She Rode Forty Miles Into Redemption Creek Alone, and the Deputy Smiled When He Learned Where She Lived. By Sundown, Catherine Fletcher Would Discover That the Most Dangerous Man on the Road Was Not the One Wearing the Badge

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“Texas Rangers! Throw down your weapons!”

Catherine almost laughed from relief.

But Roy did not surrender.

He burst through the rear doorway.

Running.

With the ledger.

Catherine looked down.

The book in her hands—

A decoy.

Hollis had switched them.

“Damn him.”

She ran after Roy.


Roy reached the livery.

Catherine followed despite the blood soaking her sleeve.

“Catherine!” Chester shouted behind her.

She ignored him.

Roy saddled a horse badly and fast.

Catherine entered with the Winchester raised.

“Stop.”

Roy turned.

He held the real ledger in one hand.

A revolver in the other.

“You won.”

“Put down the gun.”

“No.”

“You can’t escape the Rangers.”

“I don’t need to.”

He smiled.

Then he struck a match.

Catherine’s eyes widened.

He held it over the ledger.

“Drop the rifle.”

“No.”

“I burn this, half your proof disappears.”

“Hollis knows.”

“Not enough.”

“Chester knows.”

“Not enough.”

“You confessed to poisoning Thomas.”

“To you.”

Roy lowered the match.

“Drop it.”

Catherine slowly lowered the Winchester.

Roy smiled.

“Kick it away.”

She did.

“Now the revolver.”

She removed it.

Dropped it.

“Good.”

The match flame moved closer to the ledger.

Catherine said, “You killed Thomas because of that book.”

“Yes.”

“You killed Mabel Crane.”

“Yes.”

“Others?”

Roy shrugged.

“Enough.”

“Why?”

“Because men like me spend our lives taking orders from men born with land, money, names. Vale understood something. Law is simply force wearing cleaner clothes.”

“And you wanted cleaner clothes?”

“I wanted the force.”

Catherine stared at him.

“You’re not powerful.”

Roy’s smile faded.

“You poisoned a sick man and robbed widows. That isn’t power.”

“Careful.”

“You needed a badge because without it, you were just another thief afraid someone might shoot back.”

Roy’s face tightened.

Catherine continued.

“Thomas died refusing to give you this ledger.”

“Yes.”

“And now you’re running from a wounded widow.”

Roy’s hand shook.

She saw it.

So did he.

“Shut up.”

“You’re afraid of me.”

“Shut up!”

He pointed the revolver fully at her.

Catherine smiled.

That enraged him.

He stepped closer.

Exactly what she wanted.

Behind her back, Catherine’s fingers closed around the small skinning knife tucked inside her belt.

Roy saw the movement too late.

She threw it.

The blade struck his gun hand.

Roy screamed.

The revolver fired into the rafters.

Catherine lunged.

They crashed into a stall.

The ledger fell.

Roy struck her wounded shoulder.

Pain blinded her.

She hit the ground.

He kicked her ribs.

“You should’ve stayed home.”

Catherine rolled as his boot came down again.

She grabbed a loose horseshoe.

Swung.

It struck his knee.

Roy collapsed.

She scrambled toward the revolver.

He caught her ankle.

Dragged her back.

Catherine kicked him in the face.

He released her.

She reached the gun.

Roy reached her.

They froze.

Catherine held the revolver beneath his chin.

Roy was breathing hard.

Blood ran from his hand.

“You won’t,” he whispered.

The same assumption Wade Kellan had made.

Catherine’s eyes filled with tears.

“Thomas knew I would.”

Roy’s face changed.

Before she could decide whether to pull the trigger, a voice came from the doorway.

“Don’t.”

Chester.

Catherine did not look away from Roy.

“He murdered Thomas.”

“I know.”

“He made me give Thomas the medicine that killed him.”

Chester’s face twisted.

“I know.”

Roy whispered, “Do it.”

Catherine’s finger tightened.

“Catherine,” Chester said, “if you kill him now, he becomes the last thing you carry from Thomas.”

Her breathing shook.

Roy smiled.

“You think prison matters to me?”

Then Hollis appeared behind Chester.

“It will.”

Roy’s smile disappeared.

Hollis walked in.

“You’re not going to a county cell, Roy.”

Roy stared.

“Federal charges. Murder of a witness. Theft of government payroll. Conspiracy. And if the judge is in a charitable mood, perhaps hanging.”

Catherine slowly lowered the revolver.

Roy laughed once.

“You think this ends with me?”

Hollis said, “No.”

Roy looked at Catherine.

“There are names in that ledger you haven’t read.”

Catherine picked up the book.

Roy’s eyes glittered.

“One name in particular.”

Chester went still.

Catherine noticed.

“What name?”

Roy smiled.

“Ask your new friend.”

Catherine looked at Chester.

He stared at the dirt.

“Chester.”

He said nothing.

She opened the ledger.

Pages flipped.

Callaway.

Her fingers stopped.

CHESTER CALLAWAY — PAYMENT RECEIVED — $500.

Catherine felt sick.

She looked up.

“No.”

Chester closed his eyes.

Roy laughed.

“There’s your trustworthy merchant.”

Catherine raised the revolver again.

“Explain.”

Chester’s voice was barely audible.

“I took Vale’s money.”

“For what?”

“To betray Daniel.”

Catherine’s face emptied.

