Russ had read Curtis's letter enough times that it had lost its power to
surprise him, which was not the same as losing its power. Curtis had written
it to the court three days after the wallet came out of the fairing — three days
after deputies stood in Bay 1 and held a complete wallet up to the light —
and in it he had doubled down: the boy was a thief, the boy had taken the
June money and in Curtis's belief the wallet as well, the shop man was
turning the boy against his own blood. The judge read it in silence, set it
down precisely on the corner of the file, and Russ understood that the letter,
too, had been entered — not by Marta. By its author. Then she said, "Mr.
Laird, I'd like to hear from you."
Curtis testified fairly — not a monster out of a melodrama, and the
courtroom did not make him into one, but a night-shift man with a ruined
back and a dead sister, in a shirt ironed by a man not practiced at ironing,
answering in a voice that kept trying to be reasonable about things that would
not stay reasonable under him.
The garage was the room he had. That was his testimony, in substance, said
without flinching and without decoration: when his sister died, he had a
one-bedroom house and a boy arriving with two trash bags of clothes and a
grief the size of the state; the garage was dry, it was his, it was what he could
80
make ready in a weekend; the boy had never complained; and the room down
the hall that counsel kept referring to was his late mother's sewing room, and
he had not — here his voice did something it had not done — been able to
make himself change it. Russ sat very still. He knew about rooms that stayed
as they were left. It did not excuse the cot or the heater or the concrete, and
he did not let it; but it located the man, and he filed the location where he
would need it later, when the boy asked questions he was not yet old enough
to ask.
The warehouse was the boy earning his keep, Curtis said, the way Curtis
himself had been raised — his father had put him on a loading dock at
thirteen and it had made a man of him. He had not thought of it as labor, only
as the family economy, the boy folded into the work of the house as Curtis
had been folded into his father's. The judge asked, mildly, whether the family
economy had included paying the boy. Curtis said the boy's keep was his
pay. The judge wrote something down, and the writing-down made a small
sound in the room like a latch.
The casino was a weakness. He said the word himself before counsel could
soften it into one. Once a month, twice; he wasn't proud. And June — the
accusation — was a panic, and his account of it came out in the order of a
man narrating the closing of a door from inside the room. The money was
gone from the envelope. The boy was nearest. He said it to the caseworker,
on the phone, on a Sunday — and once he had said it, the sentence stood
there with his name under it, and every day afterward the cost of unsaying it
had gone up like a storage fee, and he had paid the interest instead, in the
coin of letting it stand. "I couldn't find the door back out of the sentence,"
Curtis said. "I know how that sounds." The judge let him finish. She let the
silence after it finish too. "It sounds," she said at last, "like the most accurate
81
thing you've said today, Mr. Laird. It will be weighed as such. It does not
weigh what you might hope."
His counsel's argument, when it came, reduced to blood and sequence, as
Marta had said it would. He was the mother's brother. The placement
predated the petitioner; the boy had come to Curtis first, by family right and
the department's own initial judgment. The petitioner, counsel said, kindly,
was a widower keeping a childless house, running a business that kept a boy
around truck traffic, raised vehicles, and solvents. The failures shown were
the failures of a poor man, not an unfit one, and poverty was not a
disqualification the law recognized. Russ listened to childless house go past,
felt it land where it was aimed, and did not let it move him visibly. Cara was
twenty-six years of evidence against that sentence — a whole childhood
raised above those bays, in that traffic, by that widower — and advocate's
sentences were not under oath. The testimony is the record, Marta had told
him; the argument is just weather. He sat in the weather and waited for the
record to resume.
Cara's testimony was not on Marta's witness order, because Cara had not told
her father she was coming, and had told Marta only from the highway,
somewhere south of Morgantown, with the result that Marta — who did not
enjoy surprises the way other people did not enjoy voltage — had worked
her into the order with a pencil and a disposition. Russ found her during the
midmorning recess, turning around with his mind still in the hearing room:
there she was in the gallery's second row in her good coat, her bag at her feet,
wearing her nurse's posture — the one that said she had driven four hours