She Rode Forty Miles Into Redemption Creek Alone, and the Deputy Smiled When He Learned Where She Lived. By Sundown, Catherine Fletcher Would Discover That the Most Dangerous Man on the Road Was Not the One Wearing the Badge

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“You remembered.”

“I made an arrangement.”

“You were shot, hunted, discovered your husband had a secret identity, exposed a criminal network, and helped imprison a deputy.”

Catherine dropped the bundle on the counter.

“None of that cancels a business arrangement.”

Chester smiled.

“Eight percent.”

“Seven.”

“We already settled this.”

“Circumstances changed.”

Hector Monroe laughed from near the tobacco tins.

Agnes Billings hurried from the cloth shelves and hugged Catherine before Catherine could defend herself.

“You look well.”

“I look crushed.”

Agnes released her.

“Sorry.”

“No, you aren’t.”

“No.”

The store laughed.

For a moment it felt ordinary.

Then Ben Hollis entered.

Catherine groaned.

“What now?”

Hollis removed his hat.

“That’s rude.”

“Last time I saw you, people were shooting at me.”

“Technically they were shooting at all of us.”

“What do you want?”

Hollis placed an envelope on the counter.

Catherine looked at it.

“What?”

“Letter.”

“From whom?”

“Federal prison.”

The room became still.

Roy.

Catherine did not touch it.

“Burn it.”

Hollis said, “Read the name.”

She looked.

The handwriting on the envelope was not Roy’s.

It said:

Mrs. Catherine Fletcher — Regarding Thomas Fletcher

Her heart tightened.

“Who sent it?”

“A prisoner named Matthew Vane.”

Chester stiffened.

Catherine noticed.

“You know him?”

“No.”

Hollis said, “Vane shared transport with Roy.”

Catherine opened the letter.

Mrs. Fletcher,

Roy Sutter believes your husband is dead.

He is wrong.

Catherine stopped.

The mercantile disappeared.

“What?”

Chester stepped closer.

She read again.

Roy Sutter believes your husband is dead.

He is wrong.

Her hands began to shake.

The letter continued.

The man buried at Cottonwood Bend in November was not Daniel Callaway.

Catherine could not breathe.

Agnes whispered, “Catherine?”

She kept reading.

I know because I was there when Daniel Callaway was taken alive three days before the death you witnessed.

The paper trembled.

“No.”

Hollis looked grim.

“That’s why I came.”

Catherine shook her head violently.

“No. I buried him.”

Chester’s face had gone white.

“I washed his body.”

Hollis said nothing.

“I sat beside him while he died.”

“Catherine—”

“I know my husband’s face!”

Hollis quietly asked, “Did you?”

The question struck like a slap.

She stared at him.

“What does that mean?”

“You told me Thomas’s fever became severe.”

“Yes.”

“Swelling?”

“Yes.”

“Rash?”

“Yes.”

“Eyes?”

She remembered.

Thomas’s eyes swollen nearly shut.

Face mottled.

Skin discolored.

Dark room.

November.

Three days without sleep.

Her own fever beginning.

She whispered, “No.”

Chester gripped the counter.

Catherine read the rest.

Roy had a man named Samuel Dace. Similar height. Similar beard. Dace was dying already. They used him because Roy needed the widow to believe Daniel was dead. Daniel had hidden the ledger and refused to reveal where. Roy believed if you thought your husband dead, you would eventually uncover whatever he left behind.

Catherine’s knees weakened.

Chester caught her arm.

She pulled away.

The final lines waited.

Daniel escaped Roy’s men before Christmas. I saw him alive near Santa Elena in February. He was searching for a way home but believed Roy was watching you. He said returning would get you killed.

Catherine stopped.

February.

Thomas—Daniel—had been alive in February.

While she slept alone.

While she dug traps through ice.

While she cried at a stranger’s grave.

The letter ended:

I do not know where he is now. But before we separated, he gave me one message in case I ever found you.

Catherine’s eyes blurred.

She read the last sentence.

Tell Cat I kept the blue button.

The paper fell from her hands.

Chester caught it.

“What does that mean?”

Catherine covered her mouth.

A sound escaped her.

Half laugh.

Half sob.

On their wedding day, Catherine’s dress had been borrowed.

One blue button had fallen off.

Thomas had carried it in his pocket for thirteen years.

No one knew.

No one.

Except her husband.

“He’s alive.”

Her knees gave way.

Agnes caught her.

Catherine began to cry.

Not politely.

Not quietly.

Nine months of grief tore free at once.

“He’s alive.”

Chester knelt beside her.

His own face crumpled.

“My brother…”

Hollis looked toward the door.

“We don’t know that he’s alive now.”

Catherine lifted her head.

The ranger immediately regretted the sentence.

She wiped her face.

“When was Vane’s letter written?”

“Three weeks ago.”

“Where did he last see Thomas?”

“Santa Elena.”

“That’s west.”

“Yes.”

“How far?”

“Five days hard riding.”

Catherine stood.

Chester said, “You’re not leaving this minute.”

She looked at him.

“Yes, I am.”

“You just rode forty miles.”

“I’ve done it before.”

Hollis sighed.

“I brought horses.”

Catherine stared.

“You knew.”

“I suspected you’d be unreasonable.”

Chester reached for his coat.

“So am I.”

Catherine looked between them.

“No.”

Both men said, “Yes.”

For the first time in months, Catherine smiled.

A real smile.

Then she pointed at Chester.

“You slow me down, I leave you.”

He nodded.

“At my age, that’s fair.”

She looked at Hollis.

“You lie to me once, I shoot you.”

Hollis frowned.

“Why do I get the worse condition?”

“Experience.”

They left Redemption Creek before noon.


Santa Elena was a settlement barely worth its name.

Adobe church.

Trading post.

Six houses.

Mission ruins farther west.

Catherine showed Thomas’s description everywhere.

No one remembered him.

Then an old Mexican woman at the trading post looked at Catherine’s sketch.

“Yes.”

Catherine’s heart stopped.

“You saw him?”

“Months ago.”

“Where?”

The woman pointed west.

“He worked at Delgado ranch.”

“Is he there?”

“No.”

Catherine’s hope collapsed.

“Where did he go?”

“North.”

“When?”

“June.”

“Why?”

The woman shrugged.

“Looking for his wife.”

Catherine nearly laughed.

They had crossed the country chasing one another.

“Did he say where?”

“Redemption Creek.”

Chester stared.

“He was going home.”

“When in June?”

“Maybe six weeks.”

Catherine’s mind raced.

Six weeks.

Thomas should have reached Cottonwood Bend long ago.

Unless—

Hollis saw her fear.

“We’ll find him.”

They rode north.

Three days later, at a stage station near Fort Davis, Catherine asked again.

The station master remembered.

“A fellow named Fletcher?”

Catherine gripped the counter.

“Yes.”

“Passed through.”

“When?”

“Month ago.”

“Heading where?”

“Redemption Creek.”

“Was he alone?”

The man thought.

“No. Funny thing. A woman joined him.”

Catherine froze.

“A woman?”

“Blonde. Maybe thirty.”

Chester looked at her carefully.

Catherine’s face closed.

“Who?”

“Didn’t ask.”

They rode on.

Another station remembered them.

Thomas and the blonde woman.

Together.

Sharing food.

Talking privately.

At the third stop, the keeper said they had taken one room because the second roof leaked.

Catherine said nothing for twenty miles.

Chester finally said, “There may be an explanation.”

“There usually is.”

“You think he—”

“I think I buried a stranger believing he was my husband. I think my husband spent months alive without sending word. I think he traveled north with a woman no one can identify.”

Hollis wisely rode farther ahead.

Chester said, “Daniel loved you.”

“Thomas loved me.”

“He’s the same man.”

Catherine looked at him.

“Is he?”

That silenced Chester.

Because that was the true wound.

Catherine had spent thirteen years married to Thomas Fletcher.

But Thomas Fletcher had never existed.

She loved a man whose name, history, crimes, brother, and enemies had been hidden.

What else had been false?

Five miles south of Redemption Creek, they found the answer.

A campfire burned near the road.

One horse.

A man sitting beside it.

Dark hair threaded with gray.

Lean shoulders.

Beard shorter than Catherine remembered.

He looked up.

The world stopped.

Catherine could not move.

Neither could he.

Chester whispered, “Daniel.”

The man stood.

Catherine saw the scar on his chin.

The slight bend in his left little finger.

The way he planted more weight on his right leg from an old wagon injury.

Thomas.

Her husband.

Alive.

His face broke.

“Cat.”

That voice.

The voice she had heard in dreams.

Catherine dismounted.

For one second Thomas smiled.

Then she struck him across the face.

The sound cracked through the camp.

Hollis looked away.

Chester muttered, “Fair.”

Thomas touched his cheek.

Catherine struck him again.

Then she grabbed his shirt and kissed him.

Thomas wrapped his arms around her.

Catherine sobbed against his chest.

He whispered her name over and over.

She hit him again without letting go.

“You were alive.”

“I know.”

“I buried you.”

“I know.”

“I hate you.”

“I know.”

She kissed him again.

“I thought you were dead.”

Thomas buried his face in her hair.

“I’m sorry.”

Catherine pulled back.

“Who is the blonde woman?”

Thomas blinked.

“What?”

“The woman traveling with you.”

His expression changed.

“Oh.”

Catherine stepped back.

“Oh?”

Thomas looked toward the darkness beyond the fire.

“Come out.”

A woman emerged from the trees.

Blonde.

Thirty.

Carrying a rifle.

Catherine’s hand moved toward her revolver.

Thomas quickly said, “Catherine, this is Anna.”

“Anna who?”

The woman looked at Chester.

Chester gasped.

The rifle nearly fell from his hand.

“No.”

Anna stared at him.

“You’ve gotten old.”

Chester’s face drained.

“Anna?”

Catherine looked between them.

“Who is she?”

Thomas smiled through tears.

“My sister.”

Chester made a strangled sound.

“We don’t have a sister.”

Anna walked closer.

“You didn’t know.”

Chester stared.

Thomas said, “Neither did I.”

Anna reached into her shirt and pulled out a small silver locket.

Inside was a faded photograph.

A woman.

Chester’s mother.

Holding an infant girl.

Chester sat down hard on a rock.

“How?”

Anna’s eyes filled.

“Vale took me.”

Silence.

“He told Mother I died. He raised me under another name because he thought someday he could use me against you.”

News in the same category

She Rode Forty Miles Into Redemption Creek Alone, and the Deputy Smiled When He Learned Where She Lived. By Sundown, Catherine Fletcher Would Discover That the Most Dangerous Man on the Road Was Not the One Wearing the Badge

7 Part