Darius felt his throat tighten, and he put his arm around her, and he held her close, and he looked out at the garden, at the tree, at the house, at the whole of the life he had built with Renee and was now trying to hold together without her.
"That's right," he said. "That's exactly right. You never have to earn love, Kayla. Not from me. Not from anyone. Love isn't a prize, and it isn't a test. It's just there. It's yours. You already have it."
Kayla leaned against him, and she was quiet for a while, and then she said, "Brittany said I had to be good. She said if I was good, she would love me. And if I wasn't good, she wouldn't."
Darius closed his eyes. He had known, in a general way, what Brittany had done to his daughter. He had known about the hair, and the locked door, and the cruel words. But this was different. This was the thing underneath all of it, the thing Renee had warned him about six years ago, the thing he had not seen until now. Brittany had not just hurt Kayla's hair. She had tried to teach her that love had to be earned, and that a little girl had to be good enough to deserve it, and that if she was not good enough, the love would be taken away.
"She was wrong," Darius said, and his voice was steady, because this was the most important thing he would ever say to his daughter, and he wanted to say it right. "She was wrong about that, Kayla. You don't have to be perfect to deserve kindness. You don't have to be good to be loved. You are loved because you are you. That is the whole reason. There is no other reason, and there never will be."
Kayla looked up at him then, and her eyes were wide, and for a moment he saw the little girl she had been before Brittany came into their lives, the girl who had laughed easily and trusted completely, and he saw her beginning to come back.
"Never let anyone make her believe she has to earn love," Renee had written, and Darius understood now that those words were not just a warning. They were an instruction. They were the thing Renee had left him to do, the job she had given him, the one that mattered more than any other. He was to make sure his daughter knew, every day, that she was loved without conditions, and that no one — not Brittany, not anyone — could ever take that away from her.
He took the ribbon from Kayla's hand, gently, and he tied it, very carefully, around the bunny's neck, in a small bow.
"There," he said. "Now the bunny has it too. And the bunny doesn't have to earn it either."
Kayla laughed then, a real laugh, small and surprised, like a sound she had forgotten she could make. And Darius laughed with her, and for a moment, sitting under the tree in the garden, with the sun coming through the leaves and his daughter laughing beside him, the house felt almost like a home again.
Chapter 16: The Letter
That evening, after Kayla was in bed, Darius went back to the box of letters and took them out again, one bundle at a time, and he read them the way a man reads a map when he is lost: slowly, carefully, looking for the landmarks he had missed the first time through.
There were so many of them. Renee had written to him for years, and he had kept every one, and reading them now was like sitting down with her again, like hearing her voice in the room, patient and clear, telling him the things she had always told him, the things he had not always heard.
He read a letter from the winter Kayla was two years old, when Renee had been ill, and had written about being afraid, and about what she wanted for their daughter if she was not there to give it herself. She had written about the kind of woman she hoped Kayla would grow up to be, and about the kind of home she hoped Kayla would grow up in, and about the one thing she wanted Darius to remember above all else, if he remembered nothing else she had ever said.
He read the words again, and they were the same words he had read in the letter he had found the night before, and they were the words that had stayed with him all day, turning over in his mind like a stone in a river.
Never let anyone make her believe she has to earn love.
He sat with those words for a long time. He thought about what they meant, and about how simple they were, and about how hard they were to live by, because the world was full of people who believed the opposite, people who thought love was a reward for good behaviour, and that a child who misbehaved had earned the coldness that followed. Renee had known better. She had known that a child who believes she has to earn love will spend her whole life trying, and will never believe she has tried enough.
And then, as he read on, he found another line, in another letter, in her handwriting, and it was the same thought, said a different way, and it struck him just as hard as the first one had.
Love is not something you must earn. It is something you are given, because you are loved, and that is enough.