The supplier was embarrassed, then defensive. His accountant said the contract was legally binding and the ferry office had never questioned the rate. Calvin asked whether they could recover past payments. Miriam warned that a dispute might jeopardise the deliveries during winter. Ellis wanted to cancel the agreement and call a larger firm. Tessa preferred a negotiated correction, with a written timetable for reviewing the historic charges. None of those choices was costless. At the joint finance session Calvin asked why the west should carry the risk of a winter shortage when the east had approved the contract. Ellis said the shared authority had approved it. Calvin laid the signatures on the table: three east officers, none from the west.
For twenty minutes the meeting collapsed into a discussion about who could honestly be said to represent whom. Tessa did not intervene until both men had stopped expecting the other to concede. She asked Miriam to calculate the probable annual difference if the rate were corrected. Miriam said the saving would be modest beside the fleet budget but significant to the west reserve. A new engine could not be bought with it. A year's worth of late staff transport might be paid. Calvin's face changed. He had been imagining the cost as an abstract injustice. Now he could name the people it affected.
They invited the supplier to a meeting without lawyers, on the understanding that no agreement would be final until both councils reviewed the terms. He arrived with a folder full of delivery records and admitted he had not noticed that the location code was wrong. His bookkeeper had used the inherited contract because it saved time. Miriam showed him what the erroneous charge had produced. He offered a credit against future deliveries. Calvin wanted a refund. Ellis asked whether a concession on winter prices would be more valuable than recovering money already spent. Tessa asked them to write down both figures, then left them to negotiate. She had been preparing to chair the discussion and discovered that she was not needed for every minute of it.
A week later the supplier agreed to a partial refund and a fixed tariff reviewed annually. The west council approved it unanimously. The east council approved it after an argument about whether such a small recovery was worth the public attention. A councillor suggested reporting only that the fuel contract had been modernised. Miriam said the financial statement would show the refund regardless. Tessa watched the councillor reconsider. The forms that had once hidden a mistake could also compel an accurate account if the people keeping them refused to soften the numbers.
The same meeting considered the common reserve. For years the two shores had contributed in proportion to passengers carried, a measure that favoured the larger east routes. The west provided the longer emergency rescue distance, and in bad weather its crews often waited without carrying a single paying passenger. The present formula rewarded traffic, not readiness. Ellis defended it as objective. Calvin said a measurement could be objective and still answer the wrong question. Tessa suggested commissioning an independent calculation of standby costs, but the accountants wanted instructions about the outcome they were to model. 'Show us the actual cost of readiness,' she said, 'not the answer that makes either of us happy.'
The report was expensive. When its estimate arrived, both councils hated something in it. The east would have to pay more during the summer, when its passenger volume was high; the west would have to contribute more in winter, when it relied on emergency crews and revenues were lower. A proposal built on resentment had produced a burden neither side could escape. Calvin told Tessa this was the first document he had seen that felt genuinely joint. She said she doubted the accountants would appreciate the compliment.
At the public review a shopkeeper demanded that the west pay nothing until its right to appoint captains was recognised. A bus operator replied that a missed service would put his drivers out of work no matter who held the appointment pen. A former councillor from the east warned that separate budgets were the first stage of abandoning the alliance. Tessa explained the distinction between a shared service and a single hierarchy. A person could contribute to a common boat without agreeing that the opposite shore should select the officer who commanded the landing. It was the kind of sentence that sounded clean in a policy paper and drew twenty untidy questions in public.
One question came from a boy carrying a recorder. He asked who would decide when the river was too dangerous to cross. Tessa described the captain's authority. The boy said he had been told Ellis could overrule any captain. Ellis, seated in the front row, answered before she could. He said no director had the right to order an unsafe departure. The boy asked why the handbook described the director as final operational authority. The room went quiet. Arthur, sitting near the back, said the handbook was an older version and the safety regulation superseded it. That explanation was accurate. It did not excuse leaving the wrong instructions on the desk where new captains trained.
After the meeting Ellis asked Tessa whether she had encouraged the question. She said she had not known it was coming. He asked whether she had enjoyed watching him answer it. That was harder. She admitted there had been a moment of satisfaction when he could not dismiss the boy as someone who did not understand operations. Ellis looked away. 'Then we're both being honest,' he said. She wanted to ask what he meant by both. He had already begun speaking about the next day's forecast.