The Lies That Separated Us and the Truth That Brought Us Home

Chapter 23

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“Do you ever wish you hadn't found out?”

Eleanor considered the question. “I wish the people who knew had told us the truth before it hurt so many people. But I don't wish I had stayed ignorant.”

“What if the truth changes everything?”

“It already has.”

Sophie looked down at her hands. “What if the other girl hates us? What if she thinks we stole her life?”

“Then we listen to her. We don't decide what she should feel.”

“And if she wants nothing to do with us?”

“Then we respect that too.”

Sophie nodded, but Eleanor could see how much the uncertainty frightened her. For twenty-four years, Sophie had believed her story began in a hospital room with a mother who loved her. Now she had to consider that another child might have been taken from that same room, and that the two of them had been made into strangers by a decision neither had chosen.

Margaret Ellis lived in a narrow house on a quiet lane, with a small garden crowded by rosemary and climbing roses. A police vehicle was already parked outside. Reed's officers had checked the property and found no sign of forced entry.

The nurse opened the door before they knocked.

She was in her late seventies, with silver hair and a straight-backed posture that suggested a lifetime of refusing to be hurried. Her gaze settled on Eleanor.

“You look like your mother,” she said.

Eleanor stiffened. “You knew Margaret?”

“I knew her as a patient’s relative. She was difficult, but she was not careless. She never forgot a face.”

Margaret Ellis stepped aside and let them enter.

Her sitting room was crowded with books and framed photographs. On the mantel stood a small silver clock and a picture of a young woman in a nurse's uniform. Eleanor recognized the old hospital architecture in the background.

“That's St. Catherine's,” Sophie said.

“Yes,” Margaret replied. “I was proud of that place once.”

She led them to a dining table and placed a brown envelope in front of Peter.

“I kept this because I knew one day someone would need it. I should have spoken sooner.”

“Why didn't you?” Reed asked.

“Because I was threatened. Then I was paid. Later, I was ashamed. There is no noble explanation.”

Eleanor looked at the envelope. “Does it show which baby was mine?”

“It shows which baby was assigned to you. Whether that assignment was changed before discharge is another matter.”

Margaret opened the envelope. Inside was a thin carbon copy of a nursery log, with handwritten entries and several signatures. She pointed to three lines.

“Here are the twins in the adjoining cots. Baby E and Baby L. And here is the third infant, entered under the name of a woman called Catherine Rowe.”

“Was Catherine Rowe real?” Peter asked.

Margaret shook her head. “No. We searched the admissions register. There was no woman by that name. Dr. Voss said the mother had been transferred from another hospital and that the paperwork would follow. It never did.”

“Who signed the transfer?” Reed asked.

Margaret pointed to a line at the bottom of the page.

The signature was clear.

**M. Whitmore.**

Eleanor felt the room grow cold.

“Margaret signed the transfer herself?”

“Yes. She came to the ward shortly after midnight. She said the baby was a family responsibility and that no one was to interfere.”

“Why would she take a child who wasn't hers?”

Margaret Ellis looked at Eleanor for a long moment.

“Because the third baby was not a stranger to her. It was her grandchild.”

Peter leaned forward. “Whose child?”

The nurse closed her eyes.

“Matthew's.”

Eleanor stared at her.

“Matthew had a child?”

“Before the boating accident. A little boy. His mother died shortly after giving birth. Margaret arranged for the baby to be placed with a family she trusted. But when Matthew disappeared, she became afraid the child would be used to challenge the inheritance.”

Sophie whispered, “The third baby was my cousin.”

“Your uncle's son,” Margaret said. “And he was taken from the hospital before anyone could register him properly.”

Reed studied the log. “Do you know where he went?”

Margaret shook her head. “I only know the name written on the envelope Dr. Voss carried away.”

“What name?”

She looked toward the window, as if checking whether someone might be listening.

“Oliver.”

The name settled over the table.

Peter looked at Reed. “Then Owen Calder may not be the child we think he is.”

Margaret Ellis nodded slowly. “No. The boy raised by the Calders was not Matthew's son. He was one of the girls from the nursery.”

Eleanor looked at Sophie. The world seemed to tilt once more.

“Then where is Matthew's son?”

Margaret reached into the envelope and removed one final sheet. It was a photocopy of a letter, its edges stained by age.

News in the same category

The Lies That Separated Us and the Truth That Brought Us Home

45 Part