"You have voted. Sixty-four to thirty-six is not a misunderstanding; it is a decision, yours to make, and it has been made properly. I do not agree with it, and I believe this company will learn its cost in rooms less courteous than this one. But I ran this company for three years on the proposition that decisions properly made are executed, not relitigated, and I will not end my tenure by exempting myself from my own doctrine. I will cooperate with the transition through close of business; my office will be clear by six o'clock. I thank the board for the opportunity" — the word landed without irony and without warmth, a coin placed precisely on a counter — "and I thank Ms. Ellison for the only argument made today about the company's survival rather than its conscience. You have decided the conscience matters more. We will all find out."
He sat only long enough to collect his folder, then rose and left by the door nearest the elevators, shaking no hands and offering none to be refused; he nodded once to Elias and walked at the pace of a man with an appointment. By six o'clock his office was clear, one sealed envelope left for the general counsel with his credentials and a list, in his own hand, of the seven matters his successor would need by Friday. Security, braced for an escort nobody had ordered, stood down. He drove out in his own car, in the early dark, his dignity intact, having made no apology that day or in his counsel's evening statement, which thanked the employees and conceded nothing. The absence was noted — and, in its way, respected; a counterfeit coin would have bought less.
The meeting recessed until nine the following morning, the succession business remaining — Elias judging, correctly, that the night would deliver some of it on its own. It did. At seven-forty on Wednesday, December 9, the general counsel received the resignation of Steven Hale as chief financial officer, effective immediately: four courteous sentences — he had served two chief executives and did not propose to serve a third; his accounts were in order; he wished the company, and Clara Brandt personally, well. At nine, Grange Point's counsel confirmed in writing that the term sheet's authority had run to the chief executive who signed it, that its accountable-executive clause named him personally, and that Grange Point recognized no successor signatory. The term sheet lapsed, by its terms — nine hundred million dollars, gone with a signature's authority.
The meeting reconvened at nine-fifteen, one chair emptier and, somehow, one fuller: the empty chair was Hale's, and the full one was the chairman's, where Elias Brandt sat again.
"The succession," he said. "The meeting will come to order."
What followed was brief, because it had been arranged beforehand in Elias's office — Girard and Briggs and counsel present, Clara summoned last, so she would hear the condition before the offer.
The board voted first to name Elias Brandt interim chair of the board until the annual meeting, Briggs's support recorded and his continued service as a director noted with thanks. Then Elias, in the chair that was formally his again, put the second motion himself.
"The board will consider an interim chief executive. One name has been advanced: Clara Brandt — vice president of operations until her dismissal on November twenty-seventh, which this board finds was within the letter of the authority exercised and outside every other standard this company professes. She knows the plants and the order book. She is known to the investor whose return this company intends to seek, and she is incapable of leaving a sentence unfinished in any document she has ever touched. Before I put the motion, Mr. Girard has a condition, which the plan requires and which I support."
"The plan supports Ms. Brandt's appointment," Girard said. "The floor knows her and trusts her, which is not a small thing this week. But the support comes with a condition, and I want it in the minutes in my words, not summarized. Appointing a founder's granddaughter, in a crisis, by a board her grandfather chairs may be the right decision — I believe it is — but it must not ask anyone to take that on faith, after a month's lesson in what faith and courtesies cost. The condition: that within six months, an independent review of this appointment — its process, its terms, and her performance against the objectives this board sets her — be conducted by a reviewer neither the family nor management selects, and reported to the full board and to the plan. If she is the right appointment, the review will say so, and nobody will have to believe it because a Brandt says it." He looked to the foot of the table. "Ms. Brandt. The condition is the plan's. Do you accept it, on the record?"