"Good," I said. "Do not show him. Do not let anyone show him. And do not let Elena see it until I have spoken to her."
Mrs. Alvarez nodded, and for a moment neither of us spoke. The kitchen was warm and smelled of bread, and outside the window the garden was bright and green, and it was hard to believe that a photograph taken in that garden, on an ordinary afternoon, could be turned into something so ugly by morning.
"Mr. Sterling," Mrs. Alvarez said at last, quietly, "Elena did not steal that ring. I have known her for three years, and I have never known her to take anything that was not hers. She wears it on a chain, under her dress, where no one can see it. She does not show it off. She does not talk about it. She only takes it out when Noah asks about his mother, and then she holds it in her hand and tells him that his mother loved him very much."
"I know," I said. "I know that now. I should have known it sooner."
Before Mrs. Alvarez could answer, my phone rang. The sound was sharp in the quiet kitchen, and I knew before I looked at the screen who it would be. It was Vivian Hart. I let it ring three times, and then I answered, because I wanted to hear what she would say when she thought she had won.
"Alexander," she said, and her voice was warm and smooth, as if we were old friends, as if she had not just tried to destroy a woman and a child in print. "I am so sorry. I saw the paper this morning, and I was horrified. I had no idea it would be so cruel. I tried to stop it, truly I did, but once the press has a story like this, there is nothing anyone can do."
"You tried to stop it," I said, and I kept my voice even, although my hands had tightened around the phone.
"I did," she said. "I called the editor myself, last night, when I heard what they were planning. I told them it was unfair, that Elena was a good woman, that Noah was only a child. But they would not listen. They said the public has a right to know. They said a billionaire cannot hide a scandal like this forever."
"And what do you suggest I do?" I asked.
There was a pause, and I could hear her breathing, slow and careful, as if she were choosing her words with great care.
"Marry me," she said. "Marry me, and it will all go away. I can make it go away, Alexander. I have friends in the press. I can tell them that the story was a mistake, that Elena was only a maid, that you have chosen a proper wife, and that Noah will have a real mother now. The papers will print a correction. The photographs will stop. No one will remember Elena in a week. But if you do not marry me, I cannot protect her. The story will go on, and on, and on, until there is nothing left of her reputation, and nothing left of yours. Noah will be teased at school. People will point at him in the street. Is that what you want for your son?"
I stood in the kitchen with the newspaper on the table in front of me and Vivian Hart's voice in my ear, and I thought about how easy it would have been, three years ago, to say yes to a woman like her. She was beautiful, and clever, and she knew how to make a problem disappear, and she knew how to make a man feel as if he were being reasonable when he was really being afraid. I had almost said yes to her once, at a dinner, when she had leaned across the table and told me that Noah needed a mother, and that I needed a wife, and that we were both wasting time. I had almost believed her. Now, listening to her offer me a marriage in exchange for a woman's ruin, I felt nothing but a cold, clear disgust, and underneath it, a strange kind of relief, because for the first time in three years, I knew exactly what I would not do.
"No," I said.
"Alexander, please," Vivian said, and for the first time her voice lost its smoothness. "Think about Noah. Think about what this will do to him."
"I am thinking about Noah," I said. "That is why I am saying no."
I ended the call before she could answer, and I put the phone down on the table beside the newspaper. Mrs. Alvarez was still standing there, and she was looking at me with an expression I had not seen on her face before. It was not respect. It was something warmer than respect, and something sadder, too, as if she had been waiting a long time to see me do the right thing, and was glad that I had finally done it, even if it had taken me too long.
"Call Daniel Okafor," I said. "Tell him I need him here, now, and that it is urgent. And tell him to bring everything he can find about Sophia's ring, and about Elena, and about the night Sophia died. I want the truth, Mrs. Alvarez. I want it in writing, with witnesses, with dates, with everything. I have spent three years living on what other people told me was true. I will not do it any longer."