Tessa read it twice. She remembered the signing ceremony, the white tablecloth, the photograph now hanging in the office. Nobody in the photograph looked like a person about to argue over a clause. The notebook did not prove what the final agreement said. It proved that the question had been asked.
Ellis came in carrying a bag of apples. When he saw the notebook, he paused at the doorway.
"Your mother was always writing things down," he said.
"She wanted to know who appointed the west captains."
"She knew how it worked."
"That isn't the same as answering."
He put the apples in the bowl. "She also knew what happened when two committees claimed the same ferry. We were trying to keep a service alive."
"And she thought the west needed a choice."
"She thought many things. She was allowed to disagree with me."
Tessa looked up sharply. "Then why aren't they allowed?"
Ellis leaned on the counter. The silence that followed held more than the current argument. It held the years when Tessa had let him tell her which matters needed attention and which could be delayed, the weeks after the funeral when she had agreed to anything that preserved a routine, and the private fear that if she refused him now he would stop recognising the daughter he had raised.
"Don't pretend this is what she would have wanted," he said at last.
"I'm trying to stop pretending I know," Tessa answered. She closed the notebook and put it back in the drawer. She would request the signed agreement from the archive. Her mother's question deserved a factual answer, not an argument between survivors over who had loved her best.
The signed alliance agreement came from a cabinet in the town hall basement, bound with a faded ribbon. The clerk brought it to Tessa and Calvin under a lamp that hummed over the archive desk. The document was longer than either of them remembered. It described shared fare collection and equipment, appointed representatives to a joint operations panel and set out a method for ending the arrangement. It did not clearly transfer the west council's power to choose its own captain. In an annex, however, a paragraph authorised the joint office to confirm appointments for safety reasons.
"There," Calvin said, pointing to the page. "He'll tell us confirmation means selection."
A week after the council announced its intention to review appointments, Tessa received a request from the east personnel office for the original documents proving her eligibility to hold the district seat. She had supplied them ten years earlier. The request was technically legitimate; the records had been digitised and a signature was missing from the electronic copy. It arrived on the same morning Ellis cancelled a meeting she was scheduled to lead. She could not know whether the coincidence was deliberate. That uncertainty made the letter more disturbing than a direct threat.
She took the papers to the personnel office herself. The administrator, Faye Lawson, was a young woman who had begun work three months earlier and had no reason to know the private history of the Vane family. She looked embarrassed when she saw Tessa. The database had flagged several old appointments, she explained; everyone would be asked to provide the missing documents. Tessa asked how many other notices had gone out. Faye said nine. The rule applied to her as it did to them. Tessa left feeling foolish for having turned an administrative task into a possible retaliation before checking the facts.
Two days later the personnel office issued a second notice. This one asked whether her work with the west council created a conflict of interest in relation to her east district duties. The same rule applied to any officer who accepted external responsibilities, but nobody else had been asked to resign before a review. Tessa read the regulation carefully. It permitted temporary suspension if a conflict posed immediate harm. It did not say that talking to another council was itself a conflict. She asked for a hearing and copied her request to the east personnel committee. Ellis telephoned within an hour.
'You can save everyone the trouble by dropping the west proposal,' he said.
'Are you asking that as my father or my director?'
'I'm asking you to think about your future.'
'Which is it?'
He paused. 'I'm telling you the rules are there for a reason.'
Tessa wanted to hang up. Instead she asked him to put any instruction affecting her employment in writing. He said she was making their relationship absurdly formal. She replied that the formality protected them both. Neither had to guess later whether a family argument had become an official order. After the call she sat for a long time with the telephone face down. She was shaking, not because the conversation had been loud, but because he had known exactly which uncertainty would frighten her.
At the hearing, a committee member asked whether she had used east equipment for the west campaign. She produced copies of her expense claims and her private receipts. She had paid for travel to political meetings herself. Two hours of photocopying had been charged to the east office because the documents were required for a joint safety review. The committee asked for proof. She supplied the meeting agenda and the clerk's instruction. The chair found that use proper. Another member asked whether her public statements had undermined the service. Tessa answered that they had questioned its appointment system, not the competence of its crews.