The strongest criticism of the new arrangement came from a village that had supported withdrawal by a large majority. Its residents used the west landing but lived beyond the boundary of the district represented on the new council. They had voted in the general referendum yet could not vote for the district captain. A shopkeeper named Ruth Ellison brought a petition saying that independence had simply moved authority from one distant desk to another. Tessa read it during a crowded council session. The signatures filled four pages, with addresses that extended well beyond the line on the map.
Calvin explained that the district boundaries were inherited from an older administrative division and could not be changed overnight. Ruth said that was precisely what Ellis had said when west residents complained about east appointments. Several councillors looked offended. Tessa found the comparison uncomfortable and accurate. The new council had promised people the right to choose, then discovered that the legal definition of people did not include everyone affected by its decisions. She asked the boundary commission for advice, knowing the answer might require a formal review and another election.
The commission's officer, Dr. Keane, came to examine the boundaries. She studied the river, the roads and the settlements that had grown since the maps were drawn. She said a boundary drawn for taxation might not describe the community that depended on transport. But an immediate expansion of the electorate could diminish the votes of those already inside the district. Every change would create a different complaint. Tessa asked for options with the consequences of each stated plainly. Dr. Keane proposed an advisory committee from the outlying villages while the legal review proceeded. Ruth called it a consolation prize. She nevertheless volunteered to serve, saying someone ought to make sure the committee did not become an excuse to postpone the review.
At its first session the advisory group argued about membership. The villages nearest the river wanted more seats because they supplied the most passengers. The farther villages said they would be excluded again if seats were proportional to ticket sales. One member suggested each settlement choose a representative regardless of size, but a larger village objected that this gave twenty households the same voice as two hundred. Tessa watched them confront the problem she and Ellis had debated on a larger scale: how to combine participation with workable decisions. She offered examples from other local transport bodies, then asked the group to choose what fit their circumstances.
They settled on a mixed arrangement: one delegate from each village, plus additional places for the largest settlements, with decisions treated as recommendations until the boundary review concluded. The rule did not please everyone. Ruth said she could live with it if dissenting opinions were included in the public minutes. Sophie agreed and produced a simple form for minority statements. Calvin objected that the reports might become unwieldy. Ruth reminded him that people had spent years being told there was no need to record disagreement because someone in authority would make the sensible decision. Calvin withdrew the objection.
The advisory committee's first recommendation concerned a connecting bus. It reached the west landing three minutes after the afternoon ferry departed, forcing passengers to wait almost an hour. The bus company said it could not shift the route without disrupting school transport. The ferry captain said moving the crossing would break the east workers' connection. The committee proposed a different solution: a seasonal short crossing on market days, with passenger numbers reviewed after three months. Arthur checked the maintenance implications; Miriam calculated the fuel cost. The proposal was expensive enough to require a vote but small enough to test without changing the entire timetable.
At the public hearing, one of the older councillors asked why the west should pay for a service mostly used by villagers outside the district. Ruth stood and said those villagers bought tickets, worked in west shops and paid rates through the county that supported the landing. She listed the places where the boundary already failed to describe economic life. Calvin admitted the committee's recommendation had revealed a blind spot. He voted for the trial. The council approved it by a narrow margin, with a requirement that usage figures be published even if the result was disappointing.
The first trial crossing carried three passengers. A councillor called it wasteful before the week was out. Tessa resisted the temptation to defend it by exaggerating what three journeys meant. The second crossing carried eleven, the third nine. Weather interrupted the fourth. By the end of the month usage was lower than supporters had hoped but higher than the old forecast. The committee asked for a full seasonal comparison before cancelling. Ruth said the point of a trial was to learn, not to provide instant vindication. Tessa wished every public argument could be kept that honest.
During the second month, a road closure near the village diverted traffic towards the landing. Passenger numbers rose sharply. A newspaper praised the new crossing as a success of west independence. Tessa wrote to the editor explaining that the increase was partly temporary. The editor said she was making her own side look foolish. She replied that the figures would eventually be public, and that a good decision did not require misleading evidence. The paper printed a short correction. Ruth rang to thank her and then complained that the ferry still left five minutes too early on Thursdays. Tessa wrote down the complaint. Approval, she was learning, did not mean the end of accountability.