Creek with a sixteen-year-old girl beside him and a brass key still warm in his pocket.
The first container was full of letters. Not a few letters, not a shoebox of them, but dozens, stacked in neat bundles and tied with string, each envelope addressed in Thomas Hale's handwriting to the same name, over and over, in ink that had faded from black to brown: Rebecca. Roy lifted the top bundle out carefully, as if it might fall apart in his hands, and he saw that most of the envelopes had stamps on them, crooked and old, the kind of stamps that had cost a few cents when Thomas had bought them, and none of them had a postmark. None of them had ever been mailed.
Ava stared at them. "My mom never saw these," she said, and it was not a question. It was a fact she was saying out loud so she could believe it, and Roy heard the anger underneath it, and the grief, and the confusion, all tangled together the way they always were when a person learned that love had been there all along but had never found a way to arrive.
Roy untied the string on the top bundle and lifted out the first letter. The paper inside was thin and yellowed at the edges, and Thomas's handwriting was smaller than Roy remembered, more careful, as if he had been trying to write slowly enough to get the words right. He read the first few lines silently, then, because Ava was watching him and because he did not want to keep anything from her that belonged to her family, he read them aloud, his voice low and steady in the small concrete room.
Dear Rebecca, he read. "You are seven today. I know because I counted. I bought you a birthday card in town, and then I put it in a drawer because I did not know where to send it. Your mother said not to come around, and I told myself I was respecting that, but the truth is I was afraid. I was afraid you would look at me the way your mother looks at me, like a man who left and should stay left."
Ava's hands tightened on the strap of her backpack. Roy put the letter down and picked up another, from a different bundle, a little thicker, a little later in the stack. "Dear Rebecca," he read again. "You are twelve. I saw your school picture in the paper. You won something for science. I cut it out and put it in my wallet, and then I took it out because I was afraid someone at work would ask who you were, and I would not know what to say."
Roy paused and looked at the handwriting again, at the way the letters leaned a little to the right when Thomas was excited and stood straighter when he was trying to be careful. He could see his brother in those small changes, the talkative boy who had always moved too fast and the older man who had learned to slow down, and he wondered how many evenings Thomas had sat at a table like this one, with a pen in his hand and a photograph on the table beside him, trying to find the words that would make a daughter understand that her father had not forgotten her, even when he had not been there to prove it. The letters were not angry. They were not full of excuses. They were full of small, ordinary details, the kind of details a father would notice if he had been watching from a distance: a lost tooth, a new bicycle, a teacher's name, a song on the radio that reminded him of Texas.
Ava listened with her eyes closed for a moment, as if she were trying to hear her grandfather's voice behind Roy's voice, and when she opened them again they were bright with tears she was still refusing to let fall. "He remembered all of it," she said. "He remembered the science fair. Mom told me about that. She said she won second place and she was so mad she cried in the car. She never knew Grandpa knew. She thought nobody outside our house knew."
He read a third, and a fourth, and each one was the same in its shape and different in its details: a birthday missed, a school play he had heard about from a neighbor, a Christmas when he had bought a gift and left it in the trunk of his car until spring, a summer when he had driven past Sarah's house and seen Rebecca riding a bicycle in the driveway and had kept driving because he did not know how to stop. Thomas had not been silent because he had forgotten. He had been silent because he had practiced forgetting, and the practice had not worked, and the letters were the proof that it had not worked, stacked in plastic containers in a storage unit in Red Creek, waiting for someone brave enough to open them.