The idea of going undercover embarrassed me at first. It sounded theatrical, even a little dishonest, and I am not a woman who enjoys deception. I sat with that discomfort for several days. I asked myself whether I was being fair to people who had worked for me faithfully, whether I was setting a trap rather than seeking the truth. I concluded, slowly, that there was a difference between a trap and a test of ordinary hospitality. I was not going to invent a complaint or demand something unreasonable. I was going to walk in as any woman might walk in, dressed as I dressed on my days off, and ask for help buying a simple gift. If the shop welcomed me, I would learn that my worry was misplaced, and I would be glad to be wrong. If it did not, I would learn something I needed to know, and I would have to act on it. That seemed, on balance, more honest than another meeting about warmth.
I chose a Tuesday deliberately. Tuesdays were quiet enough that there would be no crowd to hide behind, but not so quiet that the staff would be idle and therefore unusually attentive. It was an ordinary working day, the kind of day on which a real customer would most need a genuine greeting. I planned the visit the way I used to plan a buying trip, with attention to small details, because small details were the whole point. I would not wear anything from the shop. I would not carry a bag that announced a price. I would not wear jewellery, not even the simple gold hoops I usually reached for. I would tie my hair back, as I did when I was cleaning the house or walking the dog, and I would wear the clothes I actually lived in when no one was looking.
On the morning itself, I stood in front of my bedroom mirror longer than I expected. I put on faded jeans, soft from many washes, with a frayed hem I had never bothered to repair. I put on a plain grey sweater, a little loose at the cuffs, the kind that keeps you warm without making a statement. I put on scuffed sneakers, white once, now dulled by pavements and rain. I picked up a canvas tote, the one I used for the farmers' market, with a faint stain near the bottom from a bunch of herbs. I left my rings in the small dish by the sink. I tied my hair back with a plain band. Looking at myself, I felt a strange mixture of familiarity and exposure. This was me, on a Sunday, on a day off, on a day when I was not performing the role of owner. It was also, I realised with a small pang, how a great many women look when they come into a shop with a birthday in mind and a budget held close. I had not dressed as a costume. I had dressed as a customer.
My mother’s birthday was three weeks away, and that gave the visit a true purpose beyond observation. I wanted to buy her a simple silk scarf, not the most elaborate piece we carried, but something soft and well made, in a colour she would actually wear. My mother favours blues and soft greens, the colours of the coast in early morning, and she dislikes anything fussy. She would rather have one beautiful thing than three showy ones. I had thought about the scarf for days, turning over in my mind which maker’s work would suit her, which weight of silk would sit well against a coat in cooler weather. That purpose was not an act. I genuinely wanted to leave with a gift in a bag, and I genuinely wanted to be helped to choose it. If I left empty-handed, it would not be because I had come in with nothing to buy.
I drove to King Street and parked two blocks away, because I did not want my car, which my staff might recognise, to announce me before I reached the door. I walked the rest of the way slowly, noticing the street as a visitor might. The shopfront looked, from the outside, exactly as I had hoped it would when I first imagined it: clean glass, a restrained display, two scarves arranged with space around them rather than crowded together, a small vase of fresh flowers that the morning light caught. It was beautiful. It was also, I noticed for the first time, a little forbidding. The glass was so clean it reflected the street more than it invited the eye inside. The door was heavy. There was no sign that said, in plain language, that anyone was welcome to come in and look. I had assumed the beauty would do that work. Standing on the pavement in my faded jeans, I was not sure it did.