Two hundred and forty tomato starts. A hundred and sixty peppers. Those weren't just plants. Those were the season. People had reserved them. I'd taken deposits. The peppers were my signature — the variety nobody else in the county grew, the one that brought people back year after year. Under three inches of cold April water, in soil gone to soup, they were gone. Seedlings can survive a lot, but they can't survive drowning. Their roots had been without oxygen for hours. By noon they'd be wilted past saving. I knew it the way a nurse knows it. There was no point pretending.
The basement was worse in a different way. The house had an unfinished basement — concrete floor, block walls, the place where I kept the overflow of my life. The chest freezer was down there, full of last summer's harvest I'd put up for winter. Boxes of nursery records, old tax files, the extra pots and flats. Water had seeped in through the window well and the old bulkhead door, and by the time I got down there with a flashlight, there was two inches of it across the whole floor, and the bottoms of the boxes were dark and soft. The freezer was sitting in it, humming away, and I had a wild, stupid moment of gratitude that the motor still ran before I remembered that a freezer sitting in two inches of water is a freezer that's going to die.
I called Sam Whitaker, the sprinkler contractor, and got his voicemail, and left a message that sounded calmer than I felt. I called a basement cleanup company and got a dispatcher who said they could come Thursday. I called Grace Lin, because she was the neighbor I actually liked, and she came over in her work clothes with her hose and her shop-vac and didn't ask a single question until we'd gotten the worst of the standing water moving toward the storm drain. While we worked, she told me about a patient she'd once had, years ago as a nurse, whose house had flooded in a storm — "and you know what she said to me, Claire? She said the water wasn't the worst part. The worst part was somebody else deciding it would happen." I thought about that all day. A storm is nobody's fault. This was somebody's choice, made in the dark, with a hammer. That was the part I couldn't stop turning over: not the loss, but the deliberateness. Somebody had stood where I was standing, in the dark, and decided. Then she looked at the manifold, and she looked at me, and she said, "Claire. Somebody did this."
"I know," I said.
"Do you know who?"
I looked at the fence. At Ruth's rose bed, neat and dry on the other side. At Ruth's kitchen window, the curtain pulled back just enough. "I have an idea," I said. "But ideas aren't evidence."
Grace nodded slowly. She was a practical woman, Grace. She'd worked as a nurse for twenty years before she retired, and she had the calm of somebody who'd seen worse mornings than this one. "Then get evidence," she said. "And don't go over there shouting. Shouting never fixed a thing."
She was right, and I knew she was right, and I went over there shouting anyway. Not right away. First I finished the photos. First I wrote down the timeline — when I'd last seen the system intact (Monday evening, six o'clock zone, running fine), when I'd found it (Tuesday, five-thirty a.m.), what I'd touched (the street shutoff, nothing else). I wrote it in the notebook I kept by the register, in the same neat hand I used for plant labels. Then I walked next door to 14 Willow Lane, and I knocked on Ruth Delaney's door, and when she opened it, I forgot every sensible thing Grace had just said.
Chapter 6: The Confrontation
Ruth opened the door in her bathrobe, her hair in curlers, and for a moment she just looked at me — at my wet boots, my muddy pajama pants, my face — and I saw something cross her expression that I would think about for weeks afterward. It wasn't surprise. It was calculation. The quick, private arithmetic of a person deciding what to say.
"Somebody smashed my sprinkler system last night," I said. I didn't say good morning. "Six heads snapped off, the manifold broken open, the main valve forced. Water ran all night. My seedlings are ruined and my basement's flooded."
Ruth's hand tightened on the door. "That's terrible," she said. "You should call the police."
"I will. But I'm asking you first, Ruth. Did you have anything to do with this?"
The change in her face was instant. The careful expression dropped away and what came up underneath was pure, practiced outrage. "How dare you. How dare you come to my door and accuse me. After everything —"
"After everything what?"
"Your water has been ruining my roses for two years and the city does nothing, and now you come here —" She stepped out onto the porch, bathrobe and all, and her voice went up. "My roses are dying because of your sprinklers and everybody knows it and nobody does a thing!"
"Ruth, my system was winterized until April. The city told you twice there was no violation. You got it in writing."