Aaron kept a small tally of his own on the refrigerator, under a magnet: days since the request. It was a homeowner's tally, not an investigator's, and that was the point. Other residents, he knew, had asked for less and waited as long. One neighbor had mentioned at the mailbox that she had once requested the pool repair invoices and simply given up. Giving up, he was beginning to see, was part of how the association's finances had stayed unexamined for so long. Most people asked once. Claire asked in writing, and then asked again.
Claire wrote again, citing the covenants and the state statute on nonprofit association records, and asked a narrower question: who had received the Community Safety money, and under what contract?
"How long can they do this?" Aaron asked.
"Longer than they should," Claire said. "But every delay is dated now."
When the records came, six weeks after the first request, they came incompletely. Bank statements had pages missing. Minutes existed for some meetings and not others, and the safety committee appeared mainly as a single approving line. The vendor list named landscaping firms and a pool service, and then, repeated across the year, a name Aaron did not recognize at all.
Sentinel Civic Solutions.
Claire laid the pages in chronological order across the table, the way she laid out any set of documents she intended to understand, and added the figures with a pencil in the margin, checking them twice. Aaron did the addition with her, because some numbers deserved to be arrived at by two people independently.
Over sixty thousand dollars in one year. Paid, in monthly installments and two larger lump sums, to Sentinel Civic Solutions, described in every instance by the same phrase: community monitoring services.
"Sixty thousand," Aaron said. "For what? The pool cameras? Colin walking around with a clipboard?"
"That is what we don't have," Claire said. "There's no contract in what they sent. No scope of work. No deliverables. No reports from Sentinel. For sixty thousand dollars, a vendor normally produces something. Memos. Logs. Patrol reports. There's nothing."
She searched for Sentinel Civic Solutions that evening on her personal laptop. There was no website, no listing describing monitoring services or any services. There was a sparse corporate registration and a registered address that resolved to a mailbox store in a strip mall. The company paid more than sixty thousand dollars of homeowners' money in one year could be reached, so far as the public record showed, through a rented box.
"That could still be a small business," Aaron said. "A guy with a truck."
"A guy with a truck has a phone number that rings somewhere," Claire said. "And the HOA would have his contract. And Marissa, as treasurer, could say what he did for five thousand dollars a month. Why is none of that in the records they were required to give us?"
She photographed every page and listed everything not produced: the Sentinel contract, any Sentinel reports, the missing statement pages, minutes for two meetings referenced as if they existed. An absence, documented carefully, is also a record.
The next morning she called the attorney again, as a homeowner, and gave him the figure, the vendor name, the registered address, and the list of missing documents.
He was quiet a moment.
"Sixty thousand to a mailbox," he said. "With no contract produced."
"Over sixty thousand," Claire said.
"Then my advice changes," he said. "Request a formal audit — an independent audit of the association's books, in writing, through the board and the management company, with your objection noted for the record. And keep everything. If the board refuses an audit of its own money, I want that refusal on paper first."
"He'll say we're attacking the community," Aaron said that night.
"He will," Claire said. She filed a copy of the audit request in the box. "Let him say it to a request for an audit. That's a different sentence than the ones he's been saying on the sidewalk."
Aaron looked at the name again on the statement. Sentinel Civic Solutions. It sounded like safety — the kind of name you chose when you did not want anyone to ask what was behind it.
"Who are they?" he asked.
"I don't know," Claire said. "And as a homeowner, I may not be able to find out. But someone spent our money on them for a year, and no one will show us the paper."
Chapter 11 — The Inspection
The notice arrived on a Tuesday, printed on association letterhead and delivered to every house on the street, and it used the word mandatory three times.
By order of the Hawthorne Ridge Safety Committee, all homes would undergo a home-safety inspection within the following ten days. Inspectors would examine garages, exterior storage areas, and utility rooms for fire hazards, improperly stored materials, and unpermitted equipment. Residents would be assigned a window and were required to provide access. The notice was signed by Colin Maddox as neighborhood safety director. At the bottom, in smaller type, was a sentence Aaron read twice: Residents are advised that refusal to cooperate may be reported to insurers and may affect community insurance premiums.
Claire read it standing in the kitchen, her bag still on her shoulder from work.
"Is there a rule that allows this?" Aaron asked.
"No," Claire said. "The covenants allow inspection of exterior architectural compliance — fences, paint, roofing visible from the street. There is no HOA rule that authorizes entry into homes, garages, or utility rooms. I've checked. It doesn't exist."
"Then he just— announced it."
"He announced it," Claire said, "in the hope that announcement is enough. For most people, it will be."