"It was," Eli nodded, his eyes darkening. "Mr. Nathan believed that letter. He grieved terribly — he told me he wept all night, blaming himself for not coming sooner, for leaving you children to live on strangers' charity. The children listened in silence. Despite herself, Lily pictured it: a big, lonely man in a lamplit room in a faraway city, holding a letter he believed, weeping for children he had never met. The image hurt in a strange new way — not the old ache of abandonment, but the sharper pain of knowing how much love had been waiting for them all along, held back by a wall of lies. But then... then he looked at the letter more closely."
Eli went on, his voice full of admiration: "Mr. Nathan is a careful man. He realized the handwriting didn't match that of the neighbor he'd once met. He turned the paper over and over, and found something: in the lower corner of the page, the embossed impression of a brand — the Double R ranch brand. What ordinary neighbor writing a letter by hand would have ranch-branded paper?"
"Victor Hale," Silas ground out through clenched teeth. "It had to be him. He works at the Double R — he has the ranch's paper."
"Mr. Nathan thought so too," Eli said. "That very night he saddled up and rode for Copper Flats. He went house to house, asking everyone. And he discovered the terrible truth: no family had taken you in at all. Three children had been turned out into the street, living rough by the roadside for weeks. The boarding-house keeper — Mrs. Maren — told him someone had intercepted every letter sent to Mr. Nathan's house."
Lily listened, every word of Eli's like a knife across her heart, yet also like a soothing balm. Uncle Nathan had not abandoned them. He had been deceived — cruelly, and with calculation.
"When Mr. Nathan learned the truth," Eli said, his voice dropping, "I've never seen him like that. He stood in the middle of the road, shaking, then drove his fist into a wall until his knuckles bled. He shouted, 'They're only children! How could anyone do this to them!' Then he turned to me, eyes bloodshot, and said, 'Eli, take the fastest horse in the stable and ride for Copper Flats now. Find Thomas's children. Find them no matter what. Before it's too late.'"
"Before it's too late," Lily repeated, her voice small as a whisper.
"He was afraid..." Eli hesitated, "afraid that you children were... were gone. Afraid he'd come too late — the way he came too late for his own brother."
Silas laid a hand on Eli's shoulder. "Young man, you've done well. But tell me — where is Nathan now?"
"He's still on the road," Eli answered. "After sending me off, he mounted up himself and rode the other way to search. He said, 'Two men searching cover twice the ground.' He's been riding for days now between the two towns, no sleep, no rest, following every lead, questioning every traveler. Meeting your party here was pure luck — I was on my way back to Copper Flats when I spotted your wagon from afar."
Jonah, who had been listening in silence all this while, suddenly spoke up, his voice carrying the solemnity of a little old man: "Mr. Eli, is Uncle Nathan... is he like our papa?"
Eli smiled and ruffled the boy's hair. "Very like him, son. Tall, quiet, with the same sad eyes your father had. And... just as stubborn. He quarreled with your father years ago over something, and the two brothers barely spoke after. But I've heard it said that some nights he sits up writing letters to your father that he never sends."
Lily froze. "He... writes letters to my father?"
"Mm-hm. A whole box of unsent letters. He told me once, when he'd had too much whiskey: 'Eli, you know what? The thing I regret most in life isn't quarreling with Thomas — it's letting my pride stop me from making peace with him while there was still time.'"
Those words flowed like warm water into Lily's long-frozen heart. Uncle Nathan was no cold, indifferent stranger. He was a brother weighed down with remorse, an uncle who had wept believing his niece and nephews were safe — and then suffered a hundred times worse upon learning the truth.
"But..." Lily bit her lip, asking the question that had tormented her for weeks: "Why didn't he come sooner? Why didn't he ride to Copper Flats himself from the start, instead of believing a letter?"
Eli was silent for a long while. Prairie wind swept past, lifting the hem of his cloak.
"Because someone spent weeks," he said slowly, each word heavy as stone, "making him believe there were no children left to find. That man didn't just send one forged letter. He had rumors spread all over San Antonio that the Calloway family in Copper Flats was 'all settled,' that some distant relatives had taken you children in. Every time Mr. Nathan made up his mind to ride out, some fresh piece of news made him hesitate. It was a carefully laid trap, Lily. And Mr. Nathan — a grieving, remorseful man — walked straight into it."
Eli paused, looking down at his calloused hands. "The morning he discovered the truth, I found him sitting alone in the stable, holding the forged letter in one hand, the other clenched so tight it bled. The lantern had burned low, and his shadow stretched long across the straw. He didn't look up when I came in — just sat there turning that paper over and over, as if by staring at it long enough he could undo the weeks it had stolen from him. He said nothing for a long while, then suddenly stood, saddled his own horse with his own hands — something he never does — and said to me in a hoarse voice: 'Go bring my brother's children home, Eli. Wherever they are, even if you have to turn the whole of Texas upside down.' I'd never seen him like that. Like a man who'd just found again what he thought he'd lost forever."