She Rode Forty Miles Into Redemption Creek Alone, and the Deputy Smiled When He Learned Where She Lived. By Sundown, Catherine Fletcher Would Discover That the Most Dangerous Man on the Road Was Not the One Wearing the Badge

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Chester’s face drained of color.

Catherine noticed.

“You know that name.”

Chester did not answer.

“Chester.”

He looked at her.

“Silas Vale is dead.”

“How?”

“Shot twelve years ago.”

“By whom?”

Chester’s voice was quiet.

“Me.”


Catherine did not sleep.

Near dawn, Chester finally told her the story.

Twelve years earlier, Silas Vale had run freight across five counties.

Officially.

Unofficially, he ran stolen cattle, weapons, and payroll robberies.

Roy Sutter had been young then.

Not yet a deputy.

Chester had been a freight agent.

“My younger brother joined Vale,” Chester said. “Thought it was easy money.”

“What happened?”

“Vale killed him.”

Catherine listened without blinking.

“I found Vale outside Pecos.”

“You shot him?”

“Yes.”

“Then why would Thomas have his ledger?”

“Because Vale kept records of everyone he paid.”

“Roy?”

“Maybe.”

Catherine stood.

“Thomas never mentioned Vale.”

“Did Thomas ever freight?”

“Before we married.”

“Where?”

“New Mexico. Arizona. West Texas.”

Chester’s eyes narrowed.

“What was his full name?”

“Thomas Elias Fletcher.”

Chester froze.

Catherine saw recognition.

“What?”

“I knew an Elias Fletcher.”

Her heart thudded.

“When?”

“Fifteen years ago.”

“That’s impossible.”

“He drove freight for Vale.”

Catherine stared.

“No.”

“I’m not saying he was an outlaw.”

“You’re saying he worked for the man you killed.”

“Yes.”

Catherine turned away.

The hut suddenly felt too small.

Thomas had told her stories from his freight years.

Dust storms.

Broken axles.

A drunken cook in Las Cruces.

Never Silas Vale.

Never Chester.

Never a ledger.

Why?

Calvin Price woke and groaned.

Catherine looked at him.

“Roy believes the ledger is on my property.”

“Yes.”

“How long has he believed that?”

Calvin hesitated.

“Since Fletcher died.”

Her blood went cold.

“What?”

Calvin saw the change in her face.

“I only heard Roy talking.”

“When?”

“December.”

Thomas died in November.

Catherine stepped closer.

“What did he say?”

“That Fletcher finally stopped being a problem.”

Silence.

Chester rose.

Catherine’s voice became very soft.

“Exact words.”

Calvin swallowed.

“‘Fletcher finally stopped being a problem. Now we wait for the widow to lead us to it.’”

Catherine did not move.

But something inside her shattered.

Not grief.

Grief had already broken.

This was rage.

Thomas had not simply died.

Or at least Roy Sutter had known something about his death.

Catherine picked up her Winchester.

Chester said, “Where are you going?”

“Home.”

“That’s what Roy wants.”

“Yes.”

“Then why?”

Catherine looked at him.

“Because I think Thomas left something there for me.”


The Fletcher homestead looked ordinary in morning light.

Cabin.

Barn.

Smokehouse.

Chicken run.

Garden fenced against deer.

Thomas’s grave beneath the cottonwood.

Catherine stopped beside it.

The wooden marker bore words she had carved herself.

THOMAS E. FLETCHER

1850–1885

BELOVED HUSBAND

She stood there long enough for Chester to move away.

Finally she whispered, “What did you hide?”

The wind moved through cottonwood leaves.

Nothing answered.

Inside the cabin, Catherine began searching.

Not shelves.

Not boxes.

Thomas had been clever.

If he hid a ledger from men like Roy, he would never place it where thieves would look.

She searched tools.

Floorboards.

Roof beams.

Chimney stones.

Nothing.

Chester checked the barn.

Nothing.

By afternoon, frustration had sharpened into desperation.

Catherine sat at the kitchen table.

Thomas’s chair remained opposite.

She had never removed it.

Her eyes drifted toward the wall.

A small wooden shelf held three objects.

Thomas’s shaving cup.

His father’s pocket watch.

And a tin box containing fishing hooks.

Catherine stared.

Fishing hooks.

Thomas hated fishing.

She stood.

Took down the tin.

Opened it.

Hooks.

Line.

Lead weights.

She dumped them onto the table.

The tin sounded wrong.

Too heavy.

False bottom.

Catherine pried at the edge with her knife.

A thin wooden panel lifted.

Beneath lay a folded piece of paper.

Not a ledger.

A letter.

Her hands began to shake.

The handwriting was Thomas’s.

Catherine.

She stopped breathing.

Then read.

Catherine, if you are reading this, I failed to tell you something while I had the courage. For that, I ask forgiveness I may not deserve.

She sat.

Chester entered quietly.

“Found something?”

She nodded.

He remained by the door.

Catherine continued.

Years before I met you, I drove freight for Silas Vale. At first I believed him only dishonest. Later I learned what he truly was. I began copying his records because I thought someday I could use them to bring him down. When Vale died, the original ledger disappeared. The copy did not.

Catherine looked at Chester.

He said nothing.

She read on.

Roy Sutter worked for Vale. So did men who are now judges, ranch owners, and law officers. The ledger proves theft, murder, and bribery. Roy has searched for it for years.

