He did not hate Brittany. He was surprised to find that he did not, and he thought about it for a long time, sitting in the dark, listening to the house settle around him. He was angry, and he was disappointed, and he was finished with her, but he did not hate her. Hate would have been simpler. Hate would have given him something to hold on to. But what he felt was something else, something quieter and sadder: the recognition that a person can be in pain, and can be guilty, and can be wrong, all at the same time, and that none of those things makes what she did acceptable, and none of them makes her beyond help, either. Patricia was right. Brittany needed help. And Darius hoped, in a distant, tired way, that she would find it. But he would not wait for her to find it. He would not let Kayla wait for it. His daughter came first. She had always come first. She always would.
Chapter 35: The Choice
Darius had already made his choice. He had made it the night he walked into the dressing room and saw his daughter crying, and he had made it again the night he ended the engagement, and he had made it again every day since, in every conversation, in every decision, in every moment when he had to choose between the woman he had nearly married and the little girl who was his daughter. But now, with the whole truth laid out in front of him, with Caroline's story told and Patricia's words spoken and the lie fully exposed, he understood the choice differently. It was not a choice he had made once. It was a choice he would have to keep making, every day, for as long as Kayla needed him, and he was ready to make it.
He stood in the garden, in the late afternoon, looking at the tree where Renee had once held newborn Kayla, and he thought about what it meant to choose a child. It meant more than loving her. Loving her was easy. It meant protecting her, even when protection was inconvenient, even when it meant ending a relationship, even when it meant admitting that he had been wrong about a person he had trusted. It meant believing her, when she said she was afraid, and when she said she had done nothing wrong, and when she asked him if her hair would grow back. It meant putting her first, not some of the time, but all of the time, not because she was perfect, but because she was his, and because she was six years old, and because she could not protect herself.
He thought about Brittany, and about the choice she had made at nineteen, and about the choice she had made again, at thirty-six, when she had picked up the clippers and walked into the dressing room. He thought about how a choice could follow a person for seventeen years, how it could shape everything they did, how it could turn into a pain and a guilt that they carried everywhere, and how it could end, at last, in a room full of people who loved a little girl, with a mother saying, "No, Brittany. Kayla is not your daughter." He thought about how different his own choice was, and how simple it was, and how it had never really been a choice at all, because there had never been a moment when he would have chosen anyone over Kayla, not Brittany, not anyone, not ever.
Evelyn came out into the garden then, carrying a glass of water, and she stood beside him for a while, and neither of them spoke. She was sixty-two years old, and she had worked in that house for longer than Darius had been a father, and she understood him better than almost anyone, and she knew when to speak and when to be quiet. She handed him the water, and he drank it, and she looked at the tree, and then she looked at him.
"She will be all right," Evelyn said. It was not a question. It was a statement, the kind of statement a person makes when they have watched a child for a long time and know what that child is made of.
"I know," Darius said. "I know she will. She is stronger than I am. She always has been."
"She is strong because you have never asked her to be anything she is not," Evelyn said. "You have never asked her to earn your love. You have never asked her to be perfect. You have only asked her to be Kayla. That is why she is strong. And that is why she will be all right."
Darius nodded. He thought about Renee's words, the words his mother had kept, the words about never letting anyone make Kayla believe she has to earn love, and he thought about how he had tried to live by those words, even before he had known they were written down, even before he had found the letters, even before he had understood what they meant. He had tried, and he had not always succeeded, and he had made mistakes, and he had trusted the wrong person, but he had never once asked Kayla to earn his love, and he never would. That was the choice. That had always been the choice. And he would keep making it, every day, for as long as she needed him to.
When he went back into the house, Kayla was sitting at the kitchen table, drawing, her bunny beside her, her pink ribbon on the table where she had left it, and she looked up at him and smiled, and Darius felt something in his chest loosen, something that had been tight for days, and he knew, with a certainty that surprised him, that the choice had already been made, and that it had been the right one, and that everything else, the papers and the lies and the pain and the guilt, was only noise around the edges of it. The centre of it was this: a little girl, at a kitchen table, drawing, safe in her own house, with her father standing in the doorway, watching her, and loving her, and choosing her, again and again, without ever having to think about it.