She found the folder at the back of the hall closet, a manila envelope sealed with a rubber band. Inside was the official report, eleven pages, and a plastic bag containing the personal effects the police had returned: his wallet, his wedding ring, his watch, cracked across the face and stopped at 12:07.
She had never been able to look at the watch. Now she turned it over and over in her palm. Twelve-oh-seven. If the gas station footage showed him leaving at eleven forty-nine, then he had survived nearly twenty minutes.
Twenty minutes. She closed her fingers around the watch and held it against her chest until the metal grew warm.
Not Thursday
The next Thursday arrived gray and windless. Nora slept three hours in the afternoon, ate a bowl of cereal for dinner, and drove to Route 9 at eleven forty-five, early on purpose.
She parked across the road, in the gravel lot of a shuttered fruit stand, and watched Pruitt's Sunoco through the windshield.
The fluorescent sign hummed. Two pumps stood in the pale light. Inside the little glass booth, no one sat on the stool.
Midnight came. The wind finally began, a thin cold whistle through the trees.
Twelve-fifteen. Twelve-thirty. A single car drove through, a farm truck, and the driver pumped his own gas and left money on the counter, then drove off, frowning at the empty booth.
At one, Nora crossed the road.
The attendant door was locked. The Closed sign was turned out, though the lights burned bright and the cash drawer, visible through the window, sat half-open. A mug of coffee stood on the counter, still faintly steaming.
Steaming.
The hair rose along her arms. "Walt?" she called. "Walt, it's Nora Ellison."
Nothing. The only answer was the hum of the sign and a small mechanical tick from the pump.
She walked around the building. The back door stood ajar, swinging a few inches in the wind. A trash can had been knocked on its side, and a wet cigarette lay beside it.
"Walt!"
A soft sound came from somewhere beyond the cinderblock wall, a groan, half-swallowed. She followed it, her heart pounding, around the corner of the building and into the shadow where the dumpster stood.
He lay curled against the base of the wall, one hand clutching his side, his wool cap gone. Blood darkened his white hair at the temple.
"Walt." She dropped to her knees, her training taking over before her fear could. Pulse, thready but present. Breathing, shallow. A swelling above his ear the size of a plum. "Walt, can you hear me? It's Nora."
His eyes fluttered open. They found hers with a kind of astonished relief.
"You came," he whispered.
"Don't talk. I'm calling an ambulance."
"They took... they took the wrong one..." His fingers clutched her sleeve with surprising strength. "I gave them the wrong one. The old one. Tell them... tell them I gave them the wrong one."
"Who, Walt? Who did this?"
But his lids were already closing. She pulled out her phone and dialed, speaking the numbers and address with the cold, clear voice of a woman who had done this a thousand times, and who had never before done it with her own heart breaking.
Rain began to fall, soft and fine, onto the old man's face. Nora took off her jacket and covered him, and kept one hand pressed against his pulse.
While she waited for the ambulance, the minutes seemed to stretch like taffy. Nora kept talking, because talking kept a person anchored. She told Walt about the shift she had worked that day, about Lila's new cat, about the maple tree outside her window that had begun to turn. She told him nothing important at all, because it did not matter what she said. It mattered that she was there.
"You're a good talker," Walt whispered once, his eyelids fluttering.
"I've been told."
"Your husband was the same. Never shut up about carburetors."
She laughed, though her throat ached. "He'd be thrilled that you remember."
The rain thinned to a drizzle, and in the distance she heard the first faint wail of the siren. Walt's grip loosened on her sleeve, and for a terrible second she thought he had slipped away. She pressed two fingers to his throat and found the beat, slow and stubborn.
"Stay with me," she said. "Walt. Stay."