Simmons Machining sat on the east side, in a long brick building that had been a streetcar barn before it had been anything else, and it announced itself the way old shops do: with presence, a loading dock worn smooth, and windows kept clean by somebody who believed windows were a promise to the street. Ninety people worked there. Clara knew the number the way she knew every supplier's number — but knowing a number, she was learning, was not the same as knowing what it weighed.
Denise Simmons met her at the office door herself, because of course she did. She was forty-one, tall like her grandfather, with her hair cut close and a machinist's economy of movement even in an office sweater, and she looked at Clara with an expression that was not hostility, exactly, but something more exhausting: the look of a woman deciding how much of the truth a visitor had earned.
"You came yourself," Denise said. "Nobody from Kestrel has come themselves in two years. They send the portal." She held the door. "Come on, then. You may as well see what a portal can't."
She walked Clara through the shop first, because the shop was the argument. Rows of machining centers, some old and kept like honored elders, some new; the smell of cutting fluid and hot metal; a wall of inspection gauges laid out like surgical instruments; and people — Clara counted without meaning to, the operations habit — who nodded at Denise the way people nod at someone whose competence is a settled fact. At the far end, under the tall windows, an empty bay stood with its machines sheeted, not mothballed, but waiting, the way a held note waits.
"That bay was yours," Denise said. "Kestrel's work ran there for eleven years. It's been sheeted since March."
They went up to the office, which was small and fiercely organized, and Denise did not offer her the soft version. She opened a binder — tabbed and annotated — and put it on the desk between them.
"That's our bid," she said. "For the machining contract. The last one. Your people ran it as a scored competition — tolerance, delivery, quality, capacity, price. Their own scoring, from their own evaluation team. Read the summary page."
Clara read it. She already knew the shape of what she would find — you do not run operations without learning to smell an arranged result — but there is a difference between smelling a thing and holding it. Simmons Machining: first on tolerance, first on quality history, first on delivery, second on capacity, second on price. Total score, first. Not close, first.
"And the award went offshore," Clara said.
"The award went to a strategic consolidation." Denise's voice was very dry. "I have the letter. Procurement wrote me a beautiful letter. It thanked us for our long partnership. It used the word synergy, which in my experience is what people say when they don't want to say the cheaper word, which is cheaper. Or when somebody upstairs wanted the local name off the books before they dressed the company up for sale. I never figured out which, and I stopped asking. I had a shop to run."
"Your grandfather—" Clara began.
My grandfather made your grandfather's first part on a handshake with no paper, in that shop, at a bench I can show you. It's still there. We don't use it; we keep it oiled. "Walter Simmons built this company on that handshake, and Elias Brandt built Kestrel on it, and for forty years the two companies kept faith at that bench. Then your Mr. Kellerman decided the past was a cost center. He never called me, you know. A man who is going to end a forty-year relationship ought to be able to pick up a telephone. Instead it came through a portal and a letter with the word synergy in it. My grandfather shook a hand. His successor sent a form letter."
"What does losing the contract mean," Clara asked, "in real terms? Not the statement. The real terms."
Denise considered her; the visitor had asked the second question, the one that mattered.
"Ninety people," Denise said. "Was ninety-six. I laid off six in the spring and I dream about it still, all six faces, in order. The bay stays sheeted. I bid small work to fill the hours, and every week I decide again whether to sell two of the old machines. My grandfather is gone eleven years. He never saw it end. I'm grateful for that in a way I can't say out loud at home." She closed the binder, gently, as if it were sleeping. "I kept the scored bid because my grandfather kept everything, and because some part of me believed somebody from your building would eventually come and ask to see it. You're the first."
"I'm not here officially," Clara said. "I have no authority to promise you anything, and I won't insult you by—"
"Clara." Denise said it the way you interrupt someone you have decided to respect. "You drove across town with no appointment and asked to see the sheeted bay. I know what official looks like. Official sends a portal." A pause. "What are you actually doing?"