She Smashed My Sprinkler and Drowned My Garden — Then the Inspector Told Her to Stay Put

Chapter 13

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

In the morning I called Reyes. I told him what Laura had said, and he was quiet for a moment, and then he said, "I'd like to interview Ms. Bennett. Today, if possible. Can you ask her to call me?"

I called Laura. She answered on the second ring, like she had been waiting.

"He wants to talk to you," I said. "Today."

"I'll call him," she said. "I will."

"He'll want the truth," I said. "Exactly what you heard. Not what you think it means."

"I know," Laura said. "Claire — can I ask you something? Do you think she did it? My mother?"

I held the phone and looked out my kitchen window at the fence, at Ruth's roses budding along it, at the post with the hammer dents that Reyes had photographed.

"I think the evidence will say what it says," I told her. "That's all I think right now."

Laura was quiet. "That's a better answer than I would have given," she said finally.

That afternoon, Laura called me back. She had talked to Reyes. She had told him about the offer letter on the kitchen table, about Ben's words — the nursery lowered property values, if the nursery failed Claire might sell. She had told him she knew her mother was angry and had said nothing. Reyes had written it all down, and she had signed the statement.

"He asked me if I'd seen the letter recently," Laura told me. "I said yes, it was still on the table last week. He asked if my mother talked about it. I said she talked about the nursery a lot. About the runoff. About the property values." She paused. "He asked if I thought my mother was capable of smashing your manifold. I told him I didn't know. I told him I hoped not."

"That's honest," I said.

"It's the only thing I have left to be," Laura said.

After we hung up, I went to my file drawer and took out Ben Hartley's offer letter and my refusal. I read them both again, slowly. The offer was typed on heavy cream paper, with his company's letterhead — Hartley Development — and it was all very professional, very courteous. A fair market offer, he had written. An exciting opportunity for the street. My refusal was on my own plain paper, three short paragraphs. Thank you, no, please do not contact me about this again.

I put them back in the drawer. But I took a photograph of both of them with my phone first, because Reyes had told me to document everything, and because I was starting to understand that paper was the only thing in this whole mess that didn't change its story.

I didn't sleep that night either. I lay in bed and listened to the house — the refrigerator, the furnace kicking on, the small settling sounds of a place that had been through something and was still standing. I thought about what Laura had said about the tomatoes, about Ruth at my door nine years ago with a paper bag. I tried to hold both Ruths in my head at once: the neighbor with the tomatoes, and the woman who had stood in my yard with a hammer. They didn't fit together. They were the same person, and they didn't fit, and that was the thing I couldn't get past.

Around three in the morning I got up and went to the kitchen and made tea I didn't drink. I stood at the window and looked at Ruth's dark house, and I thought about fear — hers, mine. She was afraid of losing her street, her property value, the order of her life. I was afraid of losing the nursery, the thing I had built with my own hands after my marriage ended. We were both afraid, and fear had made her pick up a hammer, and it had made me want to scream at her door. Fear was the common ground, and it was the worst possible foundation for anything.

I went back to bed eventually. I didn't sleep. But I stopped trying, and that was almost as good.

That evening, Grace Lin came over with a casserole and sat at my kitchen table and listened to the whole thing — the offer letter, Laura on the porch, the statement.

"You know what I think?" Grace said, scraping the last of the casserole from her plate. "I think that man put an idea in an angry woman's head, and then he walked away, and now she's holding the hammer and he's holding nothing."

"Reyes says Ben faces no charge," I said. "His company denies any knowledge."

"Of course they do," Grace said. "That's what companies are for. Denying knowledge." She stood up and put her plate in my sink. "Claire, listen to me. You did the right thing, letting Laura talk to the inspector. That's how this gets settled. Not on the street. On paper."

I nodded, but I was thinking about Ruth, alone in her house next door, and about Laura, caught between her mother and the truth, and about Ben Hartley, who had sent a letter on cream paper and then gone quiet. I was thinking that the flood had been the easy part. The water pumped out. The rest of it — the suspicion, the knowing, the paper — that was going to take longer to drain.

News in the same category

She Smashed My Sprinkler and Drowned My Garden — Then the Inspector Told Her to Stay Put

45 Part