Hollis said, “Chester—”

“No.” Chester looked at Catherine. “She deserves it.”

He stepped inside.

“Vale threatened our mother. Said he would burn her house with her inside unless I told him where Daniel was hiding.”

Catherine said nothing.

“I told him.”

Roy smiled.

“And Vale caught Daniel.”

Chester nodded.

Tears stood in his eyes.

“I thought he killed him.”

Catherine’s hand trembled.

“Thomas spent fifteen years believing you sold him.”

“Yes.”

“Did he know why?”

“No.”

“Why didn’t you find him?”

“I searched.”

“For fifteen years?”

“For fifteen years.”

Chester looked at her.

“Every freight camp. Every ranch town. Every jail notice. Every grave list.”

His voice broke.

“I opened that mercantile because Redemption Creek sits on three major roads. I thought maybe one day he would walk through the door.”

Catherine stared.

“And he never did.”

“No.”

“He lived forty miles away.”

Chester laughed once through tears.

“Forty miles.”

The cruelty of it filled the stable.

Fifteen years.

Forty miles.

Two brothers separated by shame and silence.

Catherine looked at the ledger.

Then something caught her eye.

A notation beside Chester’s name.

RETURNED.

She frowned.

Below it:

$500 RETURNED TO S. VALE THROUGH THIRD PARTY. C.C. REFUSES FURTHER CONTACT.

Catherine looked up.

Roy’s smile vanished.

She turned the book toward Chester.

“You gave it back.”

Chester stared.

“Yes.”

Roy said, “Doesn’t change what he did.”

“No,” Catherine said. “It doesn’t.”

Chester lowered his head.

Catherine continued.

“But it changes what he became afterward.”

Roy’s face hardened.

Rangers entered.

They bound his hands.

As they led him away, he looked at Catherine one last time.

“You think you know your husband now?”

Catherine held the ledger against her chest.

“No.”

Roy smiled faintly.

Then Catherine said, “But I know you.”

The smile disappeared.


Roy Sutter did not hang.

Not immediately.

The ledger caused something much larger than Redemption Creek.

Three sheriffs resigned.

One judge vanished before arrest.

Two ranch owners were charged with receiving stolen cattle.

A former county clerk confessed to altering land deeds.

Mabel Crane’s remains were discovered in a dry well twelve miles north of town.

Her sister came from Louisiana to bury her.

Sheriff Amos Creed survived the shotgun wound and eventually testified in exchange for avoiding the gallows.

Roy refused.

He went to trial.

Catherine testified.

So did Chester.

So did Ben Hollis.

When the prosecutor asked Catherine to describe Thomas’s death, she thought she would break.

She did not.

She looked directly at Roy and told the truth.

Every spoonful of medicine.

Every fevered night.

Every time Thomas had apologized for being a burden.

Every time she had told him to stop talking because he needed strength.

Then she said the thing that silenced the courtroom.

“He did not die because he was weak. He died because he trusted the medicine in my hand, and I trusted the law that was supposed to protect us.”

Roy looked away first.

He was sentenced to life in federal prison after prosecutors declined to pursue hanging in exchange for information leading to six additional arrests.

Catherine hated that bargain.

Hollis did not.

“Dead men stop talking,” he told her.

“Some deserve to.”

“Most do.”

She looked at him.

“Is that Ranger wisdom?”

“No. Personal preference.”

Months passed.

Catherine returned to Cottonwood Bend.

She repaired the grave.

Both graves.

The little one by the river.

Thomas’s beneath the cottonwood.

Or Daniel’s.

She still did not know which name to carve.

One evening Chester arrived carrying a new wooden marker.

Catherine stepped from the cabin.

“What’s that?”

“For him.”

She looked.

The marker read:

THOMAS ELIAS FLETCHER

BORN DANIEL ELIAS CALLAWAY

1850–1885

HUSBAND. BROTHER. A MAN WHO CHOSE BETTER.

Catherine stared at it for a long time.

Then said, “You missed stubborn.”

Chester laughed softly.

“So did you.”

“And terrible at singing.”

“I remember that.”

“You heard him sing?”

“When we were boys.”

Catherine looked at Chester.

For the first time, she did not see the mercantile owner.

She saw Thomas’s brother.

The eyes were different.

But the way he tilted his head when amused—

Thomas had done that.

Her throat tightened.

“Tell me about him.”

Chester’s smile vanished into grief.

“What?”

“Before he was Thomas.”

Chester sat on the porch.

So did Catherine.

And as sunset covered Cottonwood Bend in amber light, Chester told her about Daniel Callaway.

A boy who stole peaches.

A sixteen-year-old who broke his arm jumping from a barn roof because his brother dared him.

A young man who could never pass an injured animal.

A terrible card player.

A worse liar.

Catherine laughed until she cried.

Then cried until she could not laugh.

When Chester left the next morning, something inside her had shifted.

Not healed.

Healing was too clean a word.

But opened.


Summer turned toward autumn.

Catherine returned to Redemption Creek with six beaver pelts.

And two otter.

Exactly as promised.

When she entered the mercantile, Chester looked at the bundle.

News in the same category

She Rode Forty Miles Into Redemption Creek Alone, and the Deputy Smiled When He Learned Where She Lived. By Sundown, Catherine Fletcher Would Discover That the Most Dangerous Man on the Road Was Not the One Wearing the Badge

7 Part