It had been a Thursday night, around eleven-thirty, about three weeks before the incident. Two dogs had been barking in Linda's garage, not the occasional bark of a dog startled by a noise, but the continuous, rolling barking of animals that would not settle, going on and on until it filled the whole back of the house. Lucas had school in the morning. Daniel had lain awake listening to it, and finally he had gotten up, put on his shoes, and walked over next door. He knocked, and Linda answered the door wearing pajamas, her hair loose, looking annoyed at being woken and then quickly rearranging her face into something more reasonable when she saw who it was.
He told her the barking had to stop. He said it plainly, not angrily, because he was tired and he wanted to go back to bed, and he did not want a fight with a neighbor at midnight. Linda said, "They'll be gone tomorrow."
Daniel said, "There are new dogs every week."
That was when her face hardened. Not dramatically, not into shouting, but into something closed and flat, the way a person's face goes when they have decided you are not on their side anymore. She looked at him for a moment, and then she said, "You should worry about your own dog."
At the time, Daniel had thought she meant Cooper barked too. Cooper barely barked anymore at twelve, but every dog barks sometimes, and Daniel had taken it as a deflection, the kind of thing people say when they do not want to talk about their own problem so they point at yours instead. He had gone home. The barking had eventually stopped that night. He had not thought about the sentence again until now, sitting in his kitchen with Maya on the phone, hearing it come back to him with a different weight on it.
There had been one more part of that conversation, and Daniel told Maya about that too, because it mattered now in a way it had not mattered then. Before she closed the door, Linda had asked him about Cooper and the fence. Something like, "Old dogs pick up anything. You might want to watch what yours eats." Daniel remembered the phrasing because it had struck him as odd even at the time, a strange thing to say to a man who has just come over to complain about barking. Why bring up what Cooper ate? Cooper ate his dry food from his bowl in the kitchen. He did not pick things up near the fence. He barely went near the fence except to lie in the sun beside it. But Linda had said it, casually, as if it were ordinary neighborly advice, and then she had closed the door, and Daniel had walked home across the dark yard thinking less about what she said and more about how glad he was that the barking had stopped.
Maya went quiet on the phone. Not the quiet of someone who has stopped listening. The quiet of someone who has just heard something slot into place. Daniel waited. He could hear, faintly, the sound of a pen or a keyboard on her end, or maybe just the stillness of an office. He did not rush her. He had learned, in the last two days, that rushing people who were trying to be careful only made them less careful.
After a moment, Maya asked him about the bucket. She asked whether Linda knew he stored the feed bucket beside the shed. Daniel said probably. The bucket sat out in the open, beside the shed, visible from the fence line. Anyone standing in Linda's yard, or walking along the shared boundary, could see it without trying. There was nothing hidden about it. It was just there, the way garden tools and old buckets are just there in people's yards.