Ortiz read the recusal twice. When she looked up, her expression had changed.
"You understand most people with your title who walk in here walk in expecting the case to become theirs," she said.
"I know what people with my title expect," Claire said. "Open the box."
Ortiz opened it and worked through it in order, taking notes in a hand that slanted hard to the left. The forged letter she held by its edges. The firm's denial. The fines. The sidewalk notes. The records, the delays, the bank statements with Sentinel repeated down the year. The inspection notice. The penalty. She stopped there.
"Emergency personnel," Ortiz said.
"His words," Claire said. "In writing. The day after my husband asked his people if they had lawful authority to enter our garage and was told they didn't need a license."
Ortiz went on. The gate photographs. The outage log. The camera stills, the covered face, the jacket at the electrical box.
She closed the box. "You have a theory," she said. "I can see the shape of the file. People don't organize paper like this without a theory."
"I'm not offering one," Claire said.
"You think it overlaps with the kind of work you do," Ortiz said. "The forgery. A shell vendor. Sixty thousand dollars."
"I think the HOA is paying a shell company controlled by people tied to the safety committee," Claire said. "I don't know who controls it, where the money goes, or whether Colin is running a fraud or working for one. Everything past that sentence is speculation by an interested party. You have no connection to my bureau. That's worth more to this case than anything I could add."
Ortiz studied her. "But you intend to find out," she said.
"You intend to find out," Claire corrected. "I am a witness."
"That distinction is going to frustrate you," Ortiz said.
"It already does," Claire said.
Ortiz smiled briefly. She asked Aaron to start at the beginning, with the fence, and to leave nothing out because it sounded too small. Aaron talked for the better part of an hour. Claire said almost nothing. Twice, when Ortiz asked a question that belonged to investigation rather than witness account, Claire answered, "That's your call, Detective," and waited.
When they stood to leave, Ortiz kept the box and gave Claire an itemized receipt, because Claire asked for one.
At the door, Ortiz said, "If I'd had your job for seventeen years, I'm not sure I'd have handed that over and signed that paper."
"Then you'd have lost the case in a different way," Claire said. "He's been counting on my title — to frighten the neighbors with, and to hide behind if I ever used it. I won't use it. Investigate him as if I were nobody. If he's done nothing criminal, that will protect him too."
In the car, Aaron said, "You hated that. Signing it. Sitting there."
"Yes," Claire said.
"You did it anyway in the first five minutes."
"That's when it had to be done," she said. "Before I knew whether she'd take it seriously. A recusal you sign after you've seen which way the wind blows isn't a recusal. It's a strategy."
Chapter 15 — Who Colin Maddox Is
Ortiz did not call for nine days, and Claire did not call her.
That was the recusal working, and it cost Claire something every day. At dinner she would catch herself looking at her phone and set it down. Once, starting a sentence with "If she's doing her job, she'll have pulled the—" she stopped and asked him about a bridge inspection instead. She was a witness. Witnesses wait.
When Ortiz did call, she asked them to come in to hear things directly, not from the neighborhood. Ortiz had a file of her own now, thinner than the box, and a legal pad covered in her leftward hand.
"I started with who your neighbor is," she said. "Because everything in your box depends on the authority he claims, and I wanted to know whether any of it was ever real."
"It isn't," Claire said. It was not a question.
"It isn't," Ortiz agreed. "Colin Maddox has never been a sworn police officer. Not in North Carolina, not anywhere I've been able to find, and I've looked where those records live. No academy, no certification, no department. The law-enforcement past he refers to — the work he says he can't discuss — does not exist in any form I can verify."
She turned a page.
"What exists is private security. Brief work, years ago, in Arizona and then in Nevada. Guard work — a uniform and a radio and no powers beyond any other citizen's. He was dismissed from two separate security employers." Ortiz looked up. "Both dismissals were for the same conduct: impersonating law enforcement during unauthorized traffic stops. He was pulling drivers over, in a vehicle fitted to suggest authority, and conducting stops he had no right to conduct. Once he detained a driver for nearly half an hour before a real trooper happened on the scene."
Aaron thought of the SUV at the bend, unlit, and the lights behind its grille. A man did not need to switch them on if their shape was enough.
"Was he prosecuted?" Claire asked.