Maya asked whether he used that bucket for food. Daniel told her the history of it, because the history mattered. Years ago, when Cooper was younger, Daniel had sometimes carried kibble from the garage out to the shed in that bucket, back when the dry food bags were stored in the garage and the shed was where he kept the scoops and the extra bowls. That had been a long time ago, back when Cooper was still young enough to run for a ball without thinking about his hips first. Lately the bucket had held other things. Gardening gloves, mostly, the worn pair Daniel used for pruning, and tennis balls, the ones Lucas and Cooper used to play fetch with before Cooper's hips made running less fun. The balls had lived in that bucket for years, a familiar rattling sound whenever Daniel moved it, until Lucas took them to school for something, a game or a project, Daniel could not remember which, and nobody had put anything back in since. So the bucket had been sitting there beside the shed, empty, ordinary, unremarkable, for anyone to see, and Daniel realized as he described it that the emptiness was part of what made it useful to someone else. An empty bucket beside a shed does not draw attention. It waits. It looks like it belongs exactly where it is, and it looks like it is waiting to be filled with whatever a person expects a feed bucket to hold.
Daniel stopped talking, and as he stopped he felt the cold feeling arrive. It started in his stomach and moved outward, the way a realization does when it is not a thought so much as a physical sensation. Anyone looking over the fence could assume that bucket was still a feed bucket. It looked like a feed bucket. It had been a feed bucket once. It sat where a feed bucket would sit. A person who wanted to make it look like a dog had been fed something dangerous would not need to find a special container or a hidden spot. They would only need to look at that bucket, sitting there in the open, and see what it could be made to look like. And a person who wanted someone else to be blamed would want the thing to look as obvious as possible. A metal bucket. Meat inside it. A sick dog nearby. A neighbor pointing and shouting.
Daniel said none of that to Maya, not in those words. He just told her the facts, and he let the facts sit there. Maya said, "I'm still gathering information." She said it the way she had said everything else, evenly, without promising him an outcome. Daniel understood that. He had come to respect the way Maya worked, the way she did not touch the meat or smell it or guess, the way she looked at the wall of the bucket instead of the drama in the middle of it. She was gathering information. That was her job. His job was to give her true things and let her do it.
But after he hung up, Daniel sat in the kitchen for a long time with the phone in his hand, thinking about the Thursday night three weeks earlier. He thought about the walk over, too, the part he had not described to Maya because she had not asked about it. The street had been quiet except for the barking, which had seemed louder outside than it had through his bedroom wall, rolling out of Linda's garage in waves. He had stood on her porch for a moment before knocking, telling himself to keep it short and civil, because a midnight argument with a neighbor helps nobody and he knew it even tired. He remembered the porch light, and the way Linda's face had changed when she saw him, annoyance giving way to something more managed, and he remembered thinking at the time that she was a person who did not like being caught off guard. He had not thought about that again until now. Now it sat alongside everything else, another small detail that had seemed like nothing at the time and now refused to stay nothing.
"You should worry about your own dog." "Old dogs pick up anything. You might want to watch what yours eats." At the time those had sounded like deflections, like a neighbor who did not want to deal with barking dogs changing the subject. Now they sounded like something else. They sounded like a person testing an idea out loud, or planting one, or maybe just thinking ahead to a story she might need later. Daniel did not know which one it was. He was careful, even in his own head, not to turn a memory into a certainty just because it frightened him. But he could not unhear the sentences now, and he could not pretend they had been meaningless small talk. Three weeks before Cooper got sick, Linda had talked about what Cooper ate, and about worrying about his own dog, and Daniel had walked home and forgotten it. That was the part that stayed with him. He had forgotten it, because at the time there had been nothing to remember it for.