He did it in a room, she said at last, into her hands. "They watched him do it in a room. Rosa. Nobody can say he didn't, now. Nobody can say it ever again."
No, Rosa said. "Nobody can say it. Eat your sandwich, mami. You're shaking."
And Denise laughed, wetly, and picked up the sandwich, and ate it, because she was a practical woman and her son had taught her, without either of them ever saying so, that a mind needs feeding same as anything else.
The interview appeared on a Tuesday, in the alumni magazine, which arrived in mailboxes across three states in a glossy envelope with a photograph of the Whitmore bell tower on the cover and the headline, inside, that the editors had chosen with the care of people who know exactly what they are doing: THE MAKING OF A PRODIGY.
Sinclair had given them four thousand words.
He did not rant. That was what made it dangerous. He was measured, wounded, reasonable as a scalpel. He spoke of his forty years of service. He spoke of the pressures of the publicity age, of universities "hungry for a story that flatters the storyteller." He said the assessment had been "conducted under conditions no serious scholar would call controlled," though the stenographer's transcript sat in a sealed file in Marchetti's office saying otherwise. He said — and this was the sentence that traveled, the sentence that was lifted out and set in bold and quoted on the evening commentary shows with a little shake of the head — that the boy was, in his judgment, "a trained performer, executing memorized repertoire with the polish of long rehearsal, as a gifted young pianist performs Chopin without understanding a note of what music is."
A trained performer. The words had a hook in them. They were built to be repeated by people who wanted a reason, any reason, to un-believe the thing they had seen, and there were more of those people than the headlines had suggested. In the comments under the article, strangers with clean hands explained to one another that of course, obviously, when you thought about it — and the thinking they did was the kind that arrives already finished, wearing its conclusion like a coat.
Andre read the interview once, at the library, on a public computer with a cracked screen, and then he closed the tab and sat for a while with his hands in his lap, looking at the dark reflection of his own face in the glass. He was not surprised. That was the worst of it, he would think later. He was sixteen years old and he was not surprised, and there ought to be a law of the universe that protected a person from running out of surprise that young.
He could have borne the magazine. He told himself so, walking home. Men like Sinclair did not surrender; they relocated the war. Fine. Let him have his four thousand words. The committee's finding was in a sealed file with his name spelled right, and his mother had eaten her sandwich in the break room like a woman at a feast.
What he could not have borne arrived on Thursday, in an envelope of a different kind, though it was not addressed to him.
It was addressed to Denise, and it was not an envelope but a summons to a meeting, printed on facilities letterhead, in the tone institutions use when they have already decided and are merely scheduling the announcement. A complaint had been received. An anonymous complaint, filed through the proper channel, alleging that over a period of years, university property — specifically, library and departmental books, textbooks, and printed materials — had been removed from Whitmore premises by a member of the custodial staff, for personal use, in violation of policy and of the terms of employment. An investigation was required. Pending its outcome, Denise Powell was suspended from her position, effective immediately. Without pay.
Denise read the letter standing in the kitchen, with her coat still on, because she had come straight from the bus. She read it twice. Her lips moved on the second reading, the way they moved over bills.
Books, she said. "They're saying I stole books."
Mama—
They're saying I stole the books. She set the letter down on the counter and smoothed it with one palm, gently, as if it were a thing that might tear. "The books out of the recycling. The books they throw away. The ones with the coffee on them. The ones in the dumpster with the—" She stopped. Her hand stayed flat on the letter. "Eleven years I never took a paper clip. Eleven years. I cleaned a man's office who kept cash in his desk, loose cash, and I dusted around it. I never took a paper clip out of that building, Andre."
I know that.
Do you know what they're going to say? Her voice stayed level, which was how Andre knew she was past the country where level voices live. "They're going to say the janitor stole books to make her son look smart. They're going to say that's the whole story. That's what the letter is for. It's not about the books. The books are just the shape they could make the paper take."