The next lead was Greyhaven.
For the first time, they were not simply searching for someone who might be dead. They were searching for a man who might still be waiting to tell them why he had disappeared.
Greyhaven was a small island off the Northumberland coast, reached by a causeway that disappeared beneath the tide twice a day. The Whitmore cottage stood above a narrow harbour, its slate roof dark against the sea. From the road it looked abandoned. The garden had grown wild, the windows were shuttered, and a rusted bicycle lay on its side beside the gate.
Reed's team arrived before them and secured the property. A local officer confirmed that the electricity account had been paid in cash until eleven months earlier. Deliveries had continued after that, though the names on the receipts changed.
“Someone wanted the cottage to look empty,” Peter said.
“Or someone wanted us to believe Matthew had been here,” Reed replied.
Eleanor stood at the gate. The wind carried the smell of salt and wet stone. She had not visited Greyhaven since she was a young bride. Daniel had brought her once, laughing as he tried to light a fire in the old kitchen. Matthew had been there too, quiet and watchful, standing at the edge of the harbour as though he could hear something beneath the waves.
A constable emerged from the house.
“We found signs of recent occupation. Fresh ash in the stove, food in the pantry, and a bed that has been slept in. No one is inside.”
“Any documents?” Reed asked.
“Some letters. Most have been burned.”
They entered the cottage. The front room contained a table, two chairs and a bookshelf. A small radio sat beside the window. On the mantel was a photograph of three young men standing beside a boat. Eleanor recognised Daniel and Matthew. The third man was Richard Hale.
She picked it up.
“Richard was here.”
Peter examined the back. “The date is written underneath. Three weeks after Matthew's supposed accident.”
Reed looked at the photograph. “That places Richard here while the family believed Matthew was dead.”
“Perhaps he came to make sure,” Hannah said.
“Or perhaps he helped him disappear,” Oliver replied.
Sophie opened a drawer and found a bundle of tide charts. Several dates had been circled in pencil. Beside one, someone had written: *Low water — north rocks.*
A narrow staircase led to a loft. Oliver went up first, followed by a constable. A moment later he called down.
“There is a room up here.”
The loft had been divided by a wooden partition. Behind it stood a narrow bed, a desk and a cabinet. On the desk lay a notebook with a black cover. The first page contained a single sentence:
*If Daniel has found the children, then I have run out of time.*
The handwriting was unfamiliar to Eleanor, but Peter recognised it.
“Matthew,” he said.
The notebook was full of entries, some only a few lines long. It described meetings with Catherine, the birth, the disappearance of the baby, and a series of attempts to contact Daniel. Matthew had believed Richard was arranging the false records, but he had also suspected Margaret of making the original decision.
One entry was dated five years earlier:
*Richard says the boy is safe. He says he has been raised by a family who can give him a future. I asked to see him. Richard refused. He said if I came near him, the child would be moved again. I have become a ghost to protect a son who may never know I exist.*
Oliver sat on the edge of the bed.
“He knew,” he whispered. “He knew I was out there.”
Eleanor placed a hand on his shoulder. “He was trying to keep you safe.”
“That's what everyone says.”
“Sometimes they were wrong. But it doesn't mean they didn't love you.”
He turned the page. A folded map slipped out. It showed the island's northern shore and marked a small building near the rocks, labelled *signal hut*. Beneath it was an address in the village on the mainland.
“Could be another hiding place,” Reed said.
A constable called from downstairs. They had found a second photograph in the kitchen, tucked behind a loose panel. It showed Matthew standing with a child of about six. The boy's face had been scratched away, but the child's coat bore a small embroidered star.
Oliver touched the photograph.
“I had a coat like that,” he said. “At the Calders' house. There was a star sewn inside the pocket. Mrs. Calder said she made it for me.”
The photograph did not prove anything, but it gave them a reason to keep looking.