The letter was not long, but every sentence in it felt as if it had been written with great care, as if Sophia had known that she would not have much time, and that she needed to say the most important things first. She wrote that she was giving her ring to Elena, not lending it, not asking her to keep it safe for a little while, but giving it to her, freely, because Elena had been her best friend since they were girls, and because Elena had been the one who stayed with her through the long nights in the hospital, when I was away on business and my mother was too frightened to come near the ward. She wrote that Elena had promised to raise Noah, and that she, Sophia, had asked her to make that promise, and that she trusted Elena more than she trusted anyone else in the world, except for me. She wrote that she knew my mother would not understand, and that she knew people would talk, and that she knew Elena would be accused of wanting money, or a title, or a place in our family that was not hers. She wrote that if anyone ever said Elena had stolen the ring, they were lying, and that the truth was in the hospital records, and in the memory of the nurse who had been there that night, a woman named Margaret Bennett, who had watched Sophia take the ring from her own finger and place it in Elena's hand. She wrote that she wanted Elena to keep the ring until Noah was old enough to understand, and then to give it to him, or to keep it, as she chose, because it was hers now, and no one had the right to take it from her. She wrote that she loved me, and that she loved Noah, and that she was not afraid, because she knew that Elena would sing to Noah when he was frightened, and that I would learn, in time, to listen.
When Daniel finished reading, he folded the letter very carefully and put it back in the envelope, and he placed the envelope on my desk, and he did not speak for a long time. I did not speak either. I sat with my hands flat on the desk, looking at the envelope, and thinking about the fact that Sophia had known, even as she was dying, that Elena would be accused, and that she had tried to protect her, and that I had failed to protect her myself. I had allowed my mother to threaten her. I had allowed Vivian to lie about her. I had allowed a newspaper to print a photograph of my son and call his love a scandal. I had done nothing, for three years, except work and grieve, and tell myself that I was being strong.
"There is more," Daniel said at last, quietly. "I spoke to Margaret Bennett. She is still a nurse at the hospital, although she is older now, and she remembers that night very clearly. She remembers Sophia taking off the ring, and she remembers Elena crying, and saying that she could not take it, that it was too much, and Sophia saying that it was not too much, that it was exactly enough, because it was a promise, not a present. Margaret Bennett is willing to speak, in public, if you need her to. She said she has waited three years for someone to ask her."
"Tell her I will ask her," I said. "Tell her I am sorry it took me so long."
Daniel nodded, and he gathered his papers, and he left me alone with the letter, and I sat there for a long time, holding the envelope in my hands, and reading Sophia's words on the front of it over and over again, as if by reading them enough times I could make up for the years I had spent not knowing they were there. For Elena, when she needs it. She needed it now. She needed it more than she had ever needed anything in her life, and I was the one who was going to give it to her, not because I was her employer, and not because I was Noah's father, but because I was Sophia's husband, and Sophia had asked me, in that letter, to learn to listen.
An hour later, Elena came to my study, as I had asked her to, and she stood in the doorway for a moment before she came in, as if she were not sure whether she was allowed to enter. She was wearing her plain grey dress, and her hair was pulled back, and the gold chain was hidden under her collar, where it always was, and she looked tired, and frightened, and very young, although I knew she must be nearly thirty, and had lived through more than most women her age. I stood up when she came in, and I gestured to the chair opposite my desk, and she sat down very slowly, with her hands folded in her lap, and she waited for me to speak.
"Elena," I said, "I have read the newspaper. I know what it says. I know what Vivian Hart is trying to do. I want you to know that I do not believe a word of it."
She looked at me, and her eyes filled with tears, but she did not cry. She blinked, hard, and she looked down at her hands, and when she spoke, her voice was steady, although I could hear the effort it cost her to keep it that way.
"Mr. Sterling," she said, "I am grateful to you for saying that, but it does not change what has happened. The photograph is in the paper. People have seen it. They will talk about Noah, and they will talk about me, and they will talk about you, and it will not stop, not because it is true, but because it is interesting. I have thought about this all morning, and I have made a decision. I will leave. I will pack my things tonight, and I will go in the morning, before Noah wakes, so that he does not have to watch me go. It will be better for him. He will forget me, in time. He is only five. Children forget. It will be better for you, too. You can marry Vivian, or Celeste, or Isabella, and no one will ever mention my name again."