"Solve This, I'll Give You an A" Prof Laughed — His Laugh Died When Black Student Finished in 5 Min

Chapter 22

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Ms. Angela Foster stood in the doorway of their apartment holding a grocery bag against her chest like a hymnal.

She taught mathematics at his high school, in Room 214, with a poster of Katherine Johnson on the wall and a voice that could quiet forty teenagers; she had been Andre's teacher in ninth grade and again this year. She wore her coat and a knitted hat, and the grocery bag was full in the way of bags packed by someone who has thought about what a kitchen actually runs out of: rice, oil, eggs, oranges, a chicken, tea, the good kind of peanut butter, and on top, absurd and perfect, a small bunch of flowers wrapped in paper, the cheap bright kind from the corner store.

Mrs. Powell, she said. "Forgive me. I got your address from—" She stopped. "No. I won't lie to you in your own doorway. I looked it up in the school file, which I am not supposed to do, and if that costs me something later I'll pay it then. May I come in? I won't stay. I just—" Her voice, the voice that quieted forty teenagers, did something it had never done in Room 214. "I have something I've needed to say to your son for about four years, and I read the newspaper this week, and I decided that if I waited for a proper occasion I would die having been a coward in the correct format."

Denise stepped back. "Come in out of the hall, Ms. Foster."

They sat at the kitchen table, the three of them, with the bills pushed to one side in a neat stack — Denise would not hide them, she simply moved them the way you move a chair for a guest — and the flowers stood in a water glass in the middle of the table, indecently cheerful, and Angela Foster folded her hands and looked at Andre like a person setting down something heavy carried a long way.

I knew, she said. "That's what I came to say. I knew in ninth grade. You turned in a test in October — do you remember? You solved the last problem, the one I put on for the two girls I thought might be gifted, by a method I had never seen. Not wrong. Better. I sat at my desk that night and understood that the boy in the third row who never spoke was doing mathematics I couldn't follow to the end. And I said nothing."

Ms. Foster—

Let me finish, because I've rehearsed it in the car and the car version was better. She breathed. "I told myself I didn't know how to help. That a boy like you needed a program we didn't have and a budget that didn't exist, and that if I made noise and got it wrong I'd mark you — make you a target, a project, a performance. All of that was even partly true. But the whole truth is I was afraid of the size of it. You were the biggest thing I'd ever seen in a classroom and I was afraid of being the person who mishandled you. So I gave you A's and I left you alone, and I called it respect. It wasn't respect, Andre. It was abandonment with good manners. And then a stranger with a chalkboard and a cruel streak did in five minutes what I didn't do in four years — he made the world look at you. He did it for the worst reason there is. But he did it, and I didn't, and I am sorry, and I will spend whatever's left of my career making sure I am never again that kind of sorry."

The kitchen was quiet. The radiator ticked. Somewhere below them a door closed and a child laughed in the stairwell, falling away down the flights.

You brought flowers, Denise said at last, gently, into the silence, "and a chicken, and the truth. Sit and have tea with us, Angela. The boy's going to want to argue with you about the word abandonment, because he argues with every word that costs somebody else something, but he'll do it politely, and after the tea."

Andre did argue, politely, and it did not matter, and over the tea — the good tea, from her own bag, which Denise had accepted with the gravity of a treaty — the three of them talked about ordinary things: the school, the winter coming, whether the committee's recommendations would turn into anything real or evaporate. When Angela Foster left, she hugged Denise at the door with the awkwardness of a woman not raised to it, and she put her hand, briefly, on Andre's head, as if he were much younger, and did not apologize for that either.

After she had gone, and the bag was unpacked, and the chicken was in the refrigerator like a small pink promise, Andre went to his room — the room that was half a room, curtained off the living room — and he knelt down and pulled out the shoebox from under the bed.

It was a running-shoe box, size eleven, his father's last pair. Inside it, stacked in order because even at eight he had been a creature of order, were the notebooks. Eleven of them now. Spiral-bound, marble-covered, filled edge to edge in a hand that changed as the years changed it, from the huge wobbling capitals of a child to the small exact script of the boy at the blackboard.

He took out the first one. The cover had a rocket ship on it, drawn in crayon, badly, with the flames coming out the wrong end. He opened it to the first page, and there it was, in pencil, in letters an inch tall, the date, and below it the first problem he had ever copied out of a thrown-away book and solved all by himself, at a desk in an empty lecture hall, at two in the morning, with his mother humming somewhere down the corridor over her mop:

News in the same category

"Solve This, I'll Give You an A" Prof Laughed — His Laugh Died When Black Student Finished in 5 Min

45 Part