"Paper!" She spat the word. "You and your paper. I know what I see in my garden."
By now Grace had come out onto her own porch, two doors down, and I could see curtains moving in the house across the street. Nobody shouts louder than a person who knows she's being watched, and Ruth knew. Her voice carried down the whole block. "You flood my roses and then you come to MY door —"
"I didn't flood your roses. Somebody flooded MY yard. Somebody took a hammer to my pipes, Ruth. In the night. While I was asleep in my house." My voice was shaking, and I hated it. I wanted to be calm. I wanted to be the person with the folder and the timeline. But standing on her porch looking at her fury, all I could think about was two hundred and forty tomato seedlings under water. "If it wasn't you, then you have nothing to worry about. The police will figure it out."
"The police," Ruth said, and she laughed, a short ugly sound. "You call the police on a sixty-three-year-old widow. You do that, Claire. You do that and see how it looks."
She went back inside and closed the door. Not slammed — closed, with a terrible finality, like the period at the end of a sentence. I stood on her porch with water still squelching in my boots, and Grace came down her walk and put a hand on my arm, and I let her lead me back to my own yard, because I didn't trust my legs.
"Well," Grace said quietly, "that could have gone better."
"She didn't deny it," I said. "Did you notice that? She never actually said she didn't do it."
Grace was quiet for a moment. Then she said, "I noticed." She squeezed my arm. "Now go call the police, and then the city. In that order. And Claire — from here on, you don't talk to Ruth. Not a word. You talk to the inspector, and you talk to the officer, and you let them do their jobs. You hear me?"
I heard her. I went inside, and I called the police non-emergency line, and I gave them my address and said I needed to report vandalism and flooding, and the dispatcher said an officer would come out. Then I called the city's water and code office, because Grace had said the city, and the woman on the phone said she'd send an inspector that morning. Then I sat at my kitchen table with my notebook and my phone full of pictures, and I waited, and I tried not to look at the yard. The water was mostly drained off by then, leaving behind a slick of mud and the ruined beds, flat and brown and dead-looking. Five years of mornings, under mud. I put my head down on the table next to the notebook, and I cried for about a minute, hard and quiet, and then I washed my face and went back to the window to watch for the inspector. Crying was allowed. Quitting wasn't. I had the pictures, I had the timeline, and I had the city's own letters in the folder. Somebody had done this in the night. And I was going to find out who, the way I'd learned to do everything in the last five years: one documented fact at a time.
Chapter 7: The Inspector
The inspector arrived at ten-fifteen in a white city pickup with the water department logo on the door. He was a man in his mid-forties, neat and unhurried, with a clipboard and a camera and the particular calm of somebody who has seen every kind of water disaster a suburb can produce. He introduced himself at my front door as Daniel Reyes, city water-and-code inspector, and he shook my hand like we were meeting at a barbecue.
"Show me," he said.
I took him to the manifold behind the garage, and I didn't say a word while he looked. That was hard. I wanted to narrate, to point, to explain. But Grace's voice was in my head — let them do their jobs — and Reyes didn't need my narration. He crouched by the smashed housing and studied it for a long time. He took out his own camera and photographed the split PVC from three angles. He ran a gloved finger along the tool marks on the main valve and made a note. He stood and looked at the snapped heads, and he bent down and picked up one of the broken pieces and turned it over in his hand.
"These were struck," he said. "Not worn, not frozen. Struck." He made another note. "And the valve was forced open after the damage was done. See the marks? Somebody wanted the water to keep flowing."
My throat went tight. "That's what I thought."
"It's what the evidence says," Reyes said evenly. He was careful with words, I noticed. He said what the evidence said, not what he thought. There was something steadying about it, like standing next to a wall. "Have you touched anything besides the street shutoff?"