Her mouth went dry.

If anything happens to me, do not trust the sheriff’s office in Redemption Creek. Do not trust a badge merely because it shines.

Catherine looked toward the window.

Roy’s badge flashed in her memory.

Then came the final paragraph.

The ledger is not in this house. You already know where it is, though you do not yet know that you know. Remember the place where we buried what we could not keep, beneath the tree that gave us shade when our world ended. Forgive me, Cat. I meant to tell you after winter. I loved you more than truth, and that was my cowardice.

Catherine stopped reading.

Her face emptied.

Chester looked toward the cottonwood.

The grave.

But Catherine knew Thomas did not mean his own.

He meant another.

Their first child.

The baby they had buried six years earlier.

Beneath a cottonwood near the river.

“The place where we buried what we could not keep,” she whispered.

Chester understood.

“No.”

Catherine folded the letter.

“He put it there.”

“Catherine—”

“He knew I would remember.”

“You’re not digging up your child’s grave.”

Her green eyes turned toward him.

“If Thomas buried the ledger there, Roy will eventually find it.”

“We can think.”

“I have been thinking for nine months.”

She picked up the shovel.

“I’m done.”


The little grave lay half a mile from the cabin.

The marker had faded.

BABY FLETCHER.

No name.

They had been too devastated to choose one.

Catherine stood over it with the shovel.

Chester remained back.

“I’ll do it.”

“No.”

“You shouldn’t have to.”

Catherine pushed the shovel into the soil.

“I already did once.”

That ended the argument.

She dug.

Each strike opened memory.

Thomas crying where she had never seen him cry before.

The impossibly small blanket.

Her own body aching with milk for a child who would never drink.

She stopped twice.

Continued.

At three feet, the shovel struck metal.

Catherine froze.

Chester stepped closer.

She cleared dirt with her hands.

A small iron strongbox.

Not the coffin.

Thomas had buried it above and to the side.

Catherine lifted it.

The lock was rusted.

Chester broke it with the shovel.

Inside, wrapped in oilcloth, lay a black book.

And another letter.

Catherine opened the book first.

Names.

Dates.

Payments.

Cattle brands.

Shipment numbers.

Sheriffs.

Judges.

Men marked DEAD.

Others marked PAID.

Then she saw it.

ROY SUTTER.

Repeated eleven times.

Payments for information.

Payments for horses.

Payment after something labeled CRANE PLACE.

Catherine’s eyes stopped.

“Mabel Crane.”

Chester took the book.

There it was.

MABEL CRANE — $280 — RECOVERED PROPERTY — R.S.

Below:

NO WITNESS.

Chester’s jaw tightened.

“He killed her.”

Catherine opened Thomas’s second letter.

It was shorter.

If Roy finds the ledger, he will kill for it. If Chester Callaway is still alive, you may trust him about Silas Vale—but not about everything else.

Catherine slowly raised her eyes.

Chester had gone pale.

“Not about everything else?”

He stepped back.

“Catherine—”

She raised the Winchester.

“What did Thomas mean?”

Chester stared at the barrel.

“I don’t know.”

“Try harder.”

“He may have meant my brother.”

“What about him?”

Chester rubbed a hand over his face.

“Thomas knew my brother didn’t join Vale willingly.”

“You told me he did.”

“I simplified it.”

“Why?”

“Because the truth makes me look worse.”

Catherine’s voice dropped.

“What truth?”

Chester looked at the grave.

“My brother was working with Thomas.”

Catherine did not move.

“They were both copying Vale’s records?”

“Yes.”

“And?”

“Vale discovered it.”

“What did you do?”

“I tried to get them out.”

“Did you?”

“No.”

Chester’s voice cracked.

“Vale captured my brother. Thomas escaped.”

Catherine’s heart hammered.

“And you killed Vale.”

“Two years later.”

“Why not then?”

Chester looked at her.

“Because Vale had someone else protecting him.”

“Roy?”

“No.”

“Who?”

Before Chester could answer, a rifle shot tore through the cottonwood leaves.

Catherine dropped.

The black ledger fell.

Chester dove behind the grave marker.

Another bullet struck the strongbox.

A voice called from the trees.

“Step away from the book!”

Roy.

Catherine rolled behind the cottonwood.

Chester whispered, “How many?”

Catherine peered through grass.

Roy stood near the riverbank.

Two men with him.

One was Sheriff Amos Creed.

Catherine’s stomach dropped.

The sheriff.

Roy called again.

“Mrs. Fletcher! This can end politely.”

Catherine shouted back, “You sent Wade Kellan politely too?”

A pause.

Then Roy laughed.

“Wade was impatient.”

Sheriff Creed stepped forward.

“Catherine, put down the rifle. Roy has evidence Thomas Fletcher was involved in criminal activity.”

Chester muttered, “Creed. Of course.”

Catherine glanced at him.

“The sheriff is in the ledger?”

“Find out.”

She opened it quickly.

CREED, AMOS.

Seven entries.

The last one dated only two months earlier.

News in the same category

She Rode Forty Miles Into Redemption Creek Alone, and the Deputy Smiled When He Learned Where She Lived. By Sundown, Catherine Fletcher Would Discover That the Most Dangerous Man on the Road Was Not the One Wearing the Badge

7 Part