"Solve This, I'll Give You an A" Prof Laughed — His Laugh Died When Black Student Finished in 5 Min

Chapter 34

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The conduct review was held in a room Andre never saw, and that was as it should be, and he was glad of it, and he thought about it anyway for three days straight.

He knew the room by description because Marchetti, who believed that a person who has been harmed by a proceeding is owed a plain account of it, told him the shape of it afterward without ornament. A wood-paneled hearing room on the second floor of the administration building, the panels dark with a century of polish, a long table, water glasses sweating onto coasters. Five members of the review board. A stenographer. And Edmund Sinclair, tenured professor of mathematics, holder of an endowed chair, author of two textbooks and a shelf of papers, seated at the far end of the table in a suit the color of wet slate, with his hands folded, discovering what the room felt like from the chair that was not at its head.

They played the video first. Marchetti said you could hear it in the corridor, faintly, through the heavy door — Sinclair's own voice, arriving out of a laptop's small speakers, thinned and flattened and somehow more damning for being diminished, the way a shout sounds worse repeated quietly.

Who let this thing into my classroom?

The board watched the professor watch himself. On the screen, a lecture hall full of young people laughed on cue, and phones rose like a tide coming in, and a sixteen-year-old boy in a too-large jacket stood in the doorway of the hall with his mother's shift not yet begun and nowhere else in the world to be.

Then the clerk read the transcript aloud, because the regulations required the record to be spoken and not merely shown, and so every word Sinclair had said that afternoon was given back to the room in a stranger's level voice, without his music in it, without the grin that had carried it.

Get out. You should go help your father clean the toilets.

A bunch of stinking — the clerk paused, once, the way a person pauses stepping over something on a path, and continued — idiots. This is going to be hilarious.

Solve this. I'll give you an A. Go ahead. Show me what the janitor's little son can do.

Marchetti said that Sinclair did not interrupt, and did not look away, and that his hands, which had begun folded, came unfolded somewhere in the middle of it and lay flat on the table on either side of his water glass, palm down, like a man keeping himself in his seat by main force. He had not known — the board's questions established this, and established that it was no defense — that Andre's father was ten years dead. He had not known the boy's name. He had not known the woman who cleaned his building at night was the boy's mother. He had known a uniform in a doorway and a face that did not belong to his idea of the room, and out of that much knowledge, and no more, he had built everything he said.

When his turn came to speak, the board offered him the thing the whole apparatus had been constructed to offer: the opportunity to account for himself, and, if he could find it in himself, to apologize. Sinclair stood. He was a man who had commanded lecture halls for thirty years, a man whose pauses were instruments, and Marchetti said you could feel him reach for the instrument out of pure habit, the way a falling man reaches for a rail.

I want to say, he began, "that my remarks that afternoon have been taken very much out of the context of a long and, I believe, distinguished career of service to this institution and its students." He said that in the heat of a disrupted lecture, words were chosen poorly. He said that if any person present had taken offense — if the young man had felt himself singled out — then he, Sinclair, regretted that his phrasing had lent itself to such an interpretation. He said that standards were standards, and that a university which ceased to defend the boundary of its classrooms would cease to be a university, and that he hoped the board would weigh a single afternoon against three decades.

He sat down into a silence that Marchetti described to Andre with care, because she understood he would want it exact. It was not an angry silence. It was worse than angry. It was the silence of five people writing things down.

One of the board members, a historian, a woman Sinclair had eaten lunch beside for twenty years, asked him a single question. She asked whether, in the weeks since, he had learned the boy's name. And Sinclair — who had read the file, who had sat through the video twice, whose own suspension letter had the name typed in its first paragraph — hesitated. It was a small hesitation. It lasted perhaps two seconds. In a lecture hall it would have passed unnoticed. In that room it was the loudest thing that had happened all day, because everyone at the table understood at the same moment that the name had simply never become important enough to keep, that to Edmund Sinclair, even now, even here, the boy remained a category that had embarrassed him, and not a person who had been embarrassed.

The board withdrew to deliberate. Their finding was prepared offstage, in the manner of such findings, and delivered days later in a sealed memorandum. But the afternoon had one more scene, and it did not take place in the hearing room.

News in the same category

"Solve This, I'll Give You an A" Prof Laughed — His Laugh Died When Black Student Finished in 5 Min

45 Part