The Extended Hand

Chapter 31

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Here is my arithmetic, after two weeks of sitting with it. Cash into the second quarter. A signed term sheet for nine hundred million that our own counsel cannot call definitely unauthorized — it is a masterpiece of the word 'arguably.' Against that: a commitment of seven hundred and fifty million, withdrawn in writing, confirmed in writing, from an investor silent since November ninth, whose return this motion assumes on hope and family connection. I spent thirty years in credit. Hope is not a facility. Remove the chief executive today and we void the Grange Point signature — their term sheet names him as accountable executive — and we hold: no Grange Point money, no Adeyemi money, a credit facility under review, and an interim team. I have seen that film. It does not end with a handshake. It ends with a receiver, who does not care about the etiquette of any year.

"Mr. Girard will speak for the plan, and he will be right about what the shares mean. I ask him to weigh what they will be worth: a covenant with a bankrupt is a claim in a proceeding. I will vote no — not for Andrew Kellerman's manners, which are indefensible, but for the two thousand three hundred people whose names are on no term sheet. I would rather be wrong in their company than righteous in the receiver's."

She sat down. Kellerman did not thank her; gratitude would have made it a favor, and she had not intended it as one.

"Mr. Girard," Elias said. "The plan's shares are yours to speak for."

Paul Girard was sixty-one, a Kestrel man for thirty-four years, the first nineteen on the floor at Plant 1, and trustee of the employee stock ownership plan for eight. He did not stand; trustees, he believed, reported better sitting down.

"I am not going to argue with Mr. Kellerman's numbers. They're real; I checked them the way Ms. Ellison did, because the plan's money is in them too. And I won't argue with her film — I sat in a cafeteria in 2009 and watched men older than me learn what their shares in another company were worth. So let me tell you what the twenty-two percent is, because this room has been describing it wrong.

"The plan holds the retirement of about nineteen hundred people. Not a savings account — their retirement. For much of the floor it is the only retirement asset they have besides Social Security; this company ended the pension in '98, and the plan replaced it. Every January I do the enrollment meetings myself, both plants. I do not tell a twenty-four-year-old machinist that she owns a financial instrument. I tell her she owns a piece of the place, and that it will be there when she is sixty-five if the place is there, and that all of our jobs are to make sure the place is there. She believes me because so far it has been true.

"Mr. Kellerman says a handshake is a courtesy, and in a world that runs by contract he is right; I have signed enough contracts to know it. But the board needs to understand what a handshake is on the floor, because the floor is where the twenty-two percent lives. On the floor, the shake is not decoration on an agreement. It is the part that says the paper isn't the whole of it — that if the paper has a hole in it, the man across from you will stand in the hole. Our people watched the video of November sixth; everybody in America watched it. They did not see an etiquette question. They saw their company tell a woman who had come to put three quarters of a billion dollars into their plant that her hand was not worth taking — and they took it as information about what this company's word is worth when keeping it gets uncomfortable.

"Since November sixth I have had something over two hundred conversations with plan participants. Not one asked about the term sheet. Every one asked the same question in different words: if they'll do that to her, with the cameras on, what will they do to us in a dispute about the plan, with no cameras anywhere? I am the trustee; 'trust' is the entire job description. I cannot stand up in January and ask that machinist to trust the paper her retirement is written on, from a company whose leadership has explained that the unwritten parts of an agreement are courtesies that may be withheld.

"Ms. Ellison says a covenant with a bankrupt is a claim in a proceeding. She's right; it kept me up two nights. But a company whose word is discounted doesn't reach bankruptcy all at once. It gets there by degrees — a customer shortens the leash, a supplier wants cash sooner, a bank asks shorter questions, and Mr. Hale told you this morning the bank has already shortened its questions. That is the discount, starting. It doesn't appear in Mr. Kellerman's numbers, because his numbers end at the quarter, and the discount compounds past it.

News in the same category

The Extended Hand

45 